A worried Tabitha keeps her eyes and ears on Timmy as he searches for the yellow brick road to the wizard who can help him and Julian get their hands on the demon' horn. Little Timmy finds help in the form of a sneaky, suspicious munchkin who takes Timmy's cash and then whispers the only way to reach the wizard. Timmy then dresses as Dorothy while Julian dons a lion's costume. Finding trouble in the hideous form of the living dead, Kay seeks help from Father Lonigan while Zombie Charity goes ahead with her deadly plan for Miguel. Meanwhile, Miguel remains in the throes of Zombie Charity. Kay finally breaks away from the corpses and douses a stunned Zombie Charity with holy water, stopping her from making love.
When Zombie Charity sees the scroll and realizes what Timmy is up to, she conjures up a dangerous scarecrow to deal with her "little buddy." As Zombie Charity relishes Timmy's upcoming death, Tabitha pleads for her friend's life. Nick aims his gun at a reunited Brian and Diana and demands his money. Unimpressed by the gun, Brian jumps Nick, throws the gun into the water and a fight ensues. As Brian orders him to set sail, Nick insists that Sheridan pay him what she owes him and later vows to hurt Brian permanently. Nick later remembers who Diana is. At the hospital Ivy worries about Ethan being on the run with Theresa. Rebecca tries to reassure Ivy that Theresa's medical predicament will soon send Ethan back to them. However, she does refuse to tell Ivy where the fugitives are.
As the "Cowardly Julian" attempts to flee, Timmy is menaced by the sinister scarecrow. Nick wracks his brains to remember where he's seen "Diana" before. Rebecca reminds Ivy why she can't tell anyone that Ethan and Theresa are at the cabin. Meanwhile, the suspicious prison guards question Eve about her missing patient. Beth explains to Hank how Theresa's medical condition can cause violent mood swings and psychotic behavior. Fed up with Gwen's carping, Theresa gleefully sinks a pair of scissors into her rival's back. The munchkins attempt to rescue Timmy but are repelled by the evil scarecrow. Sam, Pilar and T.C. back up Eve's story to keep the guards at bay. Later, when Ethan phones, Eve warns him that Theresa and her baby are in great peril.
As the munchkins celebrate the fiery demise of the evil scarecrow, Toto senses a new danger nearby. Brian urges "Diana" not to trust a word that comes out of Nick's lying mouth. Meanwhile, Nick triumphantly matches "Diana's" photo to a picture of the "late" Sheridan Crane. At the hospital, the suspicious prison guard reminds Luis he'll have a lot of explaining to do if Theresa turns up missing. As a terrified Gwen clings to Ethan, Theresa rages at her former fiance for leading her on. Though Rebecca remains confident that their scheme will pan out, Ivy fears for her son's safety. Theresa lunges at Ethan with the scissors and manages to wing him. Timmy and Julian come face to face with the murderous Tin Man and his trusty chainsaw.
Rebecca berates Ivy for tipping Sam off to Ethan's whereabouts. Meanwhile, Gwen warns Ethan that Theresa's baby is well on the way. Julian makes tracks to escape the Tin Man's chainsaw. The prison guards inform Sam and Luis that they'll face charges for aiding and abetting a felonious flight from justice. Thanks to some timely assistance from Hank and T.C., however, the chief of police and his officer manage to elude their pursuers and head up to the cabin with Eve. "Charity" assures Miguel that he can't remember their night in the cemetery because he was so exhausted he zoned the whole evening out. Julian saves a grateful Timmy and Toto from certain death. Theresa finally brings a healthy baby boy into the world.