5 TV shows that should definitely be on your watch list next if you loved The Better Sister

The Better Sister is a new Amazon Prime limited series that blends psychological thriller with family drama. Directed by Craig Gillespie and based on Alafair Burke’s novel, the story follows Chloe (Jessica Biel), a seemingly perfect woman whose life shatters after her husband Adam is murdered.

Forced to reconnect with her estranged sister Nicky (Elizabeth Banks), Chloe confronts dark secrets, addiction, and trauma that possibly started in childhood. The show explores themes of betrayal, sisterhood, and the emotional cost of keeping up appearances.

The Better Sister premiered on May 29, 2025, and left viewers questioning whom they should trust. If you loved this series, its emotional twists, flawed female leads, and engaging storytelling, we have five must-watch recommendations for you.

---

5 TV shows that should definitely be on your watchlist if you loved The Better Sister

If you loved watching The Better Sister, you can watch Dead to Me, Sharp Objects, The Undoing, The Sinner, and Little Fires Everywhere. Each offers the same thrilling intensity and layered drama.

Dead to Me (2019–2022)

Dead to Me is a dark comedy-drama that blends emotional depth with clever humor. It follows Jen (Christina Applegate), a recently widowed real estate agent who’s angry, grieving, and determined to find the driver who killed her husband. At a grief support group, she meets Judy (Linda Cardellini), a warm, quirky woman with a dark secret.

Their friendship grows quickly but eventually becomes tangled in lies, grief, and guilt. Like Chloe and Nicky in The Better Sister, Jen and Judy share a bond built on trauma and trust that slowly falls apart.

Though Dead to Me is funnier in tone, it shares similar emotional layers. Both shows focus on complex women coping with loss and betrayal. The slow-burning secrets and plot twists make it a worth watch. You can stream the show on Netflix.

---

Sharp Objects (2018)

Sharp Objects is a psychological drama about a woman returning to her troubled roots. Amy Adams stars as Camille Preaker, a journalist sent back to her hometown to cover the murder of two young girls. But the real story lies in Camille’s own haunted past.

As she investigates, Camille is forced to face her childhood trauma, self-harm, and a toxic relationship with her domineering mother. The show’s quiet pacing and dark mood are similar to the tension found in The Better Sister.

Both shows focus on female leads unraveling emotionally in the most raw manner while uncovering dangerous truths. Camille’s emotional scars and slow descent into past trauma make her journey feel extremely similar to Chloe’s. Family dysfunction is the main focus of the show, adding to the intense psychological suspense. You can stream the show on Max.

---

The Undoing (2020)

The Undoing centers on Grace Fraser (played by Nicole Kidman), a New York therapist living a seemingly perfect life. However, when a young woman is murdered, her husband, Jonathan (played by Hugh Grant), becomes the main suspect, shaking her world to its core.

Grace must face the end of everything she believed about her marriage, her family, and herself. Like The Better Sister, this show explores what happens when a polished life is shattered by a violent crime and long-hidden secrets.

Grace’s unraveling is eerily similar to Chloe’s emotional journey as trust erodes and truth becomes harder to find. The show keeps you guessing and delivers a slow but intense unraveling of lies and betrayal. Its polished style, tense atmosphere, and strong performances make it a great watch. You can stream the show on Max.

---

The Sinner (2017–2021)

Each season of The Sinner begins with a shocking crime, but the focus is on why it happened, not who did it. Detective Harry Ambrose (played by Bill Pullman) investigates cases that seem senseless on the surface but are deeply rooted in personal trauma.

Season one stars Jessica Biel as Cora, a young mother who commits a brutal crime in public. As her past unravels, we see the pain, abuse, and psychological scars that led her to do what she did.

Much like The Better Sister, the show focuses on hidden trauma, emotional breakdowns, and complicated female characters. Cora’s journey from silence to self-awareness is similar to Chloe and Nicky’s struggle with identity, guilt, and redemption.

Each season tells a new story, but all are character-driven and psychologically intense. You can stream the show on Netflix.

---

Little Fires Everywhere (2020)

Little Fires Everywhere explores the clash between two very different mothers in 1990s suburban Ohio. Elena (played by Reese Witherspoon) lives a picture-perfect life defined by control and order. Mia (played by Kerry Washington) is a free-spirited artist with a mysterious past.

Their children become friends, intertwining their lives and setting off a series of conflicts rooted in race, class, and secrets. As tensions rise, long-suppressed truths surface, and both women are forced to face the consequences of their choices.

Like The Better Sister, this series focuses on strong female leads whose lives are far more fragile than they appear. It’s about what happens behind closed doors, the masks people wear, and the cost one pays for perfection. The emotional intensity and slow-building drama make it a worthy next watch. You can stream the show on Hulu.

---

The Better Sister has been quite a success because it combines emotional weight with an engaging mystery. It explores sisterhood, trauma, and the fragile mask of perfection. If that blend of suspense and emotional depth is what convinced you to finish watching the series, these five shows will be great watches as well.

The Better Sister is streaming on Prime Video.

---

For more articles like this, follow Soapcentral.