7 shows will keep your eyes glued to your screen like Amy Bradley is Missing did

Amy Bradley Is Missing, a new Netflix special, delivers viewers straight into a terrifying real-world thriller: A girl goes missing during a cruise, and, instead of a stress-free vacation, her family ends up in an investigation that takes decades to uncover the mystery.

This three-part docuseries aired on July 16, 2025, bringing to light the spooky case of 23-year-old Amy Lynn Bradley, who was last seen aboard the Rhapsody of the Seas in March 1998. The show takes you through the uncertain. We wonder if it was an accident, a tragedy, or something more sinister?

And did you feel that pit in your stomach when you finished watching? Don't worry, you are not alone. As we keep questioning the unknown, and keep hoping with Amy’s family, you will be tempted to know that your desire to see real unsolved mysteries does not end here. Here are 7 similar shows that will keep your eyes glued to your screen just like Amy Bradley Is Missing.

---

Unbelievable

If Amy Bradley Is Missing gripped you with its spooky unresolved mysteries and sorrowful tones, then Unbelievable will strike just as deep. Although addressing a different type of trauma, this miniseries, too, focuses on the idea of institutional failure, resilience, and the search for truth, being carefully crafted and based on real events. Unbelievable is a 2019 Netflix limited series that was developed by Susannah Grant, Ayelet Waldman, and Michael Chabon. It is adapted from T. Christian Miller and Ken Armstrong’s Pulitzer Prize-winning 2015 article for ProPublica and The Marshall Project: “An Unbelievable Story of Rape”, which later got featured on a podcast episode of This American Life and the 2018 book A False Report. This eight-episode riveting true-crime drama tells the story of two Colorado police officers, Toni Collette as Grace Rasmussen and Merritt Wever as Karen Duvall, who discover a serial rapist years after Marie Adler, played by Kaitlyn Dever, a young woman in Washington State, reports a savage rape to the police but is pressured into retracting the report. Unbelievable is a show of stinging emotional sincerity, with a showcase of subtle acting which makes it one of the potent limited series in the genre of true crime. And if you liked Amy Bradley Is Missing because of how it portrayed the impact on real-life survivors striving to be heard and seen, Unbelievable offers a similarly intense but incredibly humane perspective on how doubt and bias can corrupt truth and how empathy and faith can play a role to restore at least some of it.

---

One Night in Idaho: The College Murders

There is no script on how to grieve nor is there a script on how to seek justice. Amy Bradley Is Missing really gets us with its raw emotion and haunting confusion, leaving the viewers shook by the major gaps between reality and theory. And One Night in Idaho: The College Murders is just a slick, current watch to have queued up right after. Coupled with an impressive visual style, this show keeps its emphasis on relationships: friends, families, classmates, torn asunder by tragedy, the growing digital culture, and the pressures of public fascination. It is a four part documentary streaming on Amazon Prime Video since July, 2025, that revisits the shocking murder of four University of Idaho students Kaylee Goncalves, Madison Mogen, Xana Kernodle, and Ethan Chapin, who were all stabbed to death in a rented house in Moscow, Idaho, on November 13, 2022. Featuring exclusive interviews with the Chapin and Laramie families, this show looks into the case as it happened: the media and social media hype surrounding it, the multi-state manhunt which resulted in the arrest of a criminology graduate student named Bryan Kohberger. Similar to Amy Bradley Is Missing, this show goes out of its way to focus on the victims and their families and neighborhoods, opposed to the sensationalism that is so common in true-crime stories. Directed and produced by Liz Garbus and Matthew Galkin, it is a detailed, sympathetic, and thoughtful dive into a contemporary crime that rocked a university town and does not allow the viewers to forget the faces behind the headlines.

---

The Disappearance of Madeleine McCann

When Amy Bradley Is Missing comes to a close, it leaves you in a state of suspension, plagued by the painful realization that some stories end in a very unsatisfactory way. If you’re still craving a true crime follow-up that matches its emotional desperation and complexity, then The Disappearance of Madeleine McCann will scratch that itch right to perfection. Released in 2019, this Netflix docuseries by Chris Smith (renowned for documentary hits like Fyre and American Movie) presents 8 interconnected episodes narrating one of the most notorious missing child cases in history. It delves straight into the case of a 3-year-old Madeleine McCann, who went missing in May 2007 from her family's holiday apartment in Praia da Luz, Portugal, at the time her parents were dining outside. The case has not been solved even after all these years, and it is the relentless tone of the series that makes it so provocative to the viewers. To the admirers of Amy Bradley Is Missing documentary it appears that both shows are grimly emotional, rooted in unresolved grief and unsettling speculation.

---

American Murder: Laci Peterson

Were you captivated by the cold-case intricacy and the emotional cost of humanity as depicted in Netflix's Amy Bradley Is Missing? Then, you must prepare for another chilling dive into real-life mystery with the 2024 documentary by Skye Borgman: American Murder: Laci Peterson, only this time it is set amidst the blinding spotlight of media chaos, publicity, and courtroom drama. Through the 3 long episodes, we are taken back to the infamous Christmas Eve of 2002, when 27-year-old and 8 months pregnant Laci Peterson mysteriously disappeared and was later found dead with her unborn child. The trial that followed took the country by storm. The series incorporates archival footage, recordings made in the courtroom, police interviews, and personal testimonials to give a multi-level re-reading of the crime and its consequences. Scott Peterson, the husband of the victim, was later arrested in spite of his claims of being innocent. Laci's friends and mother, Sharon Rocha, shared the impact the case had left on them. American Murder: Laci Peterson offers a thoughtful, emotionally explosive dive into one of the most horrifying and publicly noted murder stories of America. It surely serves as a powerful, abstract next-watch for fans of Amy Bradley Is Missing.

---

A Body in the Snow: The Trial of Karen Read

A five-episode true-crime docuseries directed by Terry Dunn-Meurer, who is also a co-creator of Unsolved Mysteries, A Body in the Snow: The Trial of Karen Read was released in March 2025. The series goes down the rabbit hole of a 2022 case where a Boston police officer named John O’Keefe was allegedly murdered by his girlfriend Karen Read. In 2024 she was declared a mistrial, and a high-stakes retrial commenced in April 2025. Despite being accused of deliberately running her SUV over her boyfriend, Read claims to be innocent. Moreover, she points accusing fingers at the police, insisting that she is a being framed by other cops at the scene. The most unique and thrilling part of this series, especially to fans of Amy Bradley Is Missing, is its deep access to the suspect. A Body in the Snow takes a personal approach and can feel uncomfortable, unlike the more distant true-crime shows. Karen is filmed as she composes herself, gets ready to go on trial, deciding what to wear, talking to fans and reporters, and and asking them about the contrast between performance and grief. She is often seen doing straight-to-camera monologues in her interviews. What you are seeing is strategy meetings, tense jury discussions in detail, and post-trial emotional meltdown instead of investigators collecting physical evidence. If you think Amy’s story in Amy Bradley Is Missing left you confused, then Karen Read’s trial will have your jaw dropped to the ground.

---

The Confession Killer

The Confession Killer is a depressing dive into just how systems can let down victims and blur the truth. This five‑episode true‑crime documentary series on Netflix examines the story of Henry Lee Lucas, who in the early 80s confessed to over 200 murders, many of which were discredited via DNA testing and inconsistencies in his timeline, decades later.

The show narrates the case of a man who yearned for the spotlight, a police department wanting to solve the cold cases as soon as possible, and anguished families seeking answers. Like Amy Bradley Is Missing, The Confession Killer shows how pressure and wishful thinking from institutional forces can bend truth. Watching Lucas’ testimonials taken at face value will remind you how cruise line investigators or witnesses ignored the warning signs in Amy’s case.

As per reports, Directors Robert Kenner and Taki Oldham took a five-year process to collect archival records, news materials, interviews with families, journalists, prosecutors, and Texas Rangers. The result is that their discussion not only ended up questioning the lies of a man, but also the failure of the system, the cognitive biases, and institutional shortcuts. The Confession Killer leaves one to think about the harmful impacts of rushing to conclusions.

---

Into the Fire: The Lost Daughter

Amy Bradley Is Missing is, without a doubt, a touching piece, but if you need another emotionally powerful, true-crime documentary in which a mother tirelessly investigates her lost daughter, Into the Fire: The Lost Daughter might be a perfect follow-up. This is a two-part Netflix true crime drama directed by Ryan White, which was released in 2024.

In 1974, Cathy Terkanian put her baby, Aundria Bowman, up for adoption and was contacted in 2010 when she was requested to provide a DNA sample during a Jane Doe investigation; it was then that she realized that her daughter had been missing for over 20 years and could've been a case of runaway. Call it maternal instincts, but Cathy, along with the help of amateur technology sleuth Carl Koppelman, began a years-long hunt for her daughter through social media campaigns, drone surveillance, interviewing peers of Aundria, and researching the history of her adoptive parents.

The docuseries slowly reveals a horrifying past: it was alleged that Aundria was sexually assaulted by her adoptive father, Dennis Bowman, and when she threatened to to file a report against him, he admitted, decades later, to killing her in during the argument and chopping and throwing her body parts in the backyard of their property in Michigan.

As a contrast to Amy Bradley Is Missing, which goes unsolved, Into the Fire: The Lost Daughter provides some sort of closure to the audience. It is a very human tale about love, loss, and the redemption of truth, and the tremendous impact a strong-willed individual can make.