Dateline: The Box - 5 harrowing details about Bill Stout's murder, revealed

Dateline again welcomes another thrill-of-your-life true-crime tale with the segment Dateline: The Box, the killing of Bill Stout, a case that shook up Montana and hit the newsstands nationally. Bill Stout was discovered dead at his Ravalli County residence on June 10, 2007, when he was shot once in the head.

He was discovered by his younger son, Noah, and wife, Anne Marie Stout, who were driving home from a routine shopping trip. The early death would become the centerpiece of Dateline, having been uncovered through investigators, courtroom testimony, and family circumstances in an odd and pointless record. Foreboding indicators filled the last several weeks of Bill Stout's life.

A decade prior, Bill had reported his pistol, holster, and ammunition stolen, a piece of news that would haunt him later. Police discovered the gun buried, concealing it in a motorcycle saddlebag in their garage, along with a rubber glove with Anne Marie's DNA. Dateline seized on how these innocuous-looking pieces of information, missing gun, glove, and web surfing, equated to form a malevolent conspiracy profile of deceit, plotting, and cold-blooded murder.

Here are 5 harrowing details about Bill Stout's murder revealed by Dateline: The Box

Expand Tweet

1. The shocking discovery

Bill Stout's body was discovered dramatically, shocking his family and the community police as well. Noah Stout, who was at home with his mother, discovered his father dead in bed. The unexpectedness of it demonstrated the arbitrariness of the crime.

Dateline also covered how a low-key day becomes a day of catastrophe and how quickly the police were forced to move to maintain the crime scene and gather evidence. The finding set the tone for what was to be an aggressive investigation into family life and premeditated crime.

2. Lost pistol and indispensable evidence

The gun itself had been removed from Bill Stout's piece a week and a half before he was murdered, and it became the linchpin to crack the case. Police officials later discovered the gun in a motorcycle saddlebag along with a rubber glove that had Anne Marie Stout's DNA on it.

The proof gave police detectives a clear connection between the murder and Anne Marie. Dateline emphasized the value of meticulous collection of sound evidence, making it possible for TV viewers to see missing object can be the starting point of a case and how much planning went into committing the crime.

3. Internet searches verify preplanning

The investigators started questioning further and found internet searches on Anne Marie's computer about murder, poisoning, and homicide on more than one occasion. These searches were presented to the court as evidence of preplanning. It was a scary sight of planning and motive.

Dateline showed it to us in documentary form so the public could see how prints on the internet could expose motive and planning in our criminal cases today. It also showed how close type behavior on the internet can lead one to open the truth.

4. Trial, conviction, and legal proceedings

Anne Marie Stout's trial was one to forget in Montana. The state had a mix of computer database checks, forensic data, and eyewitnesses to prove her voluntary participation in the killing of Bill Stout. The motive shown was revenge for Bill's infidelity and economic incentive by a $500,000 life insurance policy.

Anne Marie was found guilty of premeditated murder in September 2008 and sentenced to life, later having her appeal rejected by the Montana Supreme Court. Dateline covered the hearing at length, being assiduously fact-based about something that had actually occurred and the legal rulings without sensationalism but providing a true record of the judicial process to the viewers.

5. Motive and planning

No spur-of-the-moment crime was Bill Stout's murder. Court documents uncovered that Anne Marie did it for selfish motives and self-delusion. Researchers examined how the killing was conspired, from where and when to how to do it. The act of premeditated murder, the application of the insurance claim, and the discovery of Bill's infidelity all presented a nightmare of planning.

The show presented the facts factually, progressing from verifiable facts to not speculation.

Forensic evidence and law enforcement

Forensic evidence dominated the case. Gun residue, rubber glove DNA, and physical evidence all linked directly to Anne Marie's participation in the crime. The police locally videotaped and photographed the scene, recovered evidence, and reconstructed the timeline.

Dateline captured these processes and how far scientific evidence and diligent investigations can go in untangling complex crimes.

Public response and media coverage

Bill Stout's murder attracted national publicity and media attention. Dateline presented an in-depth, balanced account of the case, outlining the investigation, trial, and evidence without sensationalism. The show also addressed the response of the community to the senseless crime with a focus on the emotional burden for Bill's relatives and neighbors.

By adhering to established facts, Dateline let the viewers understand what had occurred without sensationalism.

Bill Stout's homicide is a gruesome reminder of the consequences of home stress, scheming, and deception. The show's meticulously researched documentary summarizes the whole case, from discovery through conviction, in terms of forensic science, detective work, and trial drama without sentimentality.