7 true crime docuseries to hop on to next if Murdaugh: Death in the Family got you hooked

Murdaugh: Death in the Family is a true crime drama series based on the story of Alex Murdaugh, South Carolina's most famous personal injury attorney. Alex was found guilty in 2023 due to the murders of his son, Paul, and his wife, Maggie. This documentary series is based on Mandy Matney's Murdaugh Murders Podcast.

Brittany Snow played Mandy. She followed the case closely and wrote about it as it happened. Many times, she shared new facts before anyone else did. Find out the entire Murdaugh family tree exclusively on Soap Central.

The viewers should see a few equally captivating true crime docuseries if Murdaugh: Death in the Family drew you into its web of mystery and corruption. Similar to the tone and complexity of the Murdaugh story, each of these shows includes intense investigations, startling revelations, and profound familial or systemic secrets.

Here's a list of seven true crime docuseries to hop on to next if Murdaugh: Death in the Family got you hooked.

Disclaimer: This article contains the writer's opinion. Readers’ discretion is advised.

---

7 true crime docuseries to hop on to next if Murdaugh: Death in the Family got you hooked

7. Stolen Youth: Inside the Cult at Sarah Lawrence (2023)

Stolen Youth: Inside the Cult at Sarah Lawrence is a disturbing true crime docuseries that uncovers the story of Larry Ray, who manipulated a group of students at Sarah Lawrence College. The story follows how Ray, the father of one of the students, exploited and victimized the friends of the girls in their campus accommodation after settling in.

Viewers saw that he developed a tiny cult. Ray manipulated young adults with guilt and mind games to make them think they hurt him and gave him millions. Similar to Murdaugh: Death in the Family, it shows how ignoring power and charm can destroy trust and family. Even freedom and places that feel safe can suddenly become a nightmare.

---

6. Cold Case: The Tylenol Murders (2025)

This crime docuseries re-analyzes the horrific case that shook America's confidence in medicine. In 1982, seven people in Chicago were murdered after consuming packets of Tylenol that were secretly poisoned with deadly cyanide. The entire country flew into a state of fear, sparking one of the largest criminal investigations in history.

The new Netflix show chronicles the efforts the police and the FBI made in search of the killer, focusing initially on one suspect, James Lewis, who composed a demand letter for money to call off the killings. Lewis was brought in, but he always insisted he was framed and refused to be the killer.

The show approaches storytelling with sensitivity through the accounts of survivors, loved ones, and crime experts. The audience is given a sense of how the disaster resulted in new regulations and changed the way pharmaceuticals were packaged and sold. The show illustrates how crime erodes trust in people and things that should be safe, like Murdaugh: Death in the Family.

---

5. Let the Devil In (2025)

Let the Devil In is a haunting docuseries about fear in a small town in New Jersey in 1987. It explores the death of a religious woman and the disappearance of her son. Locals and the police started suspecting satanic rituals and that the evil was looming in their own backyard. The show compiles the facts regarding her death and the boy's disappearance, with the aid of interviews and evidence from family members, police, and townsfolk.

Viewers witness how the rumor about satanic cults took off and how fear affected the way people treated one another. The crime docuseries showed viewers how, in some cases, believing in evil can be more devastating than the facts. Like Murdaugh: Death in the Family, the story of Let the Devil In illustrates how doubt and gossip overcome and obstruct the pursuit of the truth. At its core, it is a story about families ripped apart by secrets and loss.

---

4. The Yogurt Shop Murders (2025)

Yogurt Shop Murders portrayed the infamous 1991 murder in Austin, Texas. Four teen girls were killed after closing up at a community yogurt shop, and the city was in a state of confusion and shock. In this crime docuseries, the case unfolds in fresh interviews with police, family members, and experts who spent years investigating the case.

Evidence and facts are revealed, allowing the audience to see how blunders and uncertainty in the inquiry kept the case stationary for so many years. It also shows how the death touched the families irrevocably. Similar to the case of Murdaugh: Death in the Family, the story of Yogurt Shop Murders concerns great sadness and the pursuit of justice in close-knit families. Yogurt Shop Murders reminds viewers that crime does more than victimize the victim and instead batters communities and loved ones for years after.

---

3. Death Apartment: What Happened to Greenberg? (2025)

This crime docuseries is a case study on the unsolved murder of a schoolteacher, Ellen Greenberg, who was discovered dead with approximately 20 stab wounds in her apartment. At first, her death was declared a suicide, especially when her relatives believed that she had been killed. The family is questioning the police reports as she was found dead in a locked apartment. There is no indication of a fight.

Death Apartment: What Happened to Greenberg? investigates additional evidence and family interviews, medical specialists, and eyewitnesses. A new autopsy that looked into her death revealed that she may have been murdered by someone else. However, the Philadelphia Medical Examiner's Office confirmed the first verdict as a suicide despite the lack of evidence to support a murder case.

Greenberg's family is still demanding justice, asserting that important pieces of evidence have been ignored or disregarded. The case remains unresolved, and the series highlights the conflicting perspectives and ongoing pursuit of truth.

---

2. American Murder: Gabby Petito (2025)

American Murder: Gabby Petito is a Netflix crime docuseries based on the lives of Gabby Petito and her fiancè, Brian Laundrie. The couple set out on a cross-country van tour, documenting their experiences on social media. The journey appeared exciting but tragic when Gabby went missing in the summer of 2021. The case attracted nationwide interest when the family reported the disappearance.

The couple was once halted by the police during the tour when someone called in a fight. Gabby confessed to striking Brian, but the police left without taking considerable action. Gabby's dead body was discovered after weeks of quiet in Wyoming's Grand Teton National Park. Brian later committed suicide in Florida and left behind a confession letter for the murder of Gabby.

The documentary depicts the anguish and questions from the family about Brian's parents' involvement in the case. It portrays dark aspects of domestic violence and family complications, like in the case of Murdaugh: Death in the Family.

---

1. Amy Bradley is Missing (2025)

Amy Bradley Is Missing is a crime docuseries in which a young woman mysteriously disappeared in 1998 while the family was on a Caribbean cruise. Amy was celebrating the holidays with her family when she mysteriously went missing aboard the vessel. The documentary examines numerous theories behind the disappearance, including crime and potential human trafficking. It includes interviews with Amy's family members, who ceased to search for answers.

The missing person mystery remains unresolved to this day. The series utilizes family videos and accounts from survivors in keeping Amy's legacy alive. Similar to Murdaugh: Death in the Family, it deals with the struggle in a family with heartbreak and the abject need to find the truth. It illustrates how disappearance can cause lasting scars and unresolved questions among all the people involved.

---

Follow Soap Central for more.