And Just Like That Season 3: Redditors have thoughts on Episode 5, and they’re not holding back

Reddit left And Just Like That in flames after a moment, leaving viewers stunned and more than a little weirded out.

When you’re a guest, there are a few things you just don’t do. Like, say, raiding your host’s fridge at 2 AM without asking. Or, even worse, walking around naked like it’s your own place. It’s not about being a prude; it’s about respect.

Friends don’t let friends scar each other with unexpected nudity. Sure, people are more relaxed these days, but when you're not alone or in your own space, you owe it to others to cover up.

Maybe. Maybe in certain households, with certain friends, it’s no big deal. But from what Reddit has to say, this wasn’t that kind of situation. It felt less “free spirit” and more “what the actual hell are you doing?”

This all started from a user ranting about someone (presumably Miranda) just casually strolling around her friend’s house in the buff. The post blew up because, honestly, who does that?

Redditors didn’t hold back. One of the standout lines was:

“Why would you just walk around fully naked in the main areas in your friend’s house like put on your pajamas or house coat or something instead of walking around like you're a ghost with dementia.”

Oof. Harsh words, but they captured exactly what people were thinking.

Let’s not forget Miranda casually eating the last yogurt, banana, and that very specific Mexican Coke. These aren’t world-ending offenses, but combined? Yeah, viewers were done with her.

“Carrie stomping around in heels 24/7 knowing she has a downstairs neighbor and thinking it’s a ‘cute quirky relatable’ moment…”

It’s giving self-centered chic, and people aren’t charmed anymore.

“Things rich people don't know how to get: chocolate, bug spray, rugs, bananas, yogurt, tables, couches, a f***ing CLUE.”

Need we say more?

---

Miranda’s fall from Grace in And Just Like That

Remember when Miranda was the level-headed one? Now, Redditors can’t stand her screen time. She's become the person nobody wants at brunch.

She’s still beautiful, still fashionable, but still only talking about herself.

“Carrie always bringing the conversation back to her.”

The fans noticed in And Just Like That. And they’re not impressed.

The magic that once made Sex and the City feel like your favorite gossip session is gone. Now it feels like watching wealthy roommates who don’t like each other anymore.

There were glimmers, like the pool scene between LTW and Charlotte, but they were drowned out by drama and awkwardness.

“Jesus, the plot lines here are paper thin at this point... Ugh. I feel like I can predict them all.”

Honestly? Same.

One Redditor predicts about And Just Like That:

“Harry's cancer is going to progress rapidly, and he's gonna die.”

If that's the route the show takes, buckle up in And Just Like That.

Say what you want, but they still dress like icons.

That includes forks, glasses, and apparently common sense.

“Who starts cooking s’mores when the sun is out midday?”

Great question. Anyone?

And Just Like That is toeing a fine line between nostalgic indulgence and total disaster. While the show occasionally nails the aesthetic and gives us moments of heart, fans are tired of the weird character choices, thin plots, and ridiculous behavior.

---

For more updates, keep reading Soap Central