American Idol Season 23: Who all made it to the Top 5? List explored

The Top 5 contestants for American Idol Season 23 have been formally announced as the show draws to a close. The competition has been reduced to five exceptional performers who have continuously amazed the judges and audience after weeks of performances, eliminations, and emotional highs and lows. The pressure is greater than ever, with only one week till the big finale.

Strong performances in episode 17 contributed to the final lineup's stability. In front of a live audience, contestants gave their all as they competed for a place in the finale. With performers from a variety of genres, including upbeat songs and soulful ballads, the event produced an evening full of memorable moments.

Slater Nalley, Breanna Nix, John Foster, Jamal Roberts, and Thunderstorm Artis are the five competitors who have advanced to the finals. It is one of the most competitive finales in recent Idol history because each has demonstrated development, charm, and vocal range throughout the season. As the countdown to choose the next American Idol begins, fans have already flocked to social media to share their favorites and predictions.

Top 5 finalists of American Idol Season 23 Episode 17

In episode 17 of American Idol Season 23, the Top 7 contestants got on stage to perform some of their childhood favorites from the magical world of Disney. As the day ended, America got its top 5. Slater Nalley solidified his status as the one to beat after his performance of The Lion King’s “Can You Feel the Love Tonight” earned him a standing ovation from the audience and the judges. Breanna Nix’s bare-bones acoustic take on “Reflection” from Mulan earned her fans by fleshing out the emotionally vulnerable side she first revealed during the show’s callbacks round.

John Foster gave a dynamic performance of "Almost There" from The Princess and the Frog that showcased his stage presence and vocal dexterity. Jamal Roberts, meanwhile, wowed everyone with a very genuine rendition of Hercules’ “Go the Distance,” showing off his vocal range and control. A gamble that paid off, Thunderstorm Artis’ version of “Colors of the Wind” from Pocahontas earned accolades from the judges for its originality and technical proficiency.

These five have been a roomful of personalities and upward swing development all season , and their last episodes have only added excitement for a conclusion. Each contestant made a good case for why he or she should emerge as the next American Idol.

Who got eliminated on American Idol Season 23 Episode 17?

American Idol Season 23's Episode 17 saw the departure of two contestants just one week before the grand finale. The nationwide voting results led to the elimination of Gabby Rey and Mattie Tryon following their performances on Disney Night. Mattie delivered an emotionally resonant and vocally strong rendition of Coco's "Remember Me," earning praise for the moving quality of her performance.

Meanwhile, Gabby showcased her powerful vocal range with "How Far I'll Go" from Moana, though the judges felt her performance lacked the standout moment needed to advance in the competition. Despite their admirable efforts, neither contestant secured enough votes to continue to the finale.

Following their elimination, Slater Nalley, Breanna Nix, John Foster, Jamal Roberts, and Thunderstorm Artis were formally named the Top 5 finalists. With their own musical identities and performing styles, these competitors now enter the competition's last stages. As America gets ready to choose its new American Idol, the forthcoming finals promise fantastic performances and intense competition.

Trending

Stay tuned to ABC to watch American Idol Season 23 next Sunday on May 18, 2025, at 8/7c.

×

Was this article helpful?

Thank You for feedback