Dateline: A detailed investigation overview of the Donna Palomba case, explored

Dateline released an emotionally touching and poignant episode on August 7, 2024, called Evil Paid a Visit (Season 7, Episode 1310). The episode is a spine-chilling narrative of Donna Palomba, a Connecticut mother who in 1993 experienced a violent break-in and sexual assault at her home. Over ten years later, her attacker was finally located after years of detective work and through sheer perseverance.

The episode does not only focus on the violence of the crime, but also on the protracted struggle towards justice. It emphasizes the trauma that Donna went through, the court hearings that she had to endure, and the hurdles of a poor investigation and falsehoods going around the town that put her in doubt.

Nevertheless, Donna did not give up, and she confronted her assailant and a system that at first did not believe her, which eventually led to the conviction of the man. Dateline peels off the layers of this case, and we can see the painstaking work done by the detectives and the emotional burden on Donna and her family, as well as the strength needed to ensure justice is served.

---

Dateline: The investigation of the Donna Palomba case

It was in September 1993 that Donna Palomba, aged 36, a marketing executive and mother of two, was at home with their two daughters asleep, in Waterbury, Connecticut, when a masked intruder broke in. Her husband, John, was away for the first time in a marriage of 12 years. Recalling the incident, John tells Dateline:

“It hurt me that there was nothing I could do. I was angry. I was very angry…I felt that I let ‘em down. I wasn’t there. That’s what hurt, is you just felt like you let your family down.”

Once she had put her children to bed, Donna saw a silhouette of a “masked” man. Speaking with Dateline, Donna reveals:

“I could tell that the silhouette was of a man, and he was wearing some type of face covering… He cranked my arm up behind my back and he said, ‘If you don’t cooperate, you’re going to get hurt.’”

The intruder violently assaulted her after he “bound her wrists and eyes with nylons and covered her head with a pillowcase,” as per Oxygen report.

The intruder had cut telephone lines, severed her communication with the outside world, and left threatening messages that he would come back if she reported the incident.

Nonetheless, despite the fear, Donna gathered the courage to walk to a neighbor’s house, who called the police.

Soon after, Donna called family members, who arrived at the scene to take the kids to their grandmother’s house. However, she didn’t call John at that hour. Explaining the rationale behind it, Donna told Dateline:

“I did not want to call John, and I would not want to talk to him at this moment to frighten him when he couldn’t be there. That would just be torture for him.”

The response of the Waterbury Police Department traumatized her further. Donna was not met with compassion; instead, they suspected her. One of the senior investigators threatened to arrest her for making up the attack and not having “rock-solid evidence” of it.

Donna recounted the horror to Dateline, saying:

“He was very abrupt, and he put me in a small interrogation room with a desk, and on the desk there was a tape recorder. I was confused, but I quickly became aware that something was wrong. He took out a little white piece of paper, unfolded it, and began reading me my Miranda rights… I was dumbfounded… I started crying... It was devastating.”

Such accusations were aroused by a rumor that Donna had fabricated the assault to conceal an affair, an assertion she vehemently refused to accept, and which was proven to be false later.

The attacker of Donna Palomba remained unidentified for years. A progress came when Detective Neil O’Leary, soon to be Waterbury police chief, took a personal interest in the case. Convinced by Donna’s consistent witness account and the fact that no one came in forcibly, O’Leary hypothesized that the perpetrator would have had access to the house key.

His inquiry centered on the close social group around the evening of the assault, specifically a bachelor party that John Palomba’s friends had gone to. Though preliminary DNA results excluded a number of the party guests, the case was still open.

The breakthrough occurred in 2004, more than a decade after the incident, during an unrelated arrest. John Regan, a Waterbury native and cousin of the bachelor party groom, had been accused before of trying to sexually assault a co-worker.

O’Leary seized the opportunity, obtained Regan’s DNA, and matched it to the sample collected from Donna’s sex crimes kit back in 1993. The DNA matched, and finally, her assailant was identified after a long struggle.

In 2007, Donna appeared publicly with her story during a historic two-hour Dateline special, no longer hiding behind the identity of Jane Doe. She employed her experience to promote the rights of victims by creating a group called Jane Doe No More.

Her case helped transform the Connecticut laws regarding the time limit on DNA evidence in sexual assault to give other survivors a chance to seek justice without such restrictions.

Also read: Dateline: The Night of the Audition - 5 harrowing details about Shannon Madill Burgess's murder, revisited