A Dexter spin-off based on the Trinity has now been scrapped

The Dexter fan base has endured numerous ups and downs: new seasons, spin-offs, reboots, and endless rumors. Among the most recently discussed ideas was the prequel about the Trinity Killer that examined Arthur Mitchell’s history and how he became this dangerous individual.

Things got more and more exciting as writers were reported to have completed scripts and even suggested that John Lithgow might come back somehow. However, the project was quietly dropped. The intended Trinity series is no longer in development as the Dexter franchise changes priorities and makes some off-screen revamps.

What happened to the Trinity prequel

The intended Trinity prequel had been under discussion long enough, and even scripts were reportedly prepared. Nonetheless, it never received the official green light, and now that seems all the more improbable.

The show had first been announced in 2024 and was even said to be “in development” at Showtime/Paramount+. Fans and news outlets reported on the project’s progress, only to see it stalled over and over again.

Then everything went awry when the company started concentrating on other Dexter projects such as Dexter: Resurrection and addressed the turbulent path of Dexter: Original Sin. Creators and writers who envisioned expanding the Dexter universe had their plans abruptly scrapped or revised. Some of the showrunners themselves admitted that they were dissatisfied with the way the Trinity prequel was finally cancelled in August 2025.

Why was the Dexter spinoff about the Trinity cancelled

The entertainment business can be unstable at times. A show may receive acclaim among critics and viewers but still be cancelled when the bosses have a different idea that they believe will bring in more revenue.

That is what appears to have happened with Dexter: Original Sin and, subsequently, the Trinity prequel. Paramount has been dealing with mergers and leadership changes, and that massive shift usually involves reducing down to one major project. In the case of the Dexter franchise, it was announced that the prequel was abandoned in favor of the new series Resurrection, which features Michael C. Hall.

It is also poor taste when a company promises new shows and then ends them, and some of the creators have come forward to complain about the bewildering manner in which this was done. After all, it is a typical Hollywood narrative: when the scripts and talent were available, the studio failed to give it a thumbs-up.

What this means for the fans and the franchise

John Lithgow’s Trinity remains one of the most memorable villains that Dexter has faced, and so when the idea of a show about his history was discussed, no wonder scripts were written. To the Dexter fans, it is a mixed message: it is disappointing at this moment, but there is always a sliver of hope in the future. Still, don’t expect it soon.

Instead of coming up with a collection of spin-offs, Paramount has decided to concentrate on Dexter: Resurrection with Michael C. Hall. Viewers are crying foul: there are online petitions and much talk. However, studios hardly ever change their minds unless under immense, protracted pressure or a massive change of leadership or business strategy.

The good news? Dexter isn’t going away. Paramount has indicated that it would like to continue with Dexter stories, but at a smaller scale in the meantime. And those Trinity scripts are not lost permanently; they may be brought back in case the company changes its strategies or streaming possibilities in the future.

Trending

For more such insights on the Dexter-verse, keep following SoapCentral.

×

Was this article helpful?

Thank You for feedback