Dateline: House of Horrors – Who was Jason Payne and what do we know about his crimes? Disturbing details from the true crime episode, revisited

Dateline brought to the screen one of the most chilling family murders ever investigated in East Texas. Jason Payne, a loving husband and father, was revealed to be the man behind the murders of his wife, Nichole Payne, and her son, Taylor.

What felt like a tragic murder/s*icide case soon took a sharp U-turn once investigators began looking through the many layers. So, who really was Jason Payne? And why did he commit such unthinkable crimes?

In Dateline's "House of Horrors," we revisit a case that shook an entire community and left two innocent lives cut short in cold blood.

Dateline uncovers - Jason Payne: The perfect husband or something far more sinister?

From the outside, Jason Payne lived the dream—a large house in the woods of Quitman, Texas, a family, and a peaceful life. But Dateline peeled back the layers, and what lay underneath was far darker than anyone imagined.

Jason and Nichole met by chance at a gas station and were married just weeks later. At first, things seemed blissful. They raised four children together, including Nichole's biological son, Taylor, and an adopted son, Daniel. However, money soon became a problem until Jason received a massive $900,000 settlement from a car accident.

That money gave them the dream home Nichole had always wanted. It also built a facade of stability. According to Nichole's mother, Sherry Hawthorne, things were far from perfect.

"She wasn't happy the last couple years," she told Dateline, adding that Jason became "very controlling." Nichole's sister-in-law even revealed that she had considered leaving but was afraid Jason would hurt her.

The morning that changed everything forever

On December 11, 2007, Jason called 911 in a panic, saying he had returned home to find Nichole and Taylor dead. His wife was in bed, shot in the head. Taylor was found in the garage bedroom with a rifle between his legs. Jason claimed Taylor had refused to go to school that morning over a cell phone argument and hinted at a possible breakdown.

At first glance, it seemed like a murder-suicide. But Dateline's detailed account showed investigators weren't buying it. EMT Leah Courtney, who arrived on the scene, recalled that Taylor's body was already cold. Nichole, on the other hand, was still warm. That meant only one thing—Taylor died first.

Lieutenant Miles Tucker explained to Dateline that the timeline alone ruled out the murder/s*icide theory. And once that theory collapsed, all eyes turned back to Jason.

The clues that pointed straight to Jason Payne

Dateline explored how it didn't take long before the evidence started stacking against Jason Payne. For one, authorities discovered a white rag stained with fresh blood in his truck. Lab tests confirmed the blood belonged to Nichole. That was just the beginning.

Police also uncovered that Jason stood to gain from Nichole's $100,000 life insurance policy. The couple's financial situation had fallen apart, regardless of the earlier windfall. With the increasing stress at home and the threat of a divorce, investigators believed that Jason had the perfect motive, the means, and the perfect opportunity.

Nichole's family said that she feared retaliation if she tried to leave the situation. Her sister-in-law shared that Nichole once said Jason wanted to;

"...Burn the house down with her in it."

Nearly 10 months after the murders, Jason was finally arrested. The trial that followed revealed even more disturbing truths.

Justice took time, but it finally came

In 2010, Jason Payne was convicted and sentenced to life in prison. Nichole's mother was heartbroken over the loss of her daughter and grandson, but she was also relieved that Taylor's name was cleared.

Nicole's mother says;

"He also was trying to take his whole reputation and brand him as a murderer..."

However, the case didn't end there. In 2013, a new trial was ordered due to some problematic testimony. The second trial in 2016 led to the same result—Jason was found guilty again. He remains behind bars for life.

In a final disturbing twist, the NBC true crime show revealed that Jason's mother, Faye Payne, tried to tamper with a witness by plotting to intimidate EMT Leah Courtney. She was recorded discussing plans to scare Courtney's child and was later arrested and sentenced to probation. She has since passed away.

Dateline's "House of Horrors" episode didn't just return to a crime but looked into the understanding of a man who wore a mask of normalcy until the very end.

Jason Payne, someone who was once seen as a loving husband and a father, is now a convicted murderer serving his punishment with life without parole.

While justice was served, the trauma and pain he left behind on the victim's family still remain strong even today.

It's a reminder that appearances can be harmful, no matter who the person is.

Also read: Dateline: A complete timeline of the Jonathan Crews murder case, revisited.

Trending

Stay tuned to SoapCentral for more.

×

Was this article helpful?

Thank You for feedback