Yankees icons weigh in on controversial bread rule change at Fanatics Fest NYC 2025

After nearly five decades, the Yankees have decided to allow facial hair for all uniformed personnel and players. This is a huge change from their previous policy that only permitted mustaches. Every offseason brings changes within the team, but this decision certainly stands out — few former players know better than those who lived within that old system.

On the Friday morning of Fanatics Fest NYC 2025, former Yankees players Derek Jeter, Alex Rodriguez, C.C. Sabathia, Andy Pettitte, Jorge Posada, and filmmaker Spike Lee participated in a panel discussion with A.J. Andrews from MLB Network. They reminisced about the Yankees while discussing the franchise’s notable policy shift that has restructured one of its longstanding traditions.

The responses featured a mix of support and nostalgia, yet were all grounded in lived experience. One of the most revealing takes came from

Andy Pettitte, who said that the policy could have hurt the team's chances of getting players:

“I didn’t have a problem with it,” Pettitte commented to the group, as reported by Empire Sports Media.

“I would shave right after I pitched. I would hope we didn’t have a rainout. I hated shaving, and I didn’t want to be clean-shaven when I took the mound. Thought I looked like a wimp. We were losing players we were trying to sign… ‘Man, let it go.’”

Pettitte’s remarks suggested that there is now more modern flexibility in team dress code regulations, which are viewed largely as minimalistic and stifling.”

Tradition vs. transition: Jeter, Posada reflect on the Steinbrenner era of the Yankees

Pettitte took a different stance on the shift as others clung to its intent. Jorge Posada, for instance, connected his argument to George Steinbrenner, the late Yankees owner credited for introducing the rule with fostering discipline as its chief aim:

“I don’t know what I would have done,” Posada recalled. “If I got a couple of hits, I wouldn’t have shaven. I just thought about Mr. Steinbrenner and his rules and didn’t wanna disappoint him.”

These remarks capture how many players are devoted to the basic principles that Steinbrenner gave shape to. Derek Jeter expressed the importance of rules and how they govern discipline in the community:

Trending

“I think you have to have rules; they teach you discipline,” he mentioned during a panel. “We had different rules growing up, it just seems like they keep loosening rules…it keeps you disciplined.” Adding humor to his blend, Jeter shared, “My wife told me, ‘You can have a bald head and no hair on your face.’”

Sharing this with everyone emphasized to them that the clean-shaven rule was not just for looks but for values.

×

Was this article helpful?

Thank You for feedback