Nantucket is an Island in Massachusetts famous for its historic places and beaches. This list of affordable restaurants (relatively affordable) in Nantucket is curated from online reviews and rankings. Some of the restaurants in this list are temporarily closed for the season, so check whether the place is open before visiting.
Disclaimer: This article contains the writer's opinion. Readers’ discretion is advised.
20. B-ACK Yard BBQ - Straight Wharf

B-ACK Yard BBQ is a Barbecue restaurant located in the Nantucket Downtown Historic District with a menu consisting of BBQ, beer, cocktails, etc. Stacey McKenzie on Google reviews the restaurant as a good spot for BBQ meat and recommends dishes like 'The Selfie' (a combo dish of two meats and two sides with a Warm Roll), Cornbread, and Grilled Asparagus.
19. Downyflake Restaurant - Sparks Ave

Downyflake is described as a country cafe that serves simple items like classic American eateries. One of their most talked about items on Google Reviews is their handmade donuts. Chef Gris Paul on Google describes the place as a go-to for comfortable homemade food and goes on to recommend Breakfast Sandwiches and Sausage, Biscuits, and Gravy to try. The place is Temporarily Closed.
18. Handlebar Café - Washington St (Temporarily Closed)

Handlebar is mainly known for its beverages like artisanal coffee and teas, but they also serve snacks if you're looking for a full-course meal, maybe this isn't the place. According to Brendan Housler on Google Review, other than the 'super-friendly' staff and tasty beverages, the place is ideal for getting work done thanks to its speedy wi-fi.
17. Casa Real - Macys Ln

Casa Real is a Mexican restaurant on 5 Macys Ln in Nantucket. According to the restaurant's website, Casa Real was born out of a need for an authentic Latino Restaurant on Nantucket Island. With a diverse array of dishes from the classic New England Chowder to Carne Asada on their menu, they offer something for almost everyone.
16. The Juice Bar -Broad St #3549

The Juice Bar is yet another affordable spot to get snacks and dessert for a reasonable price, but their menu does not have breakfast or other meals unless you consider ice cream a meal. Other than multiple flavors of ice cream they also offer varieties of sorbet and yogurt, though the options aren't as diverse as the ice cream.
15. Shangri-La - Orange St

Shangri La is an Asian Restaurant in Orange St, Nantucket, that offers Asian cuisines like Momos, Sushi, Butter Chicken, fusion items like chicken tikka momo, and more, they even serve vegan items. Coming to their popular Items, Google Reviews shows that the most talked about items include Pizza and Indian curries. etc.
14. Kitty Murtagh's - Creek Rd

Kitty's was a Reddit recommendation, it is described as the island's 'local watering hole' and is known to offer items varying from classic burgers to seafood items and more. According to Robert Coulter, who describes the place as a local watering hole, Kitty's is a great place to hang out with friends or family and watch a game or play pool, etc.
13. Nantucket Pharmacy Lunch Counter - Main St

Nantucket Pharmacy Lunch Counter was on the list of Tripadvisors Natucekt's cheap eats ranking. Their old-fashioned soda fountain's menu offers a small variety of items ranging from breakfast eats to ice cream. Ray Blanco on Google Reviews says that the place is a refreshing spot to get breakfast takeout, and praises the price and size of the breakfast bagel.
12. Black-Eyed Susan's - India St

Black-Eye Susan's is a restaurant in the Nantucket Downtown Historic District. Though temporarily closed, they are expected to reopen in mid-April 2025. Their breakfast menu consists of items like housemade beef hash, Thai curry egg scramble, etc. One of the most recommended items on Google reviews is their soft and fluffy pancakes, especially the blueberry ones.
11. Henry Jr. Sandwich Shop - Orange St

Henry Jr Sandwich shop offers its customers a variety of sandwich options to choose from, for instance, Italian Grinder, Roast Beef, BLT, and more. Other than sandwiches the online menu also lists a few options for salads, beverages, and cookies. One of their most recommended item on Google Review is the meatball sub.
10. Espresso to Go - Toombs Ct

Espresso to Go with the tagline 'Better than Mom's but the same amount of Love', serves more than just coffee. Their menu also offers breakfast and lunch options like breakfast burritos, chicken sandwiches, cakes, snacks, and more. They also have a patio on the outside with a beautiful view.
9. Stubbys - Steamboat Wharf

Stubby's is a local joint in Steamboat Wharf in Nantucket that offers a diverse menu that features items like egg sandwiches to jerk chicken for reasonable prices. The popular items at Stubbys include their burger, steak and cheese, fried clam, and more. The average price point of the restaurant is reported at $10–20 on Google.
8. Walter's Deli - Broad St

Walter's Deli, located in the Nantucket Downtown Historic District, is a counter-service establishment, and Google reports that its average price range is $10- $20. Their menu often consists of items like sandwiches, salads, etc. According to the internet they serve really good lobster rolls for reasonable prices, so maybe you can give that a try.
7. Jack & Charlie's Ice Cream- Straight Wharf

Jack and Charlie's is a family-owned shop known for their desserts. Though the place has icecream in its name, its menu does have more than just icecream, they also have breakfast and coffee options like sandwiches, muffins, etc. It is temporarily closed, so you might want to check the internet before planning a visit.
6. Island Kitchen - Chins Way

Island's Kitchen is a restaurant that offers an American Menu with classic items like egg benedicts, smoothies, acai bowls, fish tacos, and more. According to HolySocom on Google review, the place is a standout spot with its 'modern take on classic island cuisine', the review further suggests that the most popular item off their menu is ice creams.
5. Something Natural - 50 Cliff Rd. (Temporarily Closed)

Something Natural is a Bakery and sandwich shop with picnic tables placed in the garden, making it a great spot to hang out. The 50 Cliff Road is currently closed for the season and is set to re-open in late March. One of their most recommended items is their sandwiches, one of which is said to be enough for two people.
4. The Nautilus - Cambridge St

The Nautilus is a well-rated spot on the internet that offers a diverse yet unique selection of seafood items and interesting cocktails. The most recommended items on their menu are the Blue Crab Fried Rice, Fried Oyster Tacos, etc. The Nantucket location opened its door to customers back in 2014, and in 2021 they also opened a branch in Boston.
3. Lemon Press - Main St (Temporarily Closed)

With a relative price range of about $20-30 on Google, Lemon Press is yet another place in Nantucket that acquired its place on the best affordable place in Nantucket according to Trip Advisor as well as Wanderlog's listicle. With a a variety of items on the menu from smoothies and sandwiches to cocktails.
2. Pi Pizzeria - W Creek Rd

Pi Pizzeria is a cozy spot to enjoy 'wood-fired Neapolitan pizza and classic Italian Cuisines'. If it is any reassurance, Pi is also an award-winning pizzeria, praised especially for its toppings combo as well as its thin and crispy crust. Their menu might vary based on the ingredients available as they claim to source local and seasonal ingredients to cook up their menu.
1. Millie's Mid-Island- Temporarily Closed

Millies MidIsland in Nantucky was among the top picks by Reddit and Wanderlog as one of the best affordable places in Nantucket. Their menu features cocktails, kinds of seafood, and many more. One of their most famous items is Madaket Mystery, a 'rum punch cocktail'. Right Now they are temporarily closed, so keep checking their website to see if they are open before you visit.

Your perspective matters!
Start the conversation