To prevent Alan from seeing Sarah, Reva knocks him out with the car’s hood. Reva runs into the church with Sarah, looking for Jon. But as soon as Josh walks in he recognizes the baby. Reva tells Josh everything and he promises to keep her secret. Reva and Josh agree to try to convince Jon to stay in Springfield with Sarah and fight Alan with his family’s support. Jon sees Josh and is about to hit him over the head, but Reva stops him and they try to convince him to stay to no avail. Later, Alan spies Sarah’s doll. Rescued and dazed, Lizzie is in shock to see Jonathan alive. When Jon tells Lizzie that he lived, but Sarah died in the car crash, she grows infuriated and rails at him. Bill helps Lizzie up and figures out her plan to come to the cabin and get pregnant. Lizzie pulls away from him, too focused on Sarah. As we see Jon, holding Sarah, looking through the window, conflicted. The judge agrees to marry Marina and Cyrus today, but we see Cyrus isn’t so thrilled with the idea. Harley realizes that Marina put Remy up to pretending to be immigration so Cyrus would marry Marina. Marina begs Harley to not rat her out, and let her tell Cyrus on her own. After Marina tells Cyrus partial truths, Harley finally comes clean with Cyrus and tells him she wants to take the risk of being with him. He tells her he’s tired of her flip-flopping. Later, Marina comes home only to find Cyrus’s things are missing.
Reva arrives at the farmhouse. Josh answers the door, and steps outside to talk to Reva privately. He asks Reva about Jonathan's whereabouts, saying that he hoped Jonathan would decide to let Lizzie and others know that he is alive. Reva tells Josh that Jonathan never said he would do that. Cassie joins Reva and Josh outside and asks Reva why she came by. Reva answers that she thought they all might go to the memorial together. Cassie tells her that she has shed so many tears at Tammy's memorial that she won't be going to baby Sarah's memorial, then goes back inside. Josh expresses to Reva that he doesn't really want to perform the service for someone he knows is still alive. Reva says that she thinks Jonathan may show up at the memorial with Sarah because he tends to like to make a grand entrance.
Alan arrives at the farmhouse, asking Josh if Reva told him about how she left and injured Alan by the side of the road. Josh notices the doll in Alan's hand and asks if it is for the memorial service. Alan responds, saying that he found it near where Reva hit him on the head with her car hood, then asks Reva if it looks familiar. Reva knows that it is Sarah's but creates a story and tells Alan that she doesn't know anything about it. Alan then tells Josh that he has some "talking points" that he wants him to read at the service, trying to ensure that no one takes the opportunity to point fingers at someone else. Josh says that he can mange just fine and doesn't need Alan's talking points. Alan tells Josh that if he doesn't respect his wishes in this private occasion, then his services will not be needed. Josh is happy to be relieved from this duty, and goes inside.
Alan and Reva are now alone. Alan says he can tell that Reva and Josh are up to something and asks what it is. Just then Bill arrives and helps Reva get out of that moment. Alan tells Reva to get a good lawyer for rendering him unconscious, then sarcastically adds "Oh, that's right. You sleep with one, don't you?" After Alan leaves, Bill, in his unique sassy style, tells Reva that he knows there are dead people walking around Springfield and that her son looked pretty darn good to him. When Reva responds by asking him what he knows, it confirms Bill's suspicion that Reva knew Jonathan was alive all along. He then discovers that Josh also knows but that Cassie doesn't. Reva and Bill have a heated exchange about Jonathan - Bill thinks Jonathan should stay away, and Reva wants Bill to stay out of it and not tell anyone that Jonathan is alive. Bill's position stems from a desire to protect Lizzie from being hurt by Jonathan again. Reva tells Bill that she will support whatever decision Jonathan makes.
Josh reads a note that Cassie left on the table that says she has taken RJ and Will to the park. At the park, Cassie leaves the boys to play while she goes to get them some hot chocolate at a nearby concession stand. Will tries to get RJ to play soccer, but RJ isn't interested in playing with Will and tells him to go play by himself. Will taunts RJ by saying that he is afraid that Will might beat him in a game. RJ snaps back that he isn't afraid of anything. Will takes the ball from RJ and tosses it. It lands on the other side of the fence, right onto some railroad tracks. RJ tries to get Will to go get it, saying he's the one that threw it there. Will tells RJ to get it since he's not afraid of anything. RJ realizes the spot he's in to prove that he's not afraid, and climbs over the fence. As he steps inside the railroad tracks to get the ball, his foot gets stuck. RJ asks Will to help him. But Will just looks at him and says nothing. RJ now hears a train coming and tells Will to go get his mother. Will hears the train whistle, yet does nothing and says nothing. He just looks at RJ with a devilish grin. Cassie returns with the hot chocolate and sees RJ on tracks. She hears RJ's cries for help and realizes that he's stuck. She jumps across the fence and tried to pull him off but realizes that his boot is wedged between the rails. She quickly unties his bootlaces and takes his foot out of the boot, then picks him up and carries him to a safe place seconds before the train passes that same spot. She is happy that he is ok and hugs him. Then she scolds him for being on the tracks when he knew better. RJ tells Cassie that Will threw his new ball on the tracks, and then dared him to go get it. Then RJ says he's leaving to go home and walks away. An angry Cassie walks over to Will and scolds him for his actions while grabbing him roughly. Then she quickly stops and hugs him, apologizing, and then says they will work it out.
Cassie returns home with Will. Josh asks what happened that caused RJ to come home alone and missing a boot. Cassie recounts the story about what happened at the park, downplaying the seriousness of it. But even she is shaken by it, and says that she has come to a decision. Josh thinks this means that Cassie will now allow Will to be placed in the special home for troubled kids. But Josh shows a shocked look on his face when he hears Cassie say that she thinks he and RJ should move out. She explains that she thinks Will needs more time to deal with his issues. Josh tries to convince her that this is best left to the professionals and that the best treatment for him would be the home for troubled kids. They argue back and forth about this. Then Josh tells Cassie that Jonathan and Sarah are alive, and that Reva knew all along. This allows Cassie to realize why Reva didn't mourn the same Cassie did and why Reva didn't want a memorial service for Jonathan. Cassie says she's happy that Reva didn't lose her child.
Jonathan is in the room that he and Tammy shared at the Beacon looking for Sarah's doll as he is preparing to leave for the airport. Tammy's spirit appears to him and tells him that he can make things right again. She adds that he knows what to do. Jonathan knows that means letting Lizzie know that Sarah is alive, and he doesn't want to do that. He is afraid of losing Sarah if Lizzie and the Spauldings find out about her. Tammy tells him that when Sarah grows up and starts asking questions and realizes that Jonathan kept Lizzie out of her life, he may lose Sarah anyway. Jonathan struggles with these thoughts but prepares to leave as planned anyway.
Lizzie is at the Spaulding mansion standing by the egg-shaped memorial statue that Alan had created not long after her 'death'. Lizzie is thinking about Sarah and wondering aloud about difficult it will be to get through this day. Bill arrives with flowers saying he is there to support her today. Lizzie tells him she doesn't need his help and that she is upset, blaming him for chasing away Jonathan. Bill responds that Jonathan left on his own and adds that he thinks Lizzie is better off with Jonathan gone. Lizzie tells Bill to leave, and then walks away.
Beth arrives without Rick. Appearing to be sincere, Alan asks her where Rick is, knowing he arranged for Rick to be "on call" at the hospital. Beth responds that he was needed at the hospital. Alex asks Alan for a private moment. She then tells him that his chance with Beth has passed and that he should accept that. Alan replies that sometimes relationships can be renewed again. He then excuses himself to comfort Lizzie. Then Beth and Lillian do the same. Alan tells everyone that it's time to begin the ceremony. Lizzie asks where Josh is. Alan informs her and everyone that Josh will not be presiding over the service today, and then adds that he will be the one to lead the service. Everyone takes his or her seat.
Alan begins the memorial by saying that they are there to remember Sarah Spaulding. Suddenly, Reva appears and firmly corrects him, saying "Randall - that would be Sarah Randall." Alan offers Reva to join them, but she rejects the offer and tells him to continue. Alan goes on and the words ring harshly in Lizzie's ear. Finally she stands up and walks away, telling Alan she won't listen to him justify what he did. Lizzie retreats to her room in the mansion and cries in her bed. Then she hears the sounds of a baby, and lifts her head to look in the direction of the sound. She sees baby Sarah's head peaking from around a dressing screen and says, "If this is a dream, I don't want to wake up." Then slowly more of Sarah is revealed, until finally Jonathan is shown holding her and walking toward Lizzie. Lizzie now realizes that her baby is alive and bursts into joyful tears that come from deep within a mother's love. Jonathan hands Sarah into Lizzie's waiting arms. Lizzie lovingly pulls her daughter close and holds her tenderly. Mother and child are finally reunited!
Alan is knocking on Lizzie's door to see if she is ok after leaving the memorial crying. Lizzie hands Sarah to Jonathan while she deals with Alan. Alan starts off sounding like he's trying to extend an olive branch. Lizzie is angry about the earlier events and their conversation turns into one negative comment after another being made by both. He invites Lizzie to the healing getaway that he has planned, but she declines the offer. She also informs Alan that she is not pregnant. Alan retorts harshly that she can't get anything right. Lizzie ends the conversation and goes back to hold her daughter. Jonathan tells Lizzie that he hopes she can see now why he had to take Sarah away - to protect her from Alan.
Alan returns to where Beth is in the mansion and continues to try to get her to go away with him. Since Rick and Lizzie are not going, Alan tells Beth it will be just the two of them. Beth tells him she's not going on that trip with just him. He reminds her of how much she loved it there and shows her a picture. She looks at it remembering fond memories, and tells him that he has to stop living in a dream world. He responds to her by warmly saying, "Some dreams never die." Then he places the picture down and walks away, leaving her with her thoughts and memories. Lillian looks on from across the room, shocked to see Beth's contemplating facial expressions.
Lizzie now lets Jonathan know how angry she is that he let her believe that Sarah was dead. He tries to explain that he had to do it to protect Sarah, but all Lizzie can think of is the grief she endured alone. She tells him she is not afraid of Alan and she finds the strength of a mother fighting for her child and she find her Spaulding voice as she takes control of the situation. Bill hears the arguing and rushes into the room to assist Lizzie. Bill tells Jonathan to leave or call security. The Lizzie says with conviction that she'll stop that plane right on the runway if he tries to leave with Sarah. Jonathan can see that he can't win and opts to leave but only for now. He faces off with Bill as the men try very hard to keep their self-control. Jonathan leaves, saying he'll be back. An elated Lizzie is thrilled to have her daughter in her arms and happy with the knowledge that she doesn't have to let her go, at least not tonight.
Lizzie and Bill get Sarah settled into Lizzie's old room at the Spaulding mansion. It's nighttime, and Lizzie tries to quiet fussy Sarah. She appears to give Bill the brush off, saying that Sarah needs bonding time with her mother. Bill expresses concern that, if he leaves, then Jonathan might return. Lizzie thinks Jonathan took Bill's threat about Granddad seriously. Bill leaves. Alone and distraught, Lizzie tells Sarah that she doesn't have to cry because her mother is right there with her.
Outside the Spaulding mansion, Jonathan speaks to figment Tammy. She commends his decision to let Lizzie know that Sarah is alive. This is the first night that Jonathan has ever spent without Sarah. He tells Tammy that he misses both her and Sarah. He's anxious to enter the mansion before Bill returns. He plans to leave for Canada this night with baby Sarah. Curious about his behavior, figment Tammy asks him what is in his bag. Hesitantly, he says that, even though Tammy is only imaginary, he still doesn't want to tell her what he's about to do. He heads toward the house.
Inside the house, Jonathan knocks on Lizzie's bedroom door. She refuses to let him in, threatening to tell her grandfather that he is alive if he doesn't leave. Jonathan reminds Lizzie that Sarah is their daughter. He urges her to let him in because he knows how to stop Sarah's wailing. Lizzie lets Jonathan into the room, and he shows her how to rub Sarah's belly and hum. Lizzie wants to know more of his tricks to help her get her motherly routine together.
Jonathan confirms that her grandfather is out of the country. He suggests that he and Lizzie take Sarah to the Bauer cabin and spend the next day together getting reacquainted. He says when they get back, they can deal with Alan. Lizzie takes that to mean that he's staying in town. She is concerned that he'll leave and take Sarah. He swears he wouldn't do that to her. Just then, Bill shows up.
Jonathan announces that he and Lizzie are just about to leave with Sarah. Lizzie invites Bill to come along on the cabin trip. Jonathan protests, but Lizzie says having Bill there will make her more comfortable. Later, while Lizzie makes a phone call, Bill and Jonathan load the car. Jonathan is rude to Bill, telling him that he did his hero routine yesterday and saying he can leave. Bill plans to stick around and monitor the situation with Lizzie and Sarah to see how it all plays out. Jonathan says he already explained to Lizzie that he wouldn't take Sarah away. Bill is curious about why Jonathan would stay in town. He wonders if Jonathan wants to stay because of Lizzie. Jonathan assures Bill that Lizzie is not the reason. Seeming to shake off the idea of jealousy, Bill says that he didn't think Lizzie would be the reason. Tauntingly, Jonathan reminds Bill that he was once married to Lizzie. Jonathan says, "If I wanted that, I could have that."
Bill chuckles uneasily, saying that he just wants to make sure Jonathan doesn't hurt her. Jonathan comments that Bill has not treated Lizzie very well either. Jonathan tells Bill that he is welcome to have Lizzie; however, Jonathan reminds Bill that he is the one who has a real bond with Lizzie. That bond is Sarah.
Meanwhile, inside, Lizzie explains recent developments to Gus. She seeks his help because Sarah belongs with her, not Jonathan. After Gus absorbs the fact that Jonathan and Sarah are alive, he agrees with Lizzie that she should not have to lose her baby. He'll help her keep her daughter for good.
Outside, Lizzie finds Jonathan at the car and wonders where Bill is. Jonathan tells her Bill went to get food. Jonathan urges Lizzie to dump Bill because they do not need a third wheel on their trip. Bill jogs up with a bag of groceries and a folder. Even though Bill says the folder doesn't concern Jonathan, Jonathan looks inside it. He finds plans for Springfield's redevelopment project. Outskirts Bar will be demolished as a result of the construction. Lizzie seems surprised by the news and Bill asks why Jonathan even cares. Jonathan presses Bill to learn what will be constructed in place of the bar. "Anything I want," Bill says. Lizzie asks Jonathan if he is okay. Jonathan nods, calling Outskirts a dump and saying Bill can do whatever he wants with it.
As everyone else gets into the car, Jonathan announces that he will drive. Clandestinely, he checks his bag and examines a small round jar of clear liquid. For a moment he glimpses Figment Tammy close to the car. She looks concerned about what Jonathan could be planning.
Lizzie, Sarah, Bill, and Jonathan arrive at the Bauer cabin. Jonathan becomes defensive when Lizzie questions him about whether he has warm clothes for Sarah and about what type of stroller he uses for her. Bill says the stroller looks like junk. Jonathan says that just because it's not designer, doesn't mean it isn't good. He says that he may not have raised Sarah the way Lizzie would have, but together, he and Sarah did "damn well." Lizzie replies that she isn't criticizing him. Lizzie gets a phone call from Gus. She pretends that it's Beth on the line. Jonathan goes outside to get more things from the car.
On the phone, Gus asks Lizzie to keep Jonathan in town for as long as she can. Gus is in the process of building a legal case for her to get custody of Sarah. Gus advises her to find out everything she can about Jonathan's activities since he's been away from Springfield. He tells her that they might have to play dirty. Lizzie says that she's ready. Once Lizzie's off the phone, she tells Bill that she'll be fine if she is alone with Jonathan. She asks him to leave. Bill believes that, if he leaves, then nothing will stop Jonathan from taking Sarah. Lizzie alludes to a plan that she has, saying that it wasn't really Beth on the phone with her earlier. In order to work her plan, she needs to be alone with Jonathan to loosen him up. Bill worries, but Lizzie assures him that she knows what she's doing. Bill agrees to leave.
Jonathan returns inside and says he finds it odd that Bill left. Lizzie explains that Bill finally understood that they needed time alone to bond with Sarah. Jonathan offers her wine, but Lizzie claims that she stopped drinking when she thought she was pregnant. She says maybe she'll have it later. Jonathan murmurs under his breath, "definitely later."
Lizzie tries to build trust with Jonathan and find dirt on his past. Lizzie listens to Jonathan relates details about how difficult it was moving around and keeping Sarah safe from Alan. He couldn't hold down a well paying job. It was hard to keep food on the table. He felt that he didn't even know how to raise a child. He had one relationship with Aubrey, which didn't work out. He felt that she was at risk just by being with him. Sadly, he adds, "And she wasn't Tammy..."
Lizzie fondly speaks Tammy's name. Jonathan asks to talk about something else. Lizzie says she knows that he misses her, and admits she really misses her, too. Jonathan becomes incensed, raging that Tammy's death is partially Lizzie's fault. With his finger in her face, he dares her to deny it. Upset, Lizzie admits that she also blames herself. She knew exactly what she was doing when she went to her grandfather, pleading for help. She says she just closed her eyes and pretended not to know what Alan would do, but admits that she did know.
Later, Lizzie realizes that Sarah has a fever. Lizzie asks to take her to Cedars, but Jonathan refuses because Alan owns half the hospital and he'd find out that Sarah's alive if they went there. He frantically asks Lizzie to check Sarah's temperature and he goes outside. Figment Tammy appears and seems to know what Jonathan fears that Sarah's fever means. He asks Tammy what to do. Lizzie comes outside. She hears him say Tammy's name. Lizzie tries to force him to realize that Tammy isn't there and standing around talking to her isn't going to help. Lizzie, however, is there. She wants him to listen to her opinions about what to do. He tells her to be quiet so he can think. They yell at each other. Lizzie tells him that she's not the airhead she used to be. She has taken charge of her life. She will take charge of this situation also. She stomps inside. He follows her, wondering what she will do. She says she plans to call her uncle Rick. He is a doctor and he hates Alan more than Jonathan does. Rick will not tell Alan the truth about Sarah.
Some time later, Jonathan opens the cabin door. Beth slaps Jonathan in the face and marches into the cabin. She demands to see her grandchild. Rick comes in behind her. With tearful joy, Beth beholds Sarah. Beth, Lizzie, and Rick huddle around the cradle and Jonathan implores Rick to be thorough in his examination. Beth pauses and looks appalled when she sees Lizzie reassuringly clutch Jonathan's hand.
Bill finally makes it back to the Beacon. Outside one of the rooms, Olivia approaches, saying that her staff informed her that a guest wanted to see her. Technically, Bill says he supposes that he's a guest. She asks why he didn't give his name. He said it's because he wanted her to actually show up. He asks her whose room it is that he stands beside. Reception says that there is no name listed on the register. Olivia shrugs to say she doesn't know whose it is. Bill claims that Jonathan is staying in the room. Olivia looks at him quizzically and says that Jonathan is dead. Bill continues, saying that Olivia is a good aunt. She did a favor for her nephew, Jonathan, by harboring him undetected at the Beacon. Olivia says if Bill knows so much, then he doesn't need her. As she leaves, he asks her about Emma. He is surprised that the Spauldings haven't come after Emma, because she is a Spaulding, after all. Bill says he's glad that the Spauldings have never asked him testify in a custody battle where he'd have to be honest. He says that he has a tendency to blab about things, and knows things that might be hurtful to Olivia should a custody case arise. With a pretentious grin on her face, Olivia asks what things. He recalls how Olivia set his father up to take the first drink that knocked him off the wagon of sobriety. He then asks her to let him into Jonathan's room, because he wants to go through Jonathan's things.
Up at the cabin, Rick diagnoses Sarah with a cold. Rick prescribes some medications and Jonathan relaxes, saying, "Good...Good..." From the other side of the room, Beth snaps that it's not good. While they are all glad to know Sarah is alive, she wants to know who gave Jonathan the right to inflict this kind of misery. Beth says that Jonathan needs to be in jail. Rick counters Beth, saying that Jonathan did the right thing. Rick says he believes that Alan is a threat, and adds that when Alan is involved, one must do whatever he has to do to protect his family.
Rick packs his medical bag. He hails Jonathan's actions and says Jonathan deserves a medal for keeping Sarah free from Alan's influence. Rick asks for Beth's understanding. Alan has hurt every person present. Beth doesn't understand. She says she's still upset that they believed the child was dead. Rick and Beth argue, but Beth can't forgive this yet. Beth talks to Lizzie and warns her not to let Jonathan out of her sight. Rick and Beth leave.
Both parents are relieved that Sarah only has a cold, however, Lizzie picked up on how tense Jonathan was. She wonders if something happened to Sarah before. Jonathan admits to Lizzie that Sarah had anemia. He had to get her a bone marrow transplant. Lizzie becomes upset, wondering how he even got a donor. Jonathan tells Lizzie that she was the donor.
Back at the Beacon, Bill and Olivia argue more. Olivia finally caves in. She opens the door to the hotel room. Bill says thanks. Olivia replies that she didn't do anything, and she stalks off. On Jonathan's laptop, Bill finds evidence that Jonathan plans to flee with Sarah this night.
Meanwhile, from the outside window view of the cabin, Lizzie and Jonathan can be seen inside yelling and screaming at each other. Finally Lizzie calms down. Back inside the room, Lizzie says that Jonathan saved Sarah's life. He says that they all did: he, Lizzie and Reva.
Jonathan prods her to have her wine, but Lizzie says she doesn't want to because she is still reeling from learning the truth about her trip with Reva. Jonathan asks if she likes her tattoo. Lizzie shows him the butterfly on her hip. Now that she understands the reason she has it, she says she loves the tattoo. As they talk, Jonathan slips something into Lizzie's wine. He hands her the glass. Holding it, Lizzie confesses that she conferred with Gus about gaining custody of Sarah. She apologizes for mistrusting Jonathan, and says now that she understands everything that Jonathan has done for their daughter, she knows that they both will do whatever it takes to keep Sarah safe. Together, she tells him, they can do anything.
Jonathan toasts to that. Before Lizzie can drink, a knock comes on the door. Bill is there, claiming he left his wallet. He asks Lizzie and Jonathan to look for it. As they do, Bill switches the two wine glasses. Suddenly he claims to have found his wallet. Jonathan asks Bill to leave. Bill notes that the two of them were having drinks. Lizzie promises to tell Bill all about the evening later. Bill hands them their glasses, and stays in the room. As Jonathan and Lizzie drink, Bill mentions that he thought "the two of you" would be gone already. Lizzie says that they aren't in a rush. Bill says that he's talking about Jonathan leaving with Sarah.
Lizzie thinks Bill is off base. Bill asks Jonathan if he's planning to leave with Sarah. Jonathan denies it and says that he thought Bill had a cab to catch. Bill asks Jonathan if he has a plane to catch and produces plane tickets. Jonathan tries to get up, but the effects of the drugs disorient him. Bill reveals that he found a prescription in Jonathan's room. He accuses Jonathan of trying to drug Lizzie and steal away with Sarah. Jonathan stumbles as Lizzie realizes that Bill is telling the truth.
Bill hustles Lizzie and Sarah out of the cabin. Meanwhile, Jonathan falls to the floor. Figment Tammy cradles his head, saying, "I was afraid this would happen." Dazed, Jonathan calls Tammy's name.
Dinah's doctor tells her that she has made great progress on her cognitive tests. She reports that she feels like herself again and that it scares her a little. Billy arrived in time to hear that, and asks her to talk over coffee. He makes it clear that his intentions are honorable and reminds Dinah of his feelings for Vanessa. When Dinah politely declines, Billy suggests that maybe they can do that another time.
Olivia tries to move a couch in her room, but stops when her breathing becomes difficult. Gus and Natalia stop by to see if she needs anything. Gus's phone rings and while he answers it, Natalia makes sure Olivia knows that she and Gus are still making plans for their wedding and that it will happen. Natalia says that she will take Emma for hot chocolate while Gus and Olivia do some paperwork to help Olivia be a top candidate to receive a heart transplant. When Natalia returns, Olivia lets Natalia know that she and Gus had a productive meeting. Gus leaves. After playing with Emma a while, Natalia leaves to pick up more medications for Olivia. Olivia calls Gus and tells him she's feeling dizzy and is having a hard time breathing, as a ploy to get him to come to her while Natalia is away. Natalia has become aware of Olivia's sneaky ways to get Gus's attention. Before Olivia can finish her call to Gus, Natalia returns, takes the phone from Olivia, and tells Gus that she will help Olivia now. Olivia makes it clear that she is still going after Gus. Natalia assures Olivia that she is confident that Gus loves her. Olivia taunts her that Harley used to say that all the time.
At the farmhouse, Cassie talks to the doctor who came to evaluate Will. The doctor tells Cassie that Will is very troubled and needs more than Cassie can provide. Cassie doesn't like that evaluation, and says that she will handle Will herself, then asks the doctor to leave. Will enters the kitchen and asks Cassie for a cookie. Cassie says they need to talk some more to try to fix the problems. Will says that he wants to have a cookie first and then talk. Cassie says no again, and begins to talk to him about the seriousness of what happened at the train tracks. As Cassie is down on her haunches to talk to Will, he pushes her and knocks her backward to the ground. He quickly says he's sorry and she hugs him, saying they will fix this, though she shows concern over what just happened.
Reva and Jeffrey arrive at the Bauer cabin to look for Jonathan. Jeffrey breaks the door down and they enter, calling for Jonathan. They find him passed out on the floor. After they get him to wake, they ask what happened. Jonathan tells them Lizzie took Sarah. Reva thinks that maybe Cassie can help with getting Sarah back. They all leave to go to Cassie's house.
Cassie hears someone at her door, turns to see who it is, and is pleasantly surprised to see Jonathan, with Reva and Jeffrey. She hugs Jonathan tightly and cries, saying she's happy to see him. Jonathan is also happy to see her and to see the farmhouse again. He looks around and everything reminds him of Tammy. Reva explains that Lizzie has Sarah and that they are trying to get the baby back before Alan finds out about her. Cassie says that she'll do whatever she can to help. Jeffrey leaves to continue to work on helping Jonathan. As Will is eavesdropping, he hears Jonathan tell Reva and Cassie how he will do anything to get Sarah back, even kill or die for her. Jonathan stays to babysit Will while the others go to see Lizzie.
Jeffrey sees Dinah on Main Street and asks if she knows where Bill is. When Dinah asks why Jeffrey is looking for Bill, Jeffrey tells her "for kidnapping." Dinah is surprised by this and asks for more information. Jeffrey tells Dinah about Jonathan and Sarah being alive, and how Lizzie has the baby and Jonathan wants Sarah back. Dinah, now questioning her recently diagnosed "improved" cognitive status, isn't sure she can believe that Jonathan and Sarah are alive. Jeffrey convinces her that it's true, but Dinah doesn't know where Bill is. She and Jeffrey exchange digs about each being used as glorified assistants to their 'partners.' Later, Dinah is in her room playing a memory game with pictures of people she knows to build her mental abilities. She finishes this activity, then picks up a picture of Mallet, and holds it close to her fondly.
While babysitting, Will hugs Jonathan and calls him his hero, as Will sees a kindred spirit in Jonathan. Through conversation, Jonathan reveals that his father died after falling off of a boat and drowning. Jonathan tells Will that although they have some similarities, he doesn't want Will to be like him.
Reva and Cassie meet Gus, who is representing Lizzie, at the Spaulding mansion. Cassie makes a strong case for both parents working things out before Alan hears about this and gets his hands on Sarah. Gus agrees, and says he'll do what he can. As Reva and Cassie leave, Reva asks about how things are going with Will. Cassie tells her that she is handling it, and they leave, as Reva's face shows concern. Before they enter the farmhouse again, Reva stops Cassie and asks her if she wants to talk about anything. Cassie seems puzzled by that question. Then Reva says that she saw Josh and RJ with their suitcases. Cassie responds, saying it's nothing. Reva tells her that it didn't look like nothing. Cassie says that it's about Will, and that she's helping him, and that's all she'll say for now.
They enter the house and find Will napping on Jonathan's lap. Jonathan gets up to talk to the two women and to get an update about what happened in their meeting. They all step outside and Jonathan gets the information about the meeting. Gus arrives on official police business. He wants to talk to Reva and asks her if she took Lizzie out of town to have a medical procedure performed on her.
Inside, Will, who had been faking his nap, gets up and gets a book about boats from the shelf. He flips through it for a while. Then he calls Josh. He tells Josh that he misses him and that he wishes they could do something together...like go boating.
Lizzie is trying to calm Sarah, who is crying uncontrollably. Finally, Beth arrives and Lizzie tells her she cannot get Sarah to stop crying. When Beth tries to open the blinds to let in the sun, Lizzie objects because she wants it dark because the baby did not sleep all night. Lizzie says that she tried everything, but Sarah will not stop crying. She wonders if she is sick again but Beth thinks the child misses her father. Lizzie points out that she is Sarah's mother. Wouldn't Sarah know that instinctively? Beth states that for her entire life, Jonathan was Sarah's sole protector, so that is what she is used to. Lizzie says that she hates that Jonathan made her a stranger to her own baby. When Lizzie brings up that he planned on drugging her and skipping town with Sarah, Beth defends him. Lizzie cannot believe that she is taking Jonathan's side over hers. Beth says that she is not but points out how well Jonathan took care of Sarah. He obviously made sacrifices in order to protect her from Alan. Lizzie replies that she is lucky her baby is a Bauer-Alan has no stake in her life. Beth tells Lizzie that she and Jonathan need to work things out, since a child unites two people, whether they like it or not.
Jonathan is in his room at the Beacon trying to call Lizzie when Bill arrives. Jonathan drags Bill inside and demands to know where Lizzie is. Bill offers to help him get inside the Spaulding mansion and get his daughter. Bill makes it clear that he wants Jonathan to take Sarah and go away. Jonathan asks what is in this for Bill, and Bill says he wants to give a relationship with Lizzie a shot and doesn't want a kid in the picture. Disgusted, Jonathan calls Bill a scumbag but accepts his help. Later, Bill gets Jonathan inside the mansion and tells him to stay put while he gets Sarah. Bill rushes out and Jonathan gets suspicious and tries the door. It is locked. Suddenly, two policemen arrive to arrest him. As he is trying to keep from being dragged away, Lizzie arrives, asks what is going on, and tells them to let him go. When they leaves, Lizzie hands him Sarah and tells him that she had no idea what that was about. Jonathan informs her that Bill set him up. Bill returns, sees Jonathan holding Sarah, and demands to know what Jonathan did. Lizzie blasts Bill for his actions since her daughter could be in danger if Alan should learn of Jonathan's arrest. Jonathan is the father of her child and Bill has upset her. Bill tells Lizzie that he convinced Jonathan to come by claiming to help him kidnap Sarah. Shocked at his actions, Lizzie throws Bill out. Later, Lizzie and Jonathan bond over Sarah and promise no more kidnappings.
Beth is on Main Street when she overhears Ava on the phone with Alan telling him that his passport problem is taken care of. It is being sent to his villa on the island. Beth asks Ava when Alan is coming home and Ava says Alan wants to come as soon as possible. Later, Beth tells Rick she needs to take a train to Chicago for a weekend bash with the ladies. When Rick leaves, she calls a man about a boat to San Gabriel.
At the Beacon, a woman wearing a pearl necklace recognizes Cyrus. The woman, who is leaving her room, was one of Alexandra's friends who had her bank account nearly decimated by him. Cyrus apologizes but she flirtatiously dismisses it since she got the money back anyway-and then some-when she divorced her husband. After the woman leaves, Cyrus breaks into her apartment and comes out with a string of pearls. He is caught red handed by Marina. Cyrus says this is what he does; he steals, she lies. He tells her that Harley thinks Marina is pushing for marriage because she does not trust him. Marina denies that and Cyrus admits that both women might be better off without him. Cyrus tells Marina that this is not him-he is not the type of guy who marries and holds a full time job. Marina asks if he would prefer life in prison and then realizes that for him this kind of life is life in prison. Cyrus asks Marina if she was ever the type of woman who lied. He even points out that she was ready to flee with him to Europe . He does not think they can keep it going and Marina agrees. It is the end. Later, as Cyrus is packing his things, Marina wonders when he stopped loving her. Cyrus insists that he never did, and hates that she forced his hand because of her doubts about him. Marina admits that sometimes she wishes she were in that building with him. Cyrus says that is a horrible thing to say and, with tears in her eyes, Marina agrees. Marina brings up the bond that Harley and Cyrus now share, leading Cyrus to look away. That seems to verify Marina's point-he cannot even think about Harley without feeling guilty. Marina asks how he would feel if some man was with her when she was kidnapped, and when they returned Cyrus was suddenly the third wheel. She asks what it is about Harley-is it because she needs him more? Marina tells Cyrus she is going to miss him and states that she thought he was the one. In tears, Cyrus tells her he wishes he could have been.
Marina finds Harley and grills her about what she said to Cyrus. Harley tells Marina that she thinks Cyrus just needs space. Marina tells her aunt to stay out of it. Harley softly replies that she does not know if she can and explains that it is because they live in a small town. Marina does not quite buy that excuse, and tells her again to stay out of it. Later, Frank finds Harley cleaning at the restaurant and asks what is wrong. Coopers clean when they are cornered. Harley denies it and Frank brings up Cyrus's immigration case. He thinks Cyrus is faking the problem to trap Marina into marrying him. Harley tells him he is wrong and soon tells him that it was Marina. Harley explains to Frank that Harley and Cyrus are very close friends, and Marina got jealous and saw Harley as a threat. Frank thinks that is ridiculous, but the look on Harley's face says otherwise. Harley goes on to admit that she may have blurred a few lines. Frank thinks that means that Harley was vulnerable and Cyrus took advantage but Harley says that it was not like that. Harley talks about her panic attacks and how Cyrus knows how to take care of her. He is good to her and for her. As Harley talks about needing Cyrus, Frank gets the impression that she does not regret having feelings for Cyrus. He starts to go and find Marina but Harley promises that she will fix this and heads off. Harley goes to talk to Marina but she is gone now; only Cyrus is there packing his things. Harley tells him that he cannot move out. Cyrus states that is off to plunder and pillage so he cannot mess up any more lives. Harley insists that he and Marina can work things out. She cannot take the thought of both he and Marina being miserable. She insists that if he leaves Marina, he might miss his one chance at happiness. Harley insists that Marina is crazy about him. She states that he could get her back. She tells Cyrus to send Marina flowers, do anything to make it work. Cyrus states that Marina is done fighting. Marina left. As Harley insists that he has to fight for Marina, Cyrus pulls Harley into a passionate kiss.
Marina goes to Company to meet with Mallet. She snaps at him when he rags on her about her extra long lunch hour and then gains control of herself and insists that they get to work. She states that she is not the kind of girl to blow her career over some guy. Mallet gently asks her what Cyrus did. Mallet takes an upset Marina outside and she notes that everyone warned her about Cyrus but she would not listen. Mallet tells Marina she's too hard on herself-just like her aunt. Marina gets a tad uncomfortable at the mention of Harley. Mallet tells Marina that she deserves better. She will find somebody better. Marina wonders if she just did and kisses Mallet.
