“Baby steps in the sass department” American Idol judge Carrie Underwood notes Mattie Pruitt’s progress before saving her

On May 5, 2025, the most recent episode of American Idol Season 23 aired. As the competition dwindled to its top 7, there was tension and difficult choices. Judge Carrie Underwood gave constructive criticism following Tennessee native Mattie Pruitt's performance of Jessie Murph's Always Been You during the "Judge's Song Contest" themed episode, pointing out a continued need for improvement.

"We're taking baby steps in the sass department, and we just want more," Underwood remarked, continuing her mentorship of the young singer.

Sixteen-year-old Mattie Pruitt found herself in a tense spot during the latest American Idol episode, landing in the bottom two alongside Josh King after America’s live votes rolled in. In a dramatic moment, all three judges (Luke Bryan, Lionel Richie, and Carrie Underwood) stepped in to unanimously save Pruitt, pushing her through to the Top 7.

Sadly, that meant the end of the road for King, despite his heartfelt take on Michael Bublé’s Home. It was a rollercoaster night that highlighted both Pruitt’s promise and the room she still has to grow, but one thing’s for sure: she’s still in the fight.

American Idol judge Carrie Underwood’s consistent coaching pays off

Carrie Underwood's feedback to Mattie Pruitt reflects a consistent theme in her coaching. This isn't the first time the country superstar has encouraged Pruitt to find her "sass." During an April 27 performance of "Piece of My Heart," Underwood was more direct, telling Pruitt:

"If there's anything I can say to you, (it's) you've gotta find your sass. You need some sass, girl, come on!"

This guidance from a former Idol winner carries particular weight. Underwood has maintained a careful balance in her judging approach, offering honest critique without veering into Simon Cowell territory. Her consistent focus on Pruitt's performance style suggests she sees significant potential in the young singer.

Luke Bryan echoed similar sentiments following Pruitt's May 5 performance, adding:

"Try to channel that sass, but vocally it was amazing."

Pruitt's journey to American Idol has unexpected connections to the judging panel. She initially auditioned alongside country singer Craig Campbell, who previously played in Luke Bryan's band before launching his successful solo career.

Campbell revealed to Taste of Country that his family and Pruitt's family live in the same town, explaining their connection. This small-world relationship adds an interesting layer to Pruitt's story, though the judges have maintained professional objectivity in their assessments.

Following her American Idol audition, Underwood had advised Pruitt to gain experience on as many stages as possible before Hollywood Week. However, Campbell acknowledged the tight timeline made this difficult, underscoring Pruitt's relative newcomer status in the competitive field.

Looking ahead at the competition

Mattie Pruitt’s path to American Idol comes with a surprising twist that connects her to the judging panel in a pretty unexpected way. She originally auditioned with country singer Craig Campbell, someone who used to play in Luke Bryan’s band before striking out on his own solo career.

As it turns out, Campbell and Pruitt's families live in the same small town, which explains their bond. He shared the connection in a chat with Taste of Country, adding a fun “small world” moment to Mattie’s already compelling American Idol story. Despite the personal ties, the judges have kept things professional, letting Mattie’s talent speak for itself.

Following her audition, Underwood had advised Pruitt to gain experience on as many stages as possible before Hollywood Week. However, Campbell acknowledged the tight timeline made this difficult, underscoring Pruitt's relative newcomer status in the competitive field.

Trending

American Idol airs Sundays at 8 p.m. ET/PT on ABC and is available to stream the next day on Hulu.

×

Was this article helpful?

Thank You for feedback