Cheat: Unfinished Business Episode 2 aired on Netflix on April 30, 2025. The second episode, If You Want to Leave, The Door's Right There, featured the remaining couples' first face-to-face conversation followed by the second Reckoning.
Participants met show host Amanda and expert Paul in the Reckoning room. The ex-couples opened up about their first one-on-one conversation and shared how it went. Paul advised them according to the issues they faced in their relationship.
Cheat: Unfinished Business Episode 2 ended with Liam and Olivia's conversation. It happened after Paul mentioned Liam's "ultimatum", which he issued to Olivia, and asked whether he wanted to leave.
Netflix describes the Cheat: Unfinished Business Episode 2 as:
"Tears, denials and a shocking ultimatum unfold at the face-to-face meetings, before Paul offers one ex the door in the Reckoning Room."
Cheat: Unfinished Business Episode 2 Recap: First face-to-face conversation between the remaining ex-couples, followed by the second Reckoning
Cheat: Unfinished Business Episode 2 started with the first episode's continued conversation between Olivia and Liam. She showed him a picture and asked him about the girl in it. He said he didn't know her.
"My best friend went on a night out with this girl. She said that she slept with Liam when me and him were together," confessed Olivia.
However, Liam was adamant about it. He told Olivia that he loved and cared only for her. He also gave her an ultimatum.
Craig and Jazz were the next couple to have a face-to-face conversation. After Jazz learned about Craig being in a relationship with his daughter's mother, she ended it. He apologized for that.
"I thought I was a girlfriend, and I turned out to be your side chick," said Jazz.
The next couple for the one-on-one conversation on Cheat: Unfinished Business was Dan and Rebecca (C). While she said he was with "other girls", was he being "disloyal," Dan thought it didn't count as "cheating." She got emotional hearing that from her ex, Dan.
Lucia and Conor were the next couple.
"How can you go from speaking about (having) kids to sleeping with someone?" she asked.
He said "buying" the thought of buying the house pressured him, and he regretted his actions. They agreed on "let's see what happens."
Cheat: Unfinished Business Episode 2 Recap: The second Reckoning
The next morning, Cheat: Unfinished Business host, Amanda, told the participants about meeting their ex in the Reckoning room. Relationship expert Paul would also be there, besides Amanda.
"Then you have a crucial decision to make. Do you stay at the retreat and continue your unfinished business? Or is one of you finished for good?" said the host.
At night, the ex-couples went to the Reckoning room for their second Reckoning. Cheat: Unfinished Business host Amanda and expert Paul were also there. Paul said that during the first face-to-face conversation, participants were supposed to be "transparent" about their cheating. However, he said that not everyone was transparent.
Kieran and Amberley argued about their previous conversation and what happened while they were in a relationship. Paul helped them throughout their conversation.
For Biggs and Rebecca, she mentioned she couldn't even "look" at him. After Paul mentioned a few things, Biggs stated that he was there to get Rebecca back and to "change", apologized to her, and confessed his love. However, she said she wasn't "sure."
For Lucia and Connor, she mentioned that he had asked about her seeing anyone. Paul advised the couple about their issues, including Connor's insecurity. The next couple was Steph and Andre. After arguing about their one-on-one conversation, Andre said he was there to "fix" their relationship and make it even "better."
Rebecca and Dan were the next couple, where he accepted being the "problem" and apologized for his "cheating." Listening to him accepting and apologizing, Rebecca got emotional. Paul said that it was a textbook apology.
The next couple was Shaun and Tegan. They discussed their previous conversation while Paul shared his communication advice. Craig and Jazz were the next ones. While she said their one-on-one conversation went well, Craig said he would do anything to show her that she means everything to her.
"I don't know what to do, but I'm willing to do anything possible to do that," said Craig.
Liam and Olivia were the next ones. They talked about Liam issuing an "ultimatum" to Olivia during their first face-to-face conversation. Paul told him the door was right there if he wanted to leave. The Unfinished Business episode 2 ended with Paul's words.
Fans can stream Cheat: Unfinished Business Episode 2 on Netflix to learn more about what happened further.