Dateline: Shattered Bonds - 5 harrowing details about Stephen Moore's disappearance and murder, revisited

In a case that shocked detectives and audience members alike, Dateline: Shattered Bonds investigated one of the most heinous domestic crime stories in recent memory—one marked by manipulation, betrayal, and one deadly murder-for-hire plot.

The 2010 killing and disappearance of Stephen Moore, a devoted New Jersey father of two, was akin to a dark soap opera with deadly real-world repercussions. What initially appeared to be a custody battle turned into a sordid and profoundly sinister story of conspiracy.

The "Dateline" episode Shattered Bonds looks back at this tragedy and uncovers the chain of events that led to Stephen's death. In a shocking turn of events, his ex-wife Kathleen Dorsett and her parents were charged with premeditated murder.

---

Here are 5 harrowing details about Stephen Moore's disappearance and murder as covered by Dateline

1. A custody battle that turned deadly

The Dateline episode showed that Stephen Moore and Kathleen Dorsett were in a bitter custody battle over their 20-month-old daughter. The couple had recently separated, and tensions were running high. The court documents and police reports indicate that Kathleen wasn't happy with the joint custody.

Authorities ultimately found that this custody battle was a primary motivating factor in the crime, as Kathleen and her parents wanted sole custody of the child.

---

2. A secret murder committed by the Dorsett Family

As depicted on Dateline, it was established upon investigation that Kathleen's father, Thomas Dorsett, invited Stephen Moore to his home in Ocean Township, New Jersey, so that he could take his daughter away. On that visit, Stephen was brutally attacked and murdered by Kathleen's father.

Facts produced in court showed that Kathleen assisted in planning the ambush with full knowledge that this was to happen. Police discovered that Stephen had been beaten and choked before having his body placed in the trunk of his own vehicle.

---

3. Grisly efforts at concealing the crime

The killer placed Stephen's dead body in the trunk of his vehicle and drove it to a school parking lot, where the body was incinerated.

Detectives discovered that the fire was a desperate attempt to burn evidence and confuse authorities. Security video and forensic evidence pieced together the chronology to ultimately result in the arrest of all three family members.

---

4. Conspiracy to kill a witness following the murder

As if the first crime weren't twisted enough, the investigation also uncovered a second conspiracy. Kathleen, who was facing trial, was alleged to have conspired with her mother, Lesley Dorsett, to arrange for a hitman to murder Stephen Moore's mother.

The prosecutors said the motive was to eliminate an important witness to testify in the custody case as well as the criminal proceeding. This new conspiracy to commit murder allegation once more served to point out the extremes to which the Dorsetts would go to hold onto power.

---

5. Sentencing and justice

Legal consequences were inevitable. Kathleen Dorsett was convicted of murder, conspiracy to commit murder, and attempted murder. She was given 58 years in prison. Thomas Dorsett received 45 years. Lesley Dorsett was given seven years for attempting to murder a witness.

The case acts as a tragic reminder of how rapidly personal conflicts turn into irreversible violence, particularly when they are fueled by manipulation and revenge.

---

Dateline: Shattered Bonds not only provides a recap of the timeline of this crime but also depicts the emotional, legal, and psychological consequences that followed. The facts are as revolting today as they were at the time of their discovery, presenting a haunting case study into the darker side of family life.

Also read: Dateline: Shattered Bonds — Who was Stephen Moore and what happened to him? Disturbing details of the 2010 incident, revealed