10 Cristin Milioti movies and TV shows you need to watch right now

Cristin Milioti movies and TV shows | Images via Apple TV, Hotstar and Prime Video
Cristin Milioti movies and TV shows | Images via Apple TV, Hotstar and Prime Video

Cristin Milioti is an American actress best known for her role as Tracy McConnell in the CBS sitcom How I Met Your Mother. She has established herself as one of the most versatile and captivating actresses on screen, in both film and television. Milioti has played a wide range of characters, from sweet and grounded to dark and forceful.

"The Penguin" marks her first Emmy nomination, which she received for her portrayal of Sofia Falcone. She is also celebrated for her emotional depth, comedic timing, and musical talent. Cristin Milioti delivered unforgettable performances in both indie films and blockbuster TV shows.

Disclaimer: This article is based solely on the writer's opinion. Reader discretion is advised.


Here is the list of the 10 Cristin Milioti movies and TV shows you need to watch right now:

10. Sleepwalk with Me (2012)

Cristin Milioti as Janet Pandamiglio in Sleepwalk with Me | Image via Apple TV
Cristin Milioti as Janet Pandamiglio in Sleepwalk with Me | Image via Apple TV

Sleepwalk with Me is a comedy-drama. Matt is a stand-up comic facing a breakup and struggling with a sleep disorder. Cristin Milioti plays Janet Pandamiglio, Matt's caring sister. Although small, her role is warm, realistic, and emotionally vital. A highlight is Janet advising Matt to pause his relationship during their engagement party, which is memorable for her calm voice and gentle concern. Milioti's performance demonstrates her ability to shine even briefly.

This early initiative served as a preview of her future achievements. This movie showcased her ability to portray passionate and subtly complex characters with genuine conviction and a lighthearted touch.


9. The Wolf of Wall Street (2013)

Cristin Milioti as Teresa Petrillo in The Wolf of Wall Street | Image via Apple TV
Cristin Milioti as Teresa Petrillo in The Wolf of Wall Street | Image via Apple TV

The Wolf of Wall Street follows the rise and fall of Jordan Belfort in the stock market, directed by Martin Scorsese. Cristin Milioti plays Teresa Petrillo, Jordan's first wife and a Queens hairdresser who supported him before his downfall. Her most notable moment is when she confronts Jordan about his infidelity, showing her pain and anger as she pours water on him and demands honesty. This scene highlights Milioti's emotional power, establishing Teresa as a strong individual alongside prominent figures.

Her performance heightens the film's intensity by illustrating the cost of Jordan's desire. It may be a small but meaningful role that helped Cristin Milioti gain recognition in Hollywood. So, get ready! Grab some popcorn and watch her in The Wolf of Wall Street.


8. Palm Springs (2020)

Palm Springs | Image via Netflix
Palm Springs | Image via Netflix

Palm Springs is a romantic comedy science fiction film about a time loop experienced by two wedding guests. Sarah Wilder, played by Cristin Milioti, is the bride's sardonic sister. She is caught in the maelstrom with Nyles (Andy Samberg), and together they discover regrets, love, and life's purpose.

One scene that shines through the character is when Sarah delivers an emotional speech at the wedding and attempts to get out of the loop. She cries, and her voice expresses weakness and optimism. Cristin Milioti is sometimes funny, sometimes dramatic, but not beyond the capacity of fluid transition between sarcasm and sincerity. Her act is goofy, protective, and humane.

Cristin's portrayal of Sarah's progress and dissatisfaction makes the character likable and relatable. Cristin Milioti's range was seen in this scene, which showcased her ability to carry a film with grace and elegance. This performance is among her most well-received to date.


7. Modern Love (Season 1, 2019)

Cristin Milioti as Maggie Mitchell in Modern Love (Season 1) | Image via Prime Video
Cristin Milioti as Maggie Mitchell in Modern Love (Season 1) | Image via Prime Video

Modern Love is a collection of romantic and life stories in New York City. At the beginning of episode one, Cristin Milioti played Maggie Mitchell. She is a woman going through dating, a sudden pregnancy, and her path to becoming a single parent. Maggie has a nice doorman in her building who supports her during her pregnancy, and she later visits the doorman with her daughter.

Viewers will remember this poignant scene when Maggie goes to him in tears after giving birth, revealing both her gratitude and her fear. The uncomplicated but charming story is made even more realistic by Cristin Milioti's quiet and grounded acting.


6. The Penguin (2024)

Cristin Milioti as Sofia Falcone in The Penguin | Image via Hotstar
Cristin Milioti as Sofia Falcone in The Penguin | Image via Hotstar

The Penguin is a Gotham crime series on HBO that serves as a sequel to The Batman. This TV show focuses on Oswald Cobblepot (played by Colin Farrell) as he struggles to take over the city’s underworld. Cristin Milioti stars as Sofia Falcone, the daughter who was held in Arkham Asylum and released after serving a ten-year sentence. Sofia is intelligent, composed, and driven by a desire for revenge.

One of the most memorable moments is when Sofia enters a tense family dinner in a striking yellow dress in episode 4 (“Cent Anni”) and then confronts her family forcefully.

Cristin Milioti delivers a cold, complex performance, making her a compelling and intimidating figure. She has received nominations and awards from the Golden Globe, Critics' Choice, Saturn, Independent Spirit, and Gotham TV awards for this role.


5. The Resort (2022)

The Resort | Image via Peacock
The Resort | Image via Peacock

The Resort is a mystery-comedy TV show about two married people who discover a cold case while on vacation in the Mayan Riviera. Cristin Milioti stars as Emma, who has suffered a miscarriage and is in a state of finding purpose. Her finest moment is the scene when Emma pulls out her diseased tooth in the jungle. This scene represents her emotional suffering.

Cristin Milioti balances laughter, sadness, and the resolve to live, which is what makes Emma's story so real. She moves through tunnels, gets drunk on tequila when protecting stakeouts, and runs down with a ruthless energy on clues. Milioti is a master at conveying grief. Thus, her combination of physical humor and emotional skill is one of the best aspects of her performance.


4. Made for Love (2021-2022)

Made for Love | Image via Prime Video
Made for Love | Image via Prime Video

Made for Love is a black comedy/sci-fi series about a woman named Hazel Green who runs away after her tech billionaire husband places a chip in her brain. Cristin Milioti portrays Hazel shrewdly and emotionally. The scene in which Hazel faces Byron and requests a divorce is her most powerful moment, demonstrating both her strength and fragility.

Milioti depicts the dread, rage, and determination that comes with being an independent individual fighting for freedom in the face of overwhelming circumstances. Hazel transforms into a strong and complex heroine by steering her clear of suspicious spies and helping her connect with her enigmatic father. Her performance anchors the humor and emotional core of the show, proving that she can take center stage in a series that combines different styles and themes.


3. Black Mirror - USS Callister (2017, reprised 2025)

Cristin Milioti as Nanette Cole in Black Mirror - USS Callister | Image via Netflix
Cristin Milioti as Nanette Cole in Black Mirror - USS Callister | Image via Netflix

In Black Mirror - USS Callister, Cristin Milioti stars as Nanette Cole, who is taken into a virtual world by her sleazy boss. She reprises her role as Captain Nanette in the 2025 sequel, USS Callister: Into Infinity, when she leads her crew into danger and the digital revolution.

The best scene is her final confrontation, where she has an argument with her digital copy and slays a deity-like villain. Cristin Milioti is courageous, clever, and emotionally rich, sharing the screen with two versions of herself (real and virtual). She turns in an exciting, multilayered performance, and Nanette was one of the most memorable characters of Black Mirror.


2. Fargo (Season 2, 2015)

Cristin Milioti as Betsy Solverson in Fargo (Season 2) | Image via Prime Video
Cristin Milioti as Betsy Solverson in Fargo (Season 2) | Image via Prime Video

Fargo's second season, set in 1979, explores the Midwest's criminal, black comedy, and family tensions. Cristin Milioti plays Betsy Solverson, a compassionate mother and wife who battles cancer silently while her husband, Lou, and father-in-law investigate a heinous crime.

In the episode "The Gift of the Magi", Betsy takes her family aside and calmly tells them that she is getting worse. The world of a crazy man requires things to be focused. Cristin portrays daily heroism in this chaotic society, introducing emotional complexity that makes the season enjoyable despite the bloodshed and ethical difficulty.


1. How I Met Your Mother (2013-2014)

Cristin Milioti as Tracy McConnell in How I Met Your Mother | Image via Hotstar
Cristin Milioti as Tracy McConnell in How I Met Your Mother | Image via Hotstar

In the sitcom How I Met Your Mother, Ted Mosby describes how he met his children's mother. The character, Tracy McConnell, who was originally introduced in the season 8 finale, is played by Cristin Milioti. One of the most unforgettable scenes is when she performs La Vie en Rose on ukulele in a train station. It is poignant, musical, and heartwarming. Her ability to sing the song makes that scene memorable.

She brought Tracy to life and helped her fall in love. She also contributed to the emotional progression of the story in subsequent episodes. Her performance remains one of the most well-liked in the show's history, and both fans and critics have complimented her attractiveness.


Edited by Yesha Srivastava