7 Dateline cases that would have made great crime drama adaptations

Watch Dateline at NBC | Image via NBC
Watch Dateline at NBC | Image via NBC

In 1992, Dateline started reporting on horrifying crimes and mysteries that would later capture the public's intense fascination. Dateline has been broadcasting a range of incidents for years, from tragic murders to mysterious disappearances. In 1992, the series was also involved in a scandal. These cases covered included small towns to large cities with families who sought answers and investigators who never gave up.

Some were solved with modern technology many years later, while others remain as haunting cold cases. Each case encapsulates a story about loss, fear, and the long way to truth. They reveal the power of crime to destroy normal lives and the strength of determination to bring justice at times. Each could make a solid crime drama.

Disclaimer: This article contains the writer's opinion. Reader's discretion is advised.


Here are 7 Dateline cases that would have made great crime drama adaptations:

7. NBC Dateline's own 1992 scandal

Dateline Season 1 | Image via NBC
Dateline Season 1 | Image via NBC

In 1992, Dateline caused a national sensation with its investigative report, titled, Waiting to Explode. This TV show investigated whether older General Motors pickup trucks could catch fire during side-impact crashes, owing to the design of the fuel tank. The publication aired a dramatic clip of one collision that seemed to support the idea. Later, it was revealed that no tanks had exploded after the collision, and as per the charges of GM against NBC, “remotely controlled incendiary devices” were installed to spark fire during one of the tests. General Motors sued NBC for defamation and temporarily withdrew its advertising from the network. NBC issued a public retraction and admitted that they had made mistakes in staging parts of the test.

The scandal damaged trust in television reporting, and many viewers felt betrayed. However, the incident also resulted in becoming a case study for journalists and producers about ethics; newsrooms also study this as a warning example.

A dramatization based on this event might blend newsroom storytelling with legal battles and personal fallout. It could depict the pressure on producers and the gradual loss of public trust, while raising tough questions about honesty in news. It would be a thrilling crime drama.


6. Murder of Idaho students

Scene from Dateline's episode "The Terrible Night on King Road" | Image via NBC
Scene from Dateline's episode "The Terrible Night on King Road" | Image via NBC

Dateline's episode, titled, The Terrible Night on King Road released in Season 33, 2025, provided a clear and bleak depiction of that tragic night of November 2022. It depicted the story of four students who were killed in their sleep in an off-campus house in Moscow, Idaho. The episode revealed that police used cellular tower data and security footage to locate the culprit, Bryan Kohberger, near the property on multiple evenings. They linked him through his DNA, found on a knife sheath, as evidence. Dateline also shared unsettling details like the killer’s online searches related to serial killers and drugging.

The episode explored how investigators pieced together digital clues and forensic evidence. It underscored the fear that had spread throughout the small community. It combined chronology reconstruction with emotive testimonials from detectives and loved ones, much like a real crime drama. A dramatization would highlight tension in the night, the hunt for the suspect, and the students involved. Since all the students belonged to the same university, the reaction of the community and fellow students could also be documented, in addition to how the internet and social media affect the investigation in modern times.


5. Disappearance of Angela Brosso

Remembering Angela Brosso | Image via NBC
Remembering Angela Brosso | Image via NBC

Angela Brosso was a young adult who went missing in 1992 in Phoenix, Arizona. She was reported missing after she failed to return from a bike ride by a canal on the night before her twenty-second birthday. The case ended up getting dubbed as a haunting local legend for years. Years later, the police were able to link her case to other attacks against women along canal trails. Detectives employed fresh tips and newfound attention to uncover a suspect.

Reports indicated that, later, a man named in police annals as Bryan Patrick Miller was connected to at least two canal murders. He adopted a macabre nickname, "Zombie Hunter," and was referred to as the same in press reports. The case demonstrates the power of one night to change countless lives forever. A Dateline-type investigation captures family tragedy and police investigation over time.

A crime drama, in contrast, could match cold case investigators with scenes from that vanishing night. The series could illustrate how incremental cases develop and how modern tools have the ability to resolve data from years ago. It can also focus on legends, survivors, and a city that is still healing and seeking answers today.


4. Natasha Atchley’s remains were discovered

Natasha Atchley shown in Dateline | Image via NBC
Natasha Atchley shown in Dateline | Image via NBC

Natasha Atchley was a nineteen-year-old who died in 1992 in Southeast Texas. She had gone to a late-night birthday party in a small town called Shepherd. Her car was found burnt on a rural road, a short distance away from the event, while her body was discovered in the trunk of the vehicle. Local police opened a homicide investigation, and the case ended up becoming a cold file for many years. Her death shocked neighbors and friends in the tight-knit area.

Television shows like Cold Justice later re-examined the scene and went through old leads. Over time, new theories have emerged in an attempt to explain what occurred that night.

Accompanied by a Dateline-style telling could cut between the wild party and the empty car on the roadside, a crime drama could follow a young team of detectives as they piece together witness statements. The show could highlight how memory fades, but evidence remains. Moreover, the lives of families who have had to live through these unsolved cases for decades could also be covered. The drama could depict forensic investigations and societal anguish. It may press for new leads and arrests.


3. Christy Mirack was brutally murdered

Christy Mirack shown in Dateline | Image via NBC
Christy Mirack shown in Dateline | Image via NBC

Christy Mirack was a young teacher who was discovered dead in her townhouse on December 21, 1992. The scene was horrifying to the small town. She was beaten as well as sexually assaulted. For decades, the case remained cold. In the 2010s, detectives utilized modern DNA equipment and genetic genealogy, providing a fresh momentum to the case. The effort resulted in constructing a family tree from small DNA connections.

The detectives pursued leads and zeroed in on a suspect who was a local disc jockey. The suspect was apprehended in 2018. He afterwards pleaded guilty and agreed to accept a life sentence in 2019. The case is commonly featured in true crime episodes as well as on Dateline. It demonstrates how the status of cold files can change with fresh research and emerging technology. It also reveals how long survivors' anguish might last.

A crime drama interpretation may vary between the good old days and the current hunt. It might capture the persistence of the detectives as well as the outrage when a small town loses a trusted person and passionate educator.


2. Lisa Ziegert was kidnapped from her workplace and murdered

Lisa Ziegert in Dateline | Image via NBC
Lisa Ziegert in Dateline | Image via NBC

Lisa Ziegert, a teaching assistant, disappeared from her after-school work on April 15, 1992. Four days later, her body was discovered in the woods outside the town. The case haunted the local community for decades. Investigators saved their evidence and continued to search for a match. New leads in 2016 and again in 2017 originated from witnesses as well as from a written confession.

Gary Schara, a suspect, emerged as a person of interest, and his name gained prominence after a letter from a girlfriend was handed over to the police. Authorities apprehended him, and he eventually pleaded guilty. Decades-long search for justice ended many years after the incident. The case has appeared on Dateline & in other crime documentary episodes. It is a tragic tale that demonstrates that patience and forensic work are still capable of solving cold crimes. A crime drama series may want to follow the family and the consistent detective work.


1. Tammy Jo Zywicki was abducted & murdered on a highway

Tammy Jo Zywicki | Image via NBC
Tammy Jo Zywicki | Image via NBC

Tammy Jo Zywicki was a college student who headed off to school in August of 1992. She experienced car difficulty on Interstate 80 in the state of Illinois. Witnesses last saw her standing next to a car with a tractor-trailer in the vicinity. She was found days later along Interstate 44 in the state of Missouri. She was stabbed and sexually assaulted. Her murder became a long-standing cold case that spanned state lines. The FBI and state police kept the file open. Family members advocated for answers for years. The case also remained of interest to amateur detectives and online communities.

Over time, new leads and suspects emerged, but no arrests were made to bring the crime to a conclusion. Dateline and other news outlets have featured the mystery as well as the family's cry for justice.

A crime drama can depict both the wide-ranging hunt for a murderer and the remote road. A crime drama can portray the suffering of an unsettled family.


We conclude that these cases may have been re-enacted as gripping crime dramas, but they were already broadcast in Dateline reports and episodes. The stories were told with poignancy, mystery, and the struggle for justice. The cases also reveal victims who deserve to be remembered, and communities that are questioned years after the attacks.

While some cases were resolved with confessions and guilty pleas, others remain open, with families still seeking closure. In all cases, the fusion of tragedy and investigation provided powerful material to adapt into crime dramas.

Edited by IRMA