Fear Street: Prom Queen cast and character guide - Who plays whom in Netflix's latest slasher sequel?

Blood, glitter, and the ghost of prom nights past, Netflix’s Fear Street: Prom Queen is here, and it's every bit as deliciously twisted as you'd hope. Set in the neon-drenched chaos of 1988, Shadyside, this standalone slasher revives the spirit of R.L. Stine’s iconic teen horror novel with a sharp new edge. The tiaras are sparkling, the dresses are killer (literally), and the competition is cutthroat, because this prom queen race has a body count.

As bodies start dropping and secrets begin to rot beneath the surface, one girl finds herself at the center of the madness. But she’s not alone; from mean girls with perfect hair to dark-hearted outsiders and suspicious authority figures, the cast of Prom Queen is as layered as the mystery itself.

So, who’s who in this bloody high school showdown? Here’s your complete guide to the stars of Fear Street: Prom Queen and the characters they bring to life in this scream-worthy sequel.

India Fowler as Lori Granger

India Fowler stars as Lori Granger, the sharp-witted outcast at the heart of Fear Street: Prom Queen. Haunted by her family's troubled legacy and determined to rewrite her own story, Lori isn’t just chasing the crown; she’s fighting to survive. India brings a quiet intensity to the role, blending vulnerability with a fierce determination that makes Lori one of the most compelling main girls the Fear Street universe has seen yet.

Suzanna Son as Megan

Suzanna Son plays Megan Rogers, the ride-or-die best friend every horror heroine wishes she had, sharp-tongued, effortlessly cool, and always a little high. In Fear Street: Prom Queen, Megan is the goth stoner with a twisted sense of humor and a surprisingly big heart. Whether she’s roasting the prom queen hopefuls or lighting up the school parking lot, she’s the glue holding Lori together as the world around them turns bloody.

Son brings a gritty, magnetic energy to Megan, making her more than just comic relief; she’s a scene-stealer with layers. In her own words, Son just wanted to be Megan, and it shows.

Fina Strazza as Tiffany

Fina Strazza plays Tiffany Falconer in Fear Street: Prom Queen, the picture-perfect prom queen with a razor-sharp smile and a heart full of secrets. On the surface, she’s Shadyside High’s golden girl: flawless, untouchable, and practically born with a tiara on her head. But behind the glitter and gloss? Pure menace.

Tiffany isn’t just playing the popularity game; she’s playing for blood. Strazza brings a magnetic, icy edge to the role, making Tiffany as captivating as she is terrifying. Think Regina George with a body count.

David Iacono as Tyler

David Iacono plays Tyler Torres, the charming yet tangled love interest caught in the middle of Fear Street: Prom Queen’s twisted high school drama. Tyler’s not just your typical jock; he’s got layers, torn between the ruthless prom queen Tiffany and the fierce underdog Lori. When prom night turns deadly, Tyler’s loyalties and true colors come to light, and David Iacono makes sure you’re hooked every step of the way.

Ella Rubin as Melissa

Melissa’s basically Tiffany’s lapdog, the classic Shadyside mean girl who’s all about keeping up appearances. But deep down, there’s this little voice of conscience gnawing at her, making her question if the price of “cool” is really worth it.

What’s interesting about Melissa is that she’s caught between two worlds. On one hand, she craves the status and validation that comes with being part of the in-crowd. And honestly? Melissa doesn’t really like Tiffany. She’s obsessed, sure, but “like” is the wrong word. She’s insecure, and someone like Tiffany, sitting at the top of the popularity ladder, gives her a taste of power and acceptance that’s impossible to resist.

Rebecca Ablack as Debbie

Debbie is one of Tiffany’s ruthless minions, the gossipy mouthpiece of the Shadyside Wolf Pack in Fear Street: Prom Queen who spreads dirt with a wicked smile. She’s meaner, sharper, and way more vicious than the other mean girls, but beneath all that nastiness is a desperate hunger to be noticed and approved by Tiffany.

What’s so captivating about Debbie is how cutthroat her jabs are; she’s brutally funny, even if she doesn’t realize it herself. Playing Debbie means dialing up the drama and stepping into that over-the-top territory where the nastiness becomes almost cartoonish. It’s not subtle cruelty; it’s full-on, wild, and that’s what makes it fun to watch. Rebecca Ablack nails that balance of vicious and hilarious, making Debbie a memorably fierce presence in the pack.

Ilan O'Driscoll as Linda

Linda is another member of Tiffany’s Wolf Pack, the straight-A student who quietly helps Tiffany stay on top. She’s the smart, cunning fox in the group, the one who flies under the radar while others scramble to win Tiffany’s favor.

What makes Linda so interesting is that she’s the silent strategist. While Debbie and Melissa fight for the spotlight and Tiffany’s attention, Linda just watches, lets them battle it out, and plays her cards with quiet confidence.

Ariana Greenblatt as Christy

Christy is the dark horse in the prom queen race, the rebellious bad girl with street cred, never spotted without her signature cowboy boots and perfectly winged eyeliner. She’s the kind of girl who owns her vibe and doesn’t care what anyone else thinks. She's the outsider in the team of cool high-schoolers in Fear Street: Prom Queen.

What’s so magnetic about Christy is her fearless attitude. She’s effortlessly cool, and that makes everyone else a little intimidated; basically, all the other girls wish they could have her freedom to just be unapologetically themselves.

Fear Street: Prom Queen is currently available to stream on Netflix.

Also Read: Fear Street: Prom Queen almost had a post-credits scene that connected it to the original trilogy