48 Hours: Mystery at Eagle Creek - Who was Rhonda Casto and what happened to her? Disturbing details of a fateful hike, explored

48 Hours: Mystery at Eagle Creek delves into the 2009 unfortunate death of Rhonda Casto, who apparently slipped from a cliff and died on the spot.

Was it an accidental death or murder? Even more than a decade later, this remains a mystery.

Turns out, the young mother of one and an aspiring model, Rhonda Casto, was not alone during the time of her death. She went on a hike with her fiancé, Stephen Nichols. What was supposed to be a simple afternoon trek sparked one of Oregon's most debated criminal cases.

Within months, investigators uncovered that Nichols had recently increased Rhonda's life insurance to $1 million, making himself a beneficiary. Friends claimed Rhonda had joked days earlier about Nichols either proposing to her or throwing her off the cliff. What followed was years of courtroom drama until after Stephen Nichols was accused of pushing Rhonda to her death and was arrested in 2015.

However, the case took multiple turns due to a lack of evidence and Stephen's changing statements, which made it more complicated.

As per Columbia Gorge News, in the end, the prosecutors dropped the murder charge in 2017 as part of a plea deal where Nichols pleaded guilty to lesser counts, including criminally negligent homicide and coercion, but not murder.

48 Hours: Mystery at Eagle Creek - Who was Rhonda Casto?

Rhonda Casto was a 23-year-old mother of a nine-month-old infant and an aspiring model who fell from a cliff in Oregon's Eagle Creek trail in 2009. She was from Portland, and she had a bright, easy laugh. Friends called her "outgoing," as per the 48 Hours episode.

She met Stephen Nichols when her mother, Julia Simmons, was looking for a place to rent, and they came across Stephen Nichols' condo advertisement. As per CBS News, Jessica Colburn, Rhonda's friend, revealed that Stephen was attracted to Rhonda. Soon, Rhonda, her then 9-year-old sister, and her mother moved to Nichols' condo.

Almost three years into their relationship, Rhonda gave birth to their daughter. However, the two weren't engaged yet. Naturally, after giving birth, she gained some weight. As per Nichols' statements, she told him that she really wanted to lose the weight for her upcoming modelling projects.

However, as per Colburn's statements, things were right between the couple, especially after the birth of their daughter. She also told CBS News that Nichols was abusive to Rhonda and that she had also witnessed their arguments. Nichols denied these claims and revealed that they were going to get married the coming summer.

However, fate took a wild turn in March 2009. Here's what happened to Rhonda Casto as per the 48 Hours episode.

48 Hours: Mystery at Eagle Creek - What happened to Rhonda Casto?

On March 16, 2009, Rhonda and Nichols hiked Eagle Creek. Near a cable-secured ledger, Rhonda slipped and plunged more than a hundred feet. Naturally, she did not survive. Nichols called 911, saying she slipped. He told the responders that he had tried to resuscitate her but failed. For months, the authorities treated Rhonda's death as suspicious but without any charges. The autopsy showed lower body trauma nd traces of drugs, which complicated the scenario. Rhonda's family and friends suspected foul play. Motive? Either financial gain or the couple's volatile relationship.

However, the investigation was messed up from the beginning. Years passed by. A secret grand jury ultimately returned an indictment. Nichols was arrested in 2015 while returning from China. In the end, the prosecutors dropped the murder charge due to lack of evidence, and Nichols pleaded guilty to lesser counts.

Rhonda's unfortunate death exposed broken relationships, legal failures, emotional struggles, and constant grief. In short, Rhonda fell and lost her life. Everything after that is tangled in blame, doubt, and a constant search for answers that remains buried at Eagle Creek. This episode of 48 Hours is available to watch on YouTube.

Trending

Follow SoapCentral for more such updates on 48 Hours.

×

Was this article helpful?

Thank You for feedback