Honey Don't! cast and character guide: Who plays whom in the latest crime comedy?

A still from Honey Don
Honey Don't! was released today. (Image via Focus Features)

Ethan Coen and Tricia Cooke's dark comedy and second film in their lesbian B-movie trilogy, Honey Don't!, has one purely evil character, and you can easily guess who played it. A clue until we finally mention the name: the celebrity is tied to the Marvel Cinematic Universe. Keep guessing, as there are two of them in the movie.

The film is a follow-up to the 2024 film Drive-Away Dolls, where Margaret Qualley played Jamie, who gets involved in some criminal matter alongside her best friend Marian, whom Thunderbolt's Geraldine Viswanathan portrayed. It was met mostly with positive reviews and made $8 million at the global box office.

Honey, Don't! stars Chris Evans and Aubrey Plaza, two from the Marvel Cinematic Universe, of whom the former is an established name and the latter joined the MCU recently. In a way, both were evil characters, but then you'll have to guess who is more evil by the end of the movie.


Honey Don't! cast and character guide

Margaret Qualley as Honey O'Donahue

Margaret Qualley (left) (Image via Getty)
Margaret Qualley (left) (Image via Getty)

The leading lady of the film is Margaret Qualley, who plays a private investigator in the film. She is involved in a case where the dead person is one of her clients at the beginning of the movie. However, she doesn't know that all of this is just a setup, which the fans will come to know about at the end of the movie.


Aubrey Plaza as MG Falcone

Aubrey Plaza (Image via Getty)
Aubrey Plaza (Image via Getty)

The Death, aka Rio Vidal, from Agatha All Along, has brought death with her in Ethan Coen's Honey Don't! too. Aubrey Plaza is just another police officer called MG Falcone in the movie, but there's more than meets the eye. And you won't be able to tell who's sexier when Honey and Falcone are in bed with each other.


Chris Evans as Reverend Drew Devlin

Chris Evans (middle) (Image via Getty)
Chris Evans (middle) (Image via Getty)

Our very own Captain America is less of a godman and more of a conman named Drew Devlin here. In the morning, he worships the god. In the night, he worships goddesses. If you know, you know.


Charlie Day as Marty Metakawich

Charlie Day (Image via Focus Features)
Charlie Day (Image via Focus Features)

Marty, played by Charlie Day in Honey Don't!, has a crush on Margaret Qualley's Honey. He is so into her that he ignores the fact that she is a lesbian. Actually, it's just the lust. Men will be men, even in the movies.


Jacnier as Hector Bonner

Jacnier (Image via Focus Features)
Jacnier (Image via Focus Features)

Jacnier's Hector Bonner is one interesting character here, though he doesn't have a major role. Though a funny one, you can bet. After an incident, he decides to take revenge on Drew and enters a room while two girls are enjoying the ride on top of him. You'll die laughing, and so will Hector in the scene. Oops, spoilers!


Rest of the Honey Don't! cast

While these are some of the main characters here, you can find the list of the rest of the Honey Don't! cast below.

  • Kristen Connolly as Heidi O’Donahue
  • Billy Eichner as Mr. Siegfried
  • Gabby Beans as Spider
  • Talia Ryder as Corinne
  • Don Swayze as Gary
  • Josh Pafchek as Shuggie
  • Lena Hall as Elle
  • Lera Abova as Cher
  • Kale Browne as Honey and Heidi’s estranged father
  • Alexander Carstoiu as Mickie
  • Christian Antidormi as Colligan
  • Kinna McInroe as Mrs. Novotny

Keep reading Soap Central for more lists like this.

Love movies? Try our Box Office Game and Movie Grid Game to test your film knowledge and have some fun!

Quick Links

Edited by Tanisha Aggarwal