9 Cristin Milioti movies and TV shows to watch after her Emmy-winning role in The Penguin

Cristin Milioti with her Emmy award for her performance in The Penguin | Image via Television Academy
Cristin Milioti with her Emmy award for her performance in The Penguin | Image via Television Academy

If you are a fan or devotee of Cristin Milioti, you will find this article interesting. Cristin Milioti is an American actress best known for her role as Sofia Falcone in HBO's criminal drama series The Penguin (2024). She took home the Primetime Emmy for Outstanding Lead Actress in a Limited Series at the 77th Primetime Emmy Awards last Sunday, September 14, 2025. After receiving the award, she said,

"It’s very hard to make sense of being alive right now in this world, and so I’m deeply grateful for the bright spots"

Fans are revisiting her finest work following her Emmy-winning performance in The Penguin. Aside from The Penguin (2024), she has worked on other television episodes and films. She brings honesty and charm into every scene, whether it's a romantic comedy or a serious drama. This article discusses 9 films and television shows starring Cristin Milioti.

Disclaimer: This article is based on the author's opinions. Reader discretion is advised.


Here is the list of the 9 Cristin Milioti movies and TV shows to watch after her Emmy-winning role in The Penguin:

9. How I Met Your Mother (2013-2014)

Cristin Milioti as Tracy McConnell | Image via Netflix
Cristin Milioti as Tracy McConnell | Image via Netflix

How I Met Your Mother is a heartfelt comedy-drama about the long search for a life partner, love, and friendship. The television series is set in New York and presents a long story about a man's meeting with his children's mother. There were flashbacks, humor, and feelings that viewers saw. These three components were applied to this TV show to produce a set of characters that developed and evolved. Cristin Milioti played the role of the Mother (Tracy McConnell). Tracy appears near the end of the series, adding warmth and coherence to the story's climax. Milioti's character is a music lover who plays bass and serves as a link between the key characters.

In Season 9, Tracy stops Ted from leaving during their first kiss. Her acting in How I Met Your Mother is soft and natural in comparison to a dramatic scene in The Penguin. Tracy is popular among fans because she grounds comedy and drama using an honest on-screen character, and these small things do matter. Her voice and timing are memorable while she played the role.


8. The Wolf of Wall Street (2013)

Cristin Milioti as Teresa Petrillo | Image via Apple TV
Cristin Milioti as Teresa Petrillo | Image via Apple TV

The Wolf of Wall Street is a loud and wild film about greed, excess, and the rise and fall of a stockbroker who chases money at any cost. The film is based on a man who builds a huge firm with wild parties, dubious deals, and drug-fueled energy. The film presented glamour and devastation through fast-paced scenes and dark comedy. Consequently, it amazed and captivated the audience. Cristin Milioti plays a minor yet significant role as Teresa Petrillo. One of her famous dialogues from the movie

"There is no such thing as bad publicity. Your hair looks good."

captivated the hearts of the audience. Teresa's appearance added dimension and realism to the film, evoking everyday existence during lunacy. We've seen her appear in a situation, putting a human face on decisions that lead to disaster. When compared to an intense moment in The Penguin, her work is quieter. Audiences love how she can make brief screen time feel complete and real. She brings truth.


7. Palm Springs (2020)

Cristin Milioti as Sarah | Image via Prime Video
Cristin Milioti as Sarah | Image via Prime Video

Palm Springs is a humorous romantic comedy that plays with time loop concepts and the minor inconveniences of being human. The film follows two wedding guests who meet by chance and then repeat the same day. It combines dark humor with sensitive moments, and it explores what it means to live completely when time is repeated. Cristin Milioti plays Sarah, a woman who is reluctant at first but who grows into risk and warmth. Her performance gives the film a beating human heart among the clever plot tricks.

In a scene where she confesses her fear, she is both raw and comic with perfect timing. She enters the room and chuckles to Nyles and says,

"Didn't work! Life is meaningless. Let's get the f*ck outta here."

When compared to a fierce scene in The Penguin, her work in Palm Springs shows a range from quiet charm to jagged edges. Fans love her because she can be playful and wounded in the same breath. That mix makes her scenes feel honest and memorable.


6. Fargo Season 2 (2015)

Cristin Milioti plays Betsy Solverson in Fargo Season 2 | Image via Prime Video
Cristin Milioti plays Betsy Solverson in Fargo Season 2 | Image via Prime Video

The Fargo season 2 is a TV series that focuses on the Midwest in 1979 as a criminal drama. The show explores family obligation, small-town violence, and the way people cope with dreadful circumstances. Cristin Milioti stars as Betsy Solverson, the kind wife of a state trooper and the mother of one of the future investigators. Her personality adds a cool and profound humanity to what is also a dark crime and a high-tension story. She shows love, strength, and quiet sadness as the plot moves toward loss and meaning. In the show, she says to Noreen,

"Ugh, I don't care if he's from Mars. Nobody with any sense would say something that foolish. We're put on this earth to do a job."

When you compare this scene to an unhinged scene in The Penguin, the contrast reveals how wide her skill set is. Audiences respond because she makes small domestic acts hold enormous emotion.


5. Made for Love (2021-2022)

Cristin Milioti as Hazel Green | Image via Prime Video
Cristin Milioti as Hazel Green | Image via Prime Video

Made for Love is a dark comic series about technology, love, and the horror of losing privacy in a modern world. It follows a woman who escapes a controlling ten-year marriage to a tech billionaire only to discover he installed a device in her brain. The technology allowed him to track her emotions and position in real time, resulting in both danger and odd comedy. Cristin Milioti stars as Hazel Green, who must find new ground while the world watches. She plays fear, anger, pity, and sharp wit in equal measure, and she gives the story its beating heart.

In Season 1, Episode 8, Hazel confronts her husband, combining rage with humorous distancing in a way that wounds deeply. Her performance in Made for Love reveals both humorous skill and intense emotional stakes, in contrast to a violent moment in The Penguin. Audiences love how she makes strange premises feel real and how she keeps us wanting to see what she will do next. Her acting lingers long after the episode is over as well.


4. Black Mirror (2011-Present)

Cristin Milioti in Black Mirror | Image via Netflix
Cristin Milioti in Black Mirror | Image via Netflix

Black Mirror is a dark anthology series that highlights the influence of technology on humanity. Each episode is standalone and imagines a future where inventions bring both happiness and suffering. Cristin Milioti stars in the episode USS Callister, where she plays Nanette Cole. Her character is intelligent, brave, and fights back against control inside a digital game world.

In Season 4, Nanette confronts her harsh boss, showing her strength and humanity. In this episode, viewers will forever recall one of her famous sentences, which is,

"Okay, stealing my p*ssy is a red fucking line."

This scene from Black Mirror illustrates her ability to portray both confidence and terror, which is different from her part in The Penguin. Audiences love her because she brings heart to strange, futuristic settings, making them feel real.


3. The Sopranos (2007)

Cristin Milioti as Catherine Sacrimoni | Image via Hotstar
Cristin Milioti as Catherine Sacrimoni | Image via Hotstar

The Sopranos is a criminal drama film that depicts the life of Tony Soprano, a mob boss who struggles to juggle family obligations with a brutal underworld. The show mixes crime, power, and deep human conflict. Cristin Milioti features in the last season as the daughter of a mobster, Catherine Sacrimoni. Her character is short-lived, yet she reveals love and fidelity within a stressful family background.

In Season 6, she helps her family amid difficult times with quiet dignity. When compared to her strong work in The Penguin, it shows how she can shift from soft support to sharp force. Fans love her range and truth in even the smallest roles.


2. The Resort (2022)

The Resort | Image via Prime Video
The Resort | Image via Prime Video

The Resort is a mystery, drama, and comedy about a couple on vacation who uncover a strange disappearance. It is a combination of romance, criminality, and secrets. Cristin Milioti stars as Emma. In the show, Milioti assesses Emma and says,

"I don't think Emma is therapied at all."

In Season 1, Episode 7, Emma is unhappy in her marriage but believes that uncovering the mystery from 15 years ago will fill her with a sense of emptiness. She is a funny and serious person when her character faces a threat and is fighting with herself.


1. The Penguin (2024)

Cristin Milioti as Sofia Falcone in The Penguin | Image via Hotstar
Cristin Milioti as Sofia Falcone in The Penguin | Image via Hotstar

The Penguin is a crime drama set in Gotham after the events of The Batman. It follows Oswald Cobblepot as he rises in the criminal world. Cristin Milioti plays Sofia Falcone, who is caught between family duty and her own ambition. She brings firepower and cunning to every scene as she faces Penguin and other rivals. Check out her clipping of the Emmy-winning moment on the verified Instagram page, "cbstv",

She appears in episode 4 of the first season, displaying clear mastery & a frightening display of rage. In The Penguin, Cristin Milioti is the audience's favorite character because she is intense and emotive, which sticks out in the violent environment of Gotham.


The list above underlined Cristin Milioti's ability to transition between mystery, comedy, and drama. Each position allowed her the chance to showcase something different. Whether she plays a gentle wife or a furious rival, she can make every scene count. Her skill remained with spectators long after the credits rolled.

Edited by Zainab Shaikh