Can't get over The Bondsman? Watch these 7 shows next (& you won't regret it)

Image via Instagram / @kevinbacon
The Bondsman (Image via Instagram/@kevinbacon)

Now that you've finished watching The Bondsman, you're in the awkward post-binge state of mind. You know what that's like—you feel like nothing is as great, and that every other TV show seems just too mundane by comparison. By taking a quirky premise about a zombie bounty hunter traveling through death, justice, and identity, The Bondsman staked out a position difficult to fill.

The combination of the dry wit, creepy mysticism, and a morally ambiguous main character makes this show unforgettable. But don't panic—you haven't run out of choices just yet. There are a few other shows that might not replicate The Bondsman, but certainly possess similar energy, tones, or themes.

It could be the supernatural twist, the brooding anti-hero with introspection, or the offbeat jobs concerning souls and secrets. Anyways, these seven shows are set to fill the gap. Let's dive in.


Here are 7 similar shows to dive right into after watching The Bondsman

1. Dead Like Me – The reaper's life is anything but restful

Dead Like Me ( Image via Prime Video)
Dead Like Me ( Image via Prime Video)

This cult classic series tracks George, an 18-year-old who's murdered by a plummeting toilet seat (yes, seriously) and is turned into a grim reaper. Her assignment? Reap souls of the newly dead and assist them in passing on. Unlike The Bondsman, however, the tone here is satirical and more lighthearted, but don't be deceived—Dead Like Me delves into heavy themes regarding life, identity, and the emotional toll of death.

Why it's a good fit: If you enjoyed The Bondsman's blend of gory subject matter and sarcastic humor, you'll feel right at home here. It also includes characters trapped in after-death work they didn't sign up for, dealing with bureaucracy and emotional numbness while working with literal souls. That begrudging-afterlife-worker premise strikes very close.


2. The Dresden Files – Magic and mystery, in a world that's just barely keeping its seams intact

The Dresden Files (Image via Apple TV)
The Dresden Files (Image via Apple TV)

Based on the top-selling urban fantasy novels of Jim Butcher, The Dresden Files revolves around Harry Dresden, a wizard and private investigator in Chicago. He investigates cases of demons, spirits, vampires, and any other magical problem in between. Although it only lasted for one season, its blend of detective noir with the supernatural created a gritty and intriguing story.

Why it's a good match: Dresden, similar to the Bondsman, exists in the gray areas—neither entirely at home in the real world nor the world of magic. Both are flawed characters who wear cynicism as armor and take on cases that tend to uncover unpleasant truths. If you enjoyed the dark tone combined with a moral dilemma, give this a watch.


3. Constantine – Redemption doesn't come cheap (or easily)

Constantine is about John Constantine, a retired occult detective and demon hunter haunted by his past. His deeds have damned him, and he's attempting to make amends before Hell takes him back. The series is dark, mysterious, and steeped in supernatural stuff—from exorcisms to spiritual warfare.

Why it's a good fit: If what engaged you about The Bondsman was a reluctant protagonist with a dark history, trapped in a universe of curses and mysterious contracts, Constantine treads the same path. There's also the larger theme of personal accountability, where each victory comes at a cost, and that emotional tension is familiar ground.


4. Reaper – When soul collection is just part of your job description

Reaper ( Image via Apple TV)
Reaper ( Image via Apple TV)

Reaper makes us meet Sam, a twentysomething whose parents traded his soul to the Devil. Now he has to serve as Hell's bounty hunter, rounding up escaped souls and returning them. It's offbeat, irreverent, and surprisingly moving despite the premise.

Why it's a good fit: While The Bondsman turns into a darker tone, Reaper gives us a funny spin on the same concepts—contractual duties with the otherworldly, accidental professions in soul-harvesting, and characters dealing with responsibilities they didn't volunteer for. If you liked The Bondsman's concept but wouldn't protest a better sense of humor, Reaper's your choice.


5. Lucifer – Crime-solving with the Devil has its highlights

Lucifer is the story of the actual Devil, who leaves Hell to run a nightclub in Los Angeles. Somehow, he finds himself consulting for the LAPD, cracking cases while at the same time grappling with existential issues about justice, punishment, and morality. Initially, the show is more procedural in format, but gradually transforms into something richer and more character-based as the series progresses.

Why it's a good fit: Similar to The Bondsman, Lucifer revolves around a supernatural character grappling with purpose and identity in a world that doesn't always accept him. It looks at the same kind of redemption, moral greys, and the fact that justice isn't necessarily black or white. In addition, both series look at how collaborating with humans makes supernatural fates messy.


6. Being Human – Monsters trying to be anything but

Being Human (Image via Prime Video)
Being Human (Image via Prime Video)

In Being Human, a vampire, a ghost, and a werewolf live together and try to have a normal life. On paper, it's absurd. But the show—both the original UK series and the American remake—is all about control, loneliness, and responsibility. Each of the characters struggles with their animal side and their humanity.

Why it's a good fit: Like The Bondsman, Being Human combines supernatural world-building with human emotion. It's not about saving the world—it's about surviving it while bearing the burden of what you are. The balance of horror, friendship, and psychological depth in the show will resonate with anyone who enjoyed the emotional undertones in The Bondsman.


7. Carnivàle – A surreal plunge into prophecy, fate, and darkness

It's set during 1930s Dust Bowl America, and Carnivàle traces the path of a young man with healing abilities and a preacher whose visions become darker by the day. Their paths cross in a struggle between good and evil that extends beyond the mortal realm. It's a slow-burning, symbolic, and disturbing series.

Why it's a good fit: If what attracted you to The Bondsman was its creepy, mythic atmosphere, Carnivàle does that on steroids. It doesn't give you answers easily. It makes you stay with the unease, struggle through its depths, and learn to accept that some tales are more about mood than conclusion. It's creepy in the same way.


Not all shows can copy The Bondsman's precise blend of the undead, justice, and dark humor—but these seven get close in their fashion. Some go full-on into the same supernatural battles. Others echo the tone, tempo, or reluctant hero situation.

Whatever you're in the mood for—introspection, spooky mythology, or just more souls getting sorted out by imperfectly human beings—this list has something to prevent your mind from wandering back to The Bondsman-shaped hole.

Also read: 10 shows like Supernatural you should not miss if you're fan of fantasy

Edited by Anshika Jain