2. Lucali

Located at 575 Henry St in Brooklyn, this Mark Iacono-founded pizzeria has been serving some of the most popular pizzas and calzones since it opened its doors in 2006. As for what makes it ultra-popular, this pizza joint is undoubtedly better known for that one time Jay-Z and Beyonce chose to have dinner at Lucali instead of attending the 54th Grammy Awards.
Edited by Sangeeta Mathew