'%20x='0'%20y='0'%20height='100%25'%20width='100%25'%20%0A%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20xlink%3Ahref=''%3E%3C/image%3E%3C/svg%3E)
Charlie Hunnam plays Ed Gein in Netflix's Monster: The Ed Gein Story, hoping to deliver a performance "as close as possible" to Gein himself. Hunnam chose realism over horror theatrics, instead seeking to illuminate mundane habits, mannerisms, and psychological depth. According to Netflix Tadum, he said,
"I wanted to get as close as possible to who Ed was, to do him justice, and for this thing to feel authentic"
He added,
"This is going to be the really human, tender, unflinching, no-holds-barred exploration of who Ed was and what he did. But who he was being at the center of it, rather than what he did."
His method ensures that the character is represented within the context of research fact rather than on the premise of the dramatization of character. Hunnam also underwent physical transformation, shedding over 30 pounds and assuming Gein's Wisconsin accent and soft tone of voice, which he attributed to Gein's complex relationship with his mother. This allowed him to give a delicate, psychologically authentic portrayal of Ed Gein.
Who was Ed Gein?
Ed Gein, who was born in 1906 in La Crosse, Wisconsin, was notorious in the 1950s for having murdered two verified individuals and practicing grave robbing. His victims included Mary Hogan, a tavern proprietor, and Bernice Worden, who owned a hardware store.
Although his offenses were few in number, they were of an extremely violent sort and penetrated deeply into American society, resulting in books, films, and mainstream popularity of true crime. In spite of his fame, his life was intensely isolated, under the strict, dictatorial dominance of his mother, and alone in rural isolation.
His criminal activity was a mix of psychological illness, social isolation, and a highly dysfunctional family life. Knowing Gein's environment, relationships, and mental illness issues is vital in putting his actions into context.
The Netflix adaptation: Intentions and creative liberties
Netflix's Monster: The Ed Gein Story tries to juxtapose history with dramatization. Although the series pays respect to Ed Gein's psychological complexity and childhood, there are several fictionized or dramatized aspects within the series:
Henry Gein's death
The series shows him murdering his brother Henry in a duel of violence. In actual history, Henry Gein passed away because of accidental asphyxiation from a heart attack in 1944. Ed did try to hide during the fight with his brother, but there is no indication of murder. This is a dramatization and increases tension, but is not a historical account.
Other murders and victims
Even though Ed Gein did confess to having murdered two women, the show brings in other victims, including a babysitter, Evelyn Hartley, and two hunters on his property. All these are fictionalized; there is no such historical occurrence where Gein is implicated with them. This is a plot twist, but not one based on actual events.
Suggested inspiration sources
The program suggests Gein was inspired by Nazi war criminals, specifically Ilse Koch, for her brutal actions during the Holocaust. Though Gein's interest in death and gruesome images is mentioned, no link to Koch or any other war criminals is attributed to any action of his. The show's comparison is thematic, not factual.
Fictionalized scenes
The show features surrealistic and artistic scenes, such as "afterlife" episodes, party dances, and fantasized encounters with pop culture icons. Such scenes are narrative devices and not historical events. In like manner, suggestions of romantic or s*xual relationships with his victims do not have a historical basis.
Tone and portrayal
Criticisms are made that the series whitewashes his image, portraying him as a victim of abuse by his mother and mental illness. While both were true in his life, dramatization may well reduce his brutality and initiative.
These choices are better for a narrative but are far from pure factual accounts.
Charlie Hunnam's preparation for accuracy
Despite these dramatizations, Charlie Hunnam's training was geared toward realistic behavioral and psychological representation. He:
Read court documents, newspaper pieces, and photographs of Ed Gein.
Analyzed rare audio tapes in order to understand Gein's speech patterns and accent.
Lost 30 pounds to physically emulate Gein.
Mastered Gein's soft Wisconsin accent.
Concentrated on subtle movement, posture, and expression to bring isolation and inner conflict to life.
Hunnam's focus was to capture him as a psychologically complex human being, rather than hyping horror elements.
Historical accuracy in production
The production design team ensured realism in the depiction of Wisconsin in the 1950s, such as:
Realistic clothing modeled the rural fashion of the times.
Richly detailed set designs, such as Gein's farmhouse and family home.
Props true to the historical account of Gein's life.
These decisions function to ground the story in fact detail, even where narrative license is given elsewhere.
The actual crimes of Ed Gein
Ed Gein's documented criminal acts include:
The murders of Bernice Worden and Mary Hogan.
Exhumation from cemeteries within the locale, making objects of human remains.
These killings, though horrific, were small in scope. They were part of a cultural heritage that shaped horror fiction and film. Netflix's series delivers these killings but still focuses on the background, like mental illness, loneliness, and domestic trauma.
Comparison of the series to actual life history
Although Netflix does indulge in some dramatization, the psychological and behavioral facts of Ed Gein are from facts. The deviations are:
Appreciation for these artistic freedoms is necessary for audiences who want an accurate depiction of the life and actions of Ed Gein.
Cultural impact and legacy
The actions, though few in number, had an enduring impact:
Inspired timeless horror movies such as Silence of the Lambs, Psycho, and The Texas Chainsaw Massacre.
Summoned controversy surrounding mental illness, isolation, and the role in crime commission.
Long remains a subject of interest to true crime buffs and researchers.
The Netflix series is part of this tradition by combining fact and fiction, and viewers have to dig through established history and artistic license.
Why this portrayal matters
Charlie Hunnam's performance illustrates the possibility of research-based, psychologically informed acting in depicting legendary figures from history. Monster: The Ed Gein Story does make some creative choices with the story, but Hunnam's acting and the production's observation of historical fact offer a factual foundation.
Trending
An appreciation of how dramatized content differs from history will enable the audience to enjoy the human complexity and understand the creative decisions made in creating his story.
Also read: What does the final line of Monster: The Ed Gein Story mean, the director answers
Reply
