The final arc of My Hero Academia has had intense battles and shocking moments. Among the most discussed topics in the manga community is whether Fumikage Tokoyami, the dark-powered student from Class 1-A, lost his powerful Dark Shadow Quirk to the series' main antagonist, All For One. This issue became clear in the final battles, as All For One demonstrated his terrifying skill of stealing Quirks from pro heroes.
The answer is no – Tokoyami did not lose his Dark Shadow Quirk to All For One. While All For One successfully stole Hawks' Fierce Wings Quirk during their fight, he never truly got Tokoyami's Dark Shadow ability.
The haze arose from misconstrued scenes and fan theories, but the manga indeed shows that Tokoyami retained his Quirk throughout the final battles and used it effectively against the villain.
Talk of Tokoyami losing his powers started during the intense fight at Gunga Mountain Villa. My Hero Academia fans saw All For One's devastating charge on multiple heroes, including his successful theft of Hawks' Quirk. During these chaotic scenes, some readers wrongly thought that All For One had also targeted and stolen Tokoyami's Dark Shadow.

This misreading was further fueled by All For One's strategic withdrawal from the battlefield. The villain appeared to be assembling powerful Quirks before his final confrontation, leading many to believe he had acquired Dark Shadow's abilities.
What actually transpired is that All For One did consider stealing Tokoyami's Quirk during their encounter. The villain admitted the potential threat that Dark Shadow posed, particularly given the advantageous conditions of darkness and stormy weather. However, his plans were interrupted by other heroes on the battlefield.
Chapter 385 of My Hero Academia showed All For One closing in on Tokoyami, hinting at the chance of stealing his Quirk. Yet Mineta's interference forced the villain to reanalyze his priorities. All For One realized he was squandering precious time and ought to focus on his primary objective of reaching and melding with Shigaraki.
The Risks Persisted in My Hero Academia

Another factor that protected Tokoyami involved All For One's deteriorating condition. My Hero Academia revealed that the villain's use of a rewind effect to restore his body came with severe limitations. Any newly stolen Quirks would be affected by this rewinding process, making them potentially useless.
This rewind mechanism significantly affected mutation-type Quirks like Hawks' wings. While All For One could steal these abilities, his rewinding body would destroy the physical changes necessary to use them effectively. This limitation made stealing specific Quirks inadequate for his rapid goals.
Keeping Tokoyami’s Quirk was crucial to the heroes’ overall battle plan. My Hero Academia showed that Dark Shadow was extremely useful against All For One due to its special properties. The sentient nature of Dark Shadow made it an unforeseen opponent that couldn't be effortlessly countered.

A key battle in My Hero Academia revealed Tokoyami using Dark Shadow at its full strength. The medley of environmental factors, strategic positioning, and his retained Quirk allowed him to deliver devastating attacks against All For One. This moment confirmed once and for all that Tokoyami kept his Quirk.
As such, My Hero Academia fans can relax about Tokoyami never losing his Dark Shadow Quirk to All For One. While the villain successfully robbed other powers during the final arc, Dark Shadow remains with its initial wielder throughout the series. Holding onto his powers was key to the heroes’ final win and kept Tokoyami’s character arc intact.
Follow SoapCentral for more updates.