General Hospital Spoilers: The Case for Scout as Drew’s Shooter

On General Hospital, the current trial of Willow Corinthos for the shooting of Drew Quartermaine feels less like a whodunit and more like a "who is she covering for?"

What’s Happening on General Hospital

General Hospital: Willow and Drew watch the trial play out | Image: ABC

The Port Charles District Attorney’s office, known for its historical ineptitude, seems convinced it has its woman. Willow (Katelyn MacMullen) was found near the scene; her recent behavior has been erratic, and her motive—Drew’s (Cameron Mathison) dismantling of her family and the loss of custody of her children—is clear.

However, veteran General Hospital viewers know that the first suspect arrested is rarely the actual perpetrator. While theories circulate about Michael Corinthos (Rory Gibson) seeking revenge, or even Willow developing Dissociative Identity Disorder (DID) akin to her twin sister Nelle, the most logical soap opera solution points in a different direction entirely: Drew’s daughter, Scout Cain (Cosette Abinante).

The "Shadowy Figure" trope is a staple in Port Charles mystery storylines. The person seen standing over Drew after the shot was fired was obscured and, crucially, appeared smaller in stature. While this could point to Willow, it points even more strongly to an aged-up pre-teen like Scout.

Drew Quartermaine’s descent over the last year has been precipitous. He went from the town’s moral compass to a vindictive businessman willing to blackmail Portia Robinson (Brook Kerr) and destroy his own family crypt just to hurt Michael. His obsession with Willow has turned possessive and frightening. It is highly plausible that Scout, who is currently around 10 to 12 years old in "soap time," witnessed her father threatening Willow or acting aggressively toward her.

An Alternate Theory

General Hospital: Is Willow's guilt her protection of Scout? | Image: ABC

On the Soap Central message boards, fans are skeptical of the current narrative. The prevailing sentiment is that Willow’s "spiraling" isn’t guilt over pulling the trigger, but the immense pressure of shielding a child. Poster 'QuartermaineKeeper' noted this week, "Willow's entire character is built on maternal sacrifice. She wouldn't shoot Drew in cold blood, but she would absolutely go to Pentonville to stop Scout from being questioned." Another long-time viewer, 'GHHistorian,' pointed out the physical logistics: "The shooter didn't run immediately. They stood frozen. That’s a terrified kid reaction, not a vengeful adult reaction."

Historical precedent at General Hospital strongly supports this theory. The show frequently uses children in violent storylines to maximize emotional fallout while avoiding long-term prison sentences for main characters. We cannot forget a young Michael Corinthos saying he killed Claudia Zacchara (Sarah Joy Brown) with an axe handle to protect his mother and newborn sister. A child acting violently in defense of a parental figure is woven into the show’s DNA.

If Scout found a gun—perhaps owned by an increasingly paranoid Drew—and used it during a perceived threat to Willow, it resolves the corner the writers have painted themselves into. It explains why Willow is acting guilty without having the internal demeanor of a killer. It stops the complete assassination of Drew’s character by making him a victim of his own child’s trauma response. Most importantly, it shifts the storyline from a simple murder trial to a complex Quartermaine family tragedy surrounding Scout’s mental health.

Willow is currently falling on her sword. The question isn't if she did it, but how long until the actual shooter breaks down and admits the truth. All signs point to Scout.

Watch all new episodes of General Hospital on ABC