Certain movies don't reach their audience immediately. Overshadowed by blockbuster competition, misinterpreted by critics, or marketed poorly, most underappreciated gems slip through the cracks after initial release. Certain films, initially dismissed or overlooked, slowly climb up the lists on streaming sites,eventually becoming contemporary cult classics or cultural touchstones. These movies tend to strike a chord with time, as audiences mature, dealing with themes that were ahead of time of their release.
This piece explores nine such films that were underrated or even forgotten when they first came out but received accolades, affection, and even critical reassessment years after their release. From animated masterpieces to sci-fi thrillers, feminist horror stories to films making strong social commentary, each of these films tells a bigger story about how timing, perception, and changing audiences can completely reshape a movie’s legacy. Whether you’re discovering these titles for the first time or revisiting them with fresh eyes, you’ll see why they’ve earned their overdue place in the spotlight. Because greatness isn't always instant it's just waiting for the moment to shine.
9 most underrated movies that became popular years after their release
1) The Iron Giant (1999)

Brad Bird's The Iron Giant tanked at the box office despite good reviews, primarily because of lackluster marketing. But the film's message regarding identity, sacrifice, and nonviolence slowly gained a dedicated following. Over time, it became a cultural reference point, name-checked in Ready Player One and celebrated at fan conventions. Vin Diesel, who voiced the eponymous Giant, regularly cites the film as one of his personal favorites. Thanks to the growing popularity of retro animation and emotionally charged storytelling, The Iron Giant has become one of the most celebrated animated movies of all time decades after being shrouded in obscurity.
2) Donnie Darko (2001)

Richard Kelly's directorial debut Donnie Darko was a box office failure after its release just weeks following 9/11. Its dark tone and fatalistic themes didn't catch on at first. But DVD sales and midnight showings turned it into a cult hit. The director's cut later explained some of its knotty time loops, revealing new layers in the film. Jake Gyllenhaal's performance as the lead and the placement of "Mad World" have become pop culture phenomena. Today the film is taught at film schools and analysed in thousands of Reddit forums. Its ascension from obscurity to cult status is a testament to how cinephiles can rediscover films and revive even the most bizarre tales.
3) Children of Men (2006)

Alfonso Cuarón's Children of Men went unnoticed when it was released in theatres, notwithstanding its breathtaking cinematography and complex narrative. In the past decade or so, the film has been extolled as uncannily prescient, particularly during worldwide crises such as the COVID-19 pandemic, increased immigration, and the rise of fascism. The long takes, particularly the iconic battle sequence, are now extensively analyzed for their technical merit. Clive Owen's acting and the disturbing realism of the portrayed dystopia have made Children of Men one of the greatest sci-fi movies ever created.
4) The Fall (2006)

Tarsem Singh's The Fall is an eye feast, filmed for over four years in more than 20 countries with no CGI. Although visually masterful, it was hardly recognized at the time of its release. It was only years later, when film buffs discovered it, that the film's dreamlike narrative and emotional center gained momentum. Lee Pace's nuanced performance and his off-screen friendship with child actor Catinca Untaru added depth to the storyline. Today, The Fall is well-revered in indie film circles as a visual poem, the artistry of which was way too ahead of its time, perfect for patient, contemplative viewers.
5) Jennifer’s Body (2009)

Originally written off as a teen horror bomb, Jennifer's Body was mis-marketed and misunderstood by critics as just another Megan Fox-fronted "sexy slasher." However, the resurgence of feminist re-evaluation in the latter half of the 2010s turned it into a cult classic. Diablo Cody's script and Karyn Kusama's direction addressed issues such as toxic friendships and female empowerment in the same breath, years before the #MeToo movement made these topics mainstream. Fox herself has termed the film as "ahead of its time" in a 2021 interview. Gen Z and the contemporary queer audiences have welcomed the film, reviving it for a thriving, colorful afterlife online via essays, memes, and TikTok edits.
6) Edge of Tomorrow (2014)

Despite its cast of Tom Cruise and Emily Blunt, Edge of Tomorrow initially underperformed, at least in part because of the muddled marketing campaign and lackluster title. Over the years, the fans embraced the film on streaming platforms and lauded its creative spin on time loops and war. Its combination of sci-fi, dark humor, and well-developed character trajectories made it a rewatch hit. The movie even had its title changed to Live Die Repeat on home media, surprisingly increasing its popularity. A long-awaited sequel has been teased for years, a testament to the movie's increasing popularity and lasting legacy as one of the smartest action movies of its time.
7) Treasure Planet (2002)

Disney's Treasure Planet was a big box office failure, upstaged by Harry Potter and The Santa Clause 2. Its pioneering combination of hand-drawn animation and 3D CGI was cutting-edge and perplexing for audiences in the early 2000s. But viewers these days have loved its bold visual style, deeply emotional narrative, and complex characters such as Jim Hawkins and John Silver. Online fan forums and retrospectives have rebranded it as an underrated classic. With increasing fondness for 2D animation, Treasure Planet has gained a new lease of life among Disney fans who now consider it to be one of the studio's most groundbreaking attempts.
8) A Scanner Darkly (2006)

Richard Linklater's A Scanner Darkly bewildered viewers with its rotoscope animation and dark storytelling but time has treated this Philip K. Dick adaptation kindly. The film's rumination on surveillance, addiction, and identity feels more prescient now in the age of digital paranoia. Starring Keanu Reeves, Winona Ryder, and Robert Downey Jr., the film blends reality and hallucinatory experiences in a manner that has begun to increasingly resemble reality with the years. Dystopian fiction fans have re-discovered it through streaming platforms, and its cult following keeps growing with time. The distinctive animation style, which was once regarded as quirky, is now appreciated as a masterful aesthetic decision.
9) It’s a Wonderful Life (1946)

Frank Capra's It's a Wonderful Life is today's holiday classic, but it flopped at the box office and languished in obscurity for decades. It wasn't until the 1970s when it slipped into the public domain and was broadcast regularly on television that the movie was rediscovered. Its messages about self-worth, community, and redemption resonated with a new generation. Ironically, its failure is what made it eternally relevant. In 2022, the Library of Congress included a restored 4K copy to its National Film Registry to preserve it. Its posthumous success reminds us that some stories just require time and a bit of faith to shine.
Not all masterpieces receive their time in the limelight immediately. These nine films are a testament to the fact that success that comes late can be as great as that which comes immediately. With changing times, evolving tastes, cultural consciousness, and further scrutiny, these underappreciated films gained the accolades they were always worthy of. Their paths from obscurity to cult status underscore the constantly changing nature of cinema appreciation. So next time a film flies under the radar, don't rule it out because maybe, its best moment may be lurking just around the corner, waiting to enthrall a new generation.
Love movies? Try our Box Office Game and Movie Grid Game to test your film knowledge and have some fun!