One choice, endless loss: Levi’s tragic fate in Attack on Titan

In the world of Attack on Titan, everyone is part of the survivor horror story. Death is always around the corner, and characters have to make a split-second decision; out of them, few decisions have left as deep a scar as the one Captain Levi Ackerman was forced to make during the aftermath of the mission to retake Shiganshina.

There was a point where Captain Levi Ackerman, bloodied and broken, stood over the dying bodies of Armin Arlert and Commander Erwin Smith, forced to choose who would live.

I still remember that scene vividly as if I saw it yesterday. Watching Levi watch two men, both heroes. One syringe. Levi had to make a choice that I’m not sure I could have. He chose Armin. He let Erwin go. And that one choice changed everything.

Even after finishing all of the series, I always end up thinking about this specific moment. Watching Levi, I felt his pain, saw how it tore at him, and saw how no amount of training, discipline, or battlefield experience could have prepared him for this. I think subtle clues were pointing towards whom he wanted to choose.

I think Levi knew that Erwin was the logical choice. Erwin in Attack on Titan was irreplaceable, a master tactician, a fearless leader, someone who could turn the tides of war with a look and a sentence. But that’s not who Levi chose. He said Erwin had suffered enough. It was time to let him rest. And in that moment, Levi made a decision not just for the mission, but for his friend.

Alternatively, there was a point where I couldn’t help but wonder if both of them could survive. There are a few fan theories on whether they would have found another Titan shifter that could’ve been captured. Maybe both Armin and Erwin could’ve survived and fought side by side in Attack on Titan.

Ultimately, I had to accept the harsh reality that Attack on Titan is unforgiving. In this world, even the best choices come with an unbearable cost. Levi didn’t have the luxury of a perfect outcome. He had a syringe, a dying friend, a boy full of hope, and seconds to decide.

Another scenario that I came across is how different the war against Marley could have been. Armin’s approach was cautious, filled with negotiations and compromise. But it lacked urgency. Knowing Erwin, he wouldn't have waited.

He would’ve struck when Marley was still busy with the Mid-East Allied Forces when their warriors were spread thin. It could’ve been a surgical strike, crippling Marley’s infrastructure and forcing peace on Paradis’ terms.

But ultimately, Levi's choice to save Armin over Erwin is one of the most painful, powerful moments in the entire series. It’s not because one was better than the other; it’s because it forced a character like Levi, someone we see as unshakeable, to make a truly impossible choice.

One choice, endless Loss in Levi’s life in Attack on Titan

Levi’s decision wasn’t just about who lived. It was about what kind of world they were going to fight for. And whether you agree with it or not, it’s a choice that changed everything.

Erwin’s death wasn’t just the loss of a commander. It was the loss of a future that might have been. And Armin’s survival, while hopeful, came with the burden of trying to live up to that lost legacy.

Trending

I’ll always wonder how differently things might’ve turned out. Maybe the Rumbling wouldn’t have happened. Maybe Eren in Attack on Titan could’ve been stopped. Maybe the Scouts wouldn’t have fallen apart. But in the world of Attack on Titan, there are no easy answers. Only choices, and the pain they leave behind. Levi chose with his heart.

And because of that, because he showed us that even the strongest soldier can be guided by love, not just duty, he became more than just a captain. He became the embodiment of what it means to be human in a world that constantly tries to strip that away. And for that, I’ll never stop respecting him.

×

Was this article helpful?

Thank You for feedback