A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms might face the same criticism that Game of Thrones did, details explored in-depth

A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms is arriving next year, expanding George R.R. Martin’s fantasy world.

Over the years, Martin's Westeros has become a shared space for readers, viewers, and showrunners alike, but with expansion, expectations also mount.

A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms enters this space with a very different tone from Game of Thrones. It is different from Game of Thrones in many ways. Firstly, the latter has a shorter narrative length and the stakes are lower. However, the upcoming HBO series may encounter a familiar criticism tied to unfinished source material.

The challenge of unfinished materials for A Knight Of The Seven Kingdoms

A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms is adapted from three published novellas by Martin: The Hedge Knight from 1998, The Sworn Sword from 2003, and The Mystery Knight from 2010. These stories follow Ser Duncan the Tall and his young squire, Egg, through smaller-scale adventures across Westeros.

The novella format makes it a suitable source material for television adaptation. However, they also represent the full extent of the finished Dunk and Egg narrative. Martin has long expressed interest in writing more on these characters but they have not been finished.

Martin himself has commented on this challenge in a blog post where he explained that if The Hedge Knight adaptation is successful, the plan would be to adapt the remaining two novellas as well. That process would take several years.

"If 'The Hedge Knight' turns out as well as we hope it will, our hope would be to go on and adapt 'The Sworn Sword' and 'The Mystery Knight' as well. That will take a few years. Then comes the hard part. Before we reach the end of the published stories, I will need to find time to write all the other 'Dunk & Egg' novellas that I have planned."

However, this alone may not take too much away from the standing of A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms. In fact, the series’s limited scope may work in its favor.

Unlike Game of Thrones, which slowly builds the tale towards a complex narrative ending, the Dunk and Egg stories are intentionally simple. They focus on personal themes more than political turmoils and power struggles.

Because of that design, adapting only the existing novellas could still result in a satisfying run. Three seasons, one for each story, would not feel incomplete. Instead, it would reflect the material as it exists.

The by-yearly approach may work in favor of A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms

There is also a logistical shift at HBO that may help. The network plans to take a biannual approach to its Game of Thrones-related projects. That slower release schedule gives Martin more time than he had during the original series’ run, even if it does not fully resolve the underlying issue.

Still, Martin’s workload remains considerable. The Winds of Winter is only the penultimate novel in A Song of Ice and Fire. Fire & Blood, from which originates the House of the Dragon, is also unfinished. Adding new Dunk and Egg novellas to that list highlights how ambitious the overall plan remains.

He expressed,

"I just need to finish 'The Winds of Winter,' and then do either 'A Dream of Spring' or volume two of 'Fire & Blood,' and slip in a new 'Dunk & Egg' between each of those in my copious spare time ... and that will keep me ahead of [showrunner Ira Parker] and his merry crew ... for a few more years. Well, I will worry about that tomorrow. Today, we're celebrating. Dunk & Egg are coming."

Trending

The series will feature an ensemble cast, including:

• Youssef Kerkour as Steely Pate
• Daniel Monks as Ser Manfred Dondarrion
• Shaun Thomas as Raymun Fossoway
• Daniel Ings as Ser Lyonel Baratheon
• Sam Spruell as Prince Maekar Targaryen
• Edward Ashley as Ser Steffon Fossoway
• Tom Vaughan-Lawlor as Plummer
• Danny Webb as Ser Arlan of Pennytree
• Peter Claffey as Ser Duncan the Tall/'Dunk'
• Dexter Sol Ansell as Prince Aegon 'Egg' Targaryen
• Finn Bennett as Prince Aerion 'Brightflame' Targaryen
• Bertie Carvel as Crown Prince Baelor 'Breakspear' Targaryen
• Tanzyn Crawford as Tanselle
• Henry Ashton plays Daeron Targaryen

×

Was this article helpful?

Thank You for feedback