Fear Street: Prom Queen Ending Explained — Who really killed Lorie’s dad?

Welcome back to Shadyside, where nothing is ever as it seems. If you've watched Netflix's Fear Street: Prom Queen (2025), you already know that behind every glittery prom dress hides a bloody secret. This movie, based on R.L. Stine’s classic 1992 book of the same name, mixes high school drama with gruesome slasher horror.

And yes, it all ties back to the cursed legacy of Shadyside. But what really happened in the ending?

Lorie is just your average teenage girl. She’s not rich. She’s not popular. She doesn’t even expect much from prom, until suddenly, she’s nominated for Prom Queen at Shadyside High. This is odd, considering she doesn’t hang out with the popular kids.

In Fear Street: Prom Queen, her best friend Rachel tells her to enjoy it, but Lorie isn’t sure. Something feels off.

The other girls nominated, Tiffany Falconer, Erica Lee, and Simone, are the typical prom queen types. Pretty, popular, and full of themselves. Lorie doesn’t fit in with them at all. So why was she chosen?

---

The murders begin

Then things that take place in the film range from being weird to terrifying in Fear Street: Prom Queen. The other nominees start dying, brutally. One by one, someone is killing them off. People start wondering if someone is clearing the way for Lorie to win.

But it gets worse. Lorie starts getting scary notes. Someone is watching her.

While trying to stay alive, Lorie finds out a painful family secret. Her father, who died years ago, had an affair. This truth hurts her relationship with her mom, Rose. Fear Street: Prom Queen it also adds emotional weight to the story: it’s not just about murder. It’s about buried secrets and broken families.

Prom night arrives, and it’s tense. Lorie is crowned queen. But before she can celebrate, a masked killer attacks her. She defends herself with her tiara, yes, her tiara, and kills the attacker.

In Fear Street: Prom Queen, when the mask comes off, the killer is revealed as Dan Falconer, Lorie’s teacher and Tiffany’s dad. WHAT?! He killed the other girls so Tiffany could win and feel better about herself.

Creepy and tragic, right? This guy’s idea of “helping” his daughter turned into a killing spree.

You think it’s over? Nope. After the attack, Lorie is invited to the Falconer house. They say they want to apologize. But it’s a setup.

Nancy Falconer, Tiffany’s mom, confesses she helped with the murders, and she drops a bomb: she was the one who killed Lorie’s dad.

Why? Because years ago, Lorie’s dad left her for Rose. Nancy never got over it. Her pride, her jealousy, it all led her to destroy Lorie’s family.

---

The dark legacy of the falconers in Fear Street: Prom Queen

Nancy controlled her husband and daughter like puppets. She wanted revenge so badly, she dragged her whole family into darkness.

But her confession finally clears Rose’s name. For years, people thought Rose had something to do with her husband’s death. Now, the truth is out - Fear Street: Prom Queen.

Just when you think it’s done, blood from Nancy’s body forms a strange symbol on the floor. Fans of Fear Street will recognize it: it’s the witch’s mark, Sarah Fier’s symbol.

In Fear Street: Prom Queen, this is a major clue that the Falconers were influenced by something darker. It’s not just about jealousy and revenge. There’s a curse fueling all of it.

The movie Fear Street: Prom Queen reminds us that in Shadyside, evil has roots. Regular people become monsters, not just because they’re bad, but because something in the town corrupts them.

Nancy, like many before her, was just the latest person to be consumed by that evil.

This movie, Fear Street: Prom Queen, isn’t just about who dies. It’s about what we inherit. The Falconers couldn’t let go of their pride. They let their past poison the present.

Lorie, though, breaks the cycle. She faces the truth and survives.

Being prom queen might sound silly, but here it’s a symbol. It shows the pressure on girls to be perfect, to compete, to “win” at high school popularity. In Shadyside, that pressure gets turned into something deadly.

Fear Street: Prom Queen ends with blood, tragedy, and a twisted sense of justice. Lorie survives, but the curse is still alive. That witch’s mark means Shadyside’s darkness isn’t finished.

More stories are coming. More secrets will be revealed. And this small town will continue to haunt us.

---

For more updates, keep reading Soap Central