7 Times a mob boss's right hand turned against him in a TV show

Mob tales on TV shows do well on loyalty, respect, and an unbreakable code, but where is the story when that loyalty falters? For years upon years, there have been TV shows delving into the dark and treacherous underworld of organized crime, but the most memorable plot turns are when the right-hand man, the closest associate of the mob boss, turns against him. These betrayals cut deeper than any external assault, exposing the vulnerable power dynamics even in the closest circles. From the traditional dramas such as The Sopranos to contemporary television shows like Tulsa King, the genre evolves, but the emotional gravity of betrayal is ageless. On any gritty TV show where mob bosses rule supreme, it isn't the cops or other gangs they are afraid of, it's the guy sitting beside them at the table.

Scenes draw viewers in, illustrating that with the best TV show, betrayal is simply a decision away. For ambition, for guilt, for fear, or revenge, the turning of a trusted right hand sets everything in motion. In this piece, we look at 7 TV moments when the mob boss's go-to confidant was his biggest menace and how those TV show betrayals forever changed the narrative.

7 Times a mob boss's right hand turned against him in a TV show

1. Paulie Gualtieri’s Brief Defiance – The Sopranos

While Paulie "Walnuts" Gualtieri is famous for being deeply loyal to Tony Soprano, there was one anxious moment when his loyalty faltered. In Season 5, Paulie's suspicion of Tony's leadership caused him to secretly ally himself with opposition elements within the family. His ambition and developing paranoia led him into dark places that made internal harmony seem at risk. But the practicality of Paulie ultimately saw him return to Tony's side, demonstrating the intricate dance of survival and power within the life of a mobster. The TV show episode demonstrates the way the strongest allies can hang in the balance of betrayal when loyalty is pitted against self-preservation.

---

2. Nacho Varga Betrays Lalo Salamanca – Better Call Saul

Nacho Varga's trajectory in Better Call Saul was complicated with inner conflict and survival. Unlike the ruthless gangsters he hung out with, Nacho acted on a need to save his father. His calculated treason against Lalo Salamanca, opening the door for assassins into Lalo's compound, played out in a stressful sequence in Season 5's finale, "Something Unforgivable." Michael Mando's performance won praise from fans for infusing complexity in a man conflicted between obligation and conscience. What is more remarkable is that Nacho's sacrifice in Season 6 is one of the show's greatest honorific exits, making a traitor a tragic hero at the end.

---

3. Karl and Chuck Betray Eli Gemstone – The Righteous Gemstones

In the TV show Season 3 of The Righteous Gemstones, Karl and Chuck Montgomery's treachery rocks the Gemstone family to its foundations. While not traditional mobsters, the Gemstones are morally corrupt televangelists who are manipulative, power-hungry, and criminally motivated. Patriarch Eli is humiliated as his nephews join forces with his rivals to control them. Their treachery, while humorously told, follows the genre of mob dramas in its focus on disloyalty within the family. What sets it apart is the series' satire of corruption in religious empires. Their betrayal of Eli isn't so much about greed, it's about generations' conflict over values, legacy, and money in a darkly comedic contemporary Southern gothic universe.

---

4. Christopher Moltisanti's Wavering Loyalty – The Sopranos

Christopher Moltisanti never strayed far from loyal protégé and a loose cannon walking a tightrope between golden boy and a threat. His descent into drug use and increasing resentment against Tony transformed him from golden boy to liability. Tony's trust was eroded following the mishandling of jobs and emotional fragility. By Season 6, Tony regarded him as a threat instead of an heir, which climaxed in the shocking scene in which he kills Christopher by suffocating him after a car accident. This legislation wasn't inspired by overt betrayal, but by decades of misinformation and tension coming to a head. Christopher's storyline still inspires controversy among fans. Was he a traitor or just a tragic victim of a rotten system?

---

5. Tig Trager Questions Clay Morrow’s Leadership – Sons of Anarchy

Tig Trager used to be fiercely devoted to Clay Morrow, SAMCRO's brutal president. But with time, Clay's increasingly unstable and self-centered choices, particularly the killing of Piney Winston and the deceit of fellow members, broke that devotion. Tig's moral compass shifted, and in later seasons, he started taking sides with Jax Teller's club vision. His transformation wasn't boisterous or explosive; it was quiet, punctuated by stares, silences, and hesitation. This was a personal betrayal, not merely club politics but emotional evolution. It revealed that in outlaw brotherhoods, transformation often begins subtly with an unspoken glance that means, "I can no longer follow you."

---

6. Goodie's Potential Betrayal of Dwight – Tulsa King

In the TV show Tulsa King, Goodie Carangi’s loyalty to Dwight Manfredi wavers when pressure mounts from both New York and local rivals. While he starts as Dwight’s right-hand man, his eventual confession about keeping secrets behind Dwight’s back hints at a subtle but deep betrayal. This conflict comes to a head in Season 2 as Dwight begins to question the loyalty of everyone around him. What's interesting here is the series' contemporary twist on mafia politics, mixing honor-school values with today's confusing allegiances. Goodie's treason isn't merely about territory, it's about surviving in a new world where the rules continuously change.

---

7. Luca Changretta’s Inside Help – Peaky Blinders

In the TV show Peaky Blinders Season 4, Luca Changretta initiates a full-blown vendetta against the Shelbys, yet what places him ahead is insider aid. Although technically an outsider, Luca takes advantage of cracks inside Tommy Shelby's operation, feeding upon old resentments and fissures. His cunning strategy turns the Shelbys' close-knit unit on its head, and a few members, such as Michael, briefly find temptation in betrayal. This betrayal theme is unique in that it's linked with family and ambition instead of mere criminal profit. Changretta's plan demonstrates that even the most intimidating bosses tumble if trust breaks down within.

---

Betrayal in a mob-centric TV show isn’t just a plot device, it’s a defining moment that reshapes power dynamics and character arcs. These shocking turns by trusted lieutenants remind viewers that in the criminal underworld, loyalty is both currency and illusion. From calculated schemes to emotional breakdowns, each betrayal we’ve seen in these TV shows leaves a lasting impact,t proving that the greatest threats often come from within. As television shows continue to stretch the limits of narrative, the struggle between trust and betrayal is still a potent force. And when the right hand turns, even the most notorious mob bosses can tumble.