'%20x='0'%20y='0'%20height='100%25'%20width='100%25'%20%0A%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20xlink%3Ahref=''%3E%3C/image%3E%3C/svg%3E)
On Dateline's gripping western Wisconsin episode "The Trouble at Dill Creek Farm," the case of Ken Juedes comes alive, a ranching pharmacist who resided in the allegedly idyllic town of Unity, Wisconsin, whose horrific 2006 murder would plague detectives for more than a decade.
Double-shotted in his rural farmhouse on Dill Creek Farm, a property once echoing with descriptions of serene open fields. The dazzling time off was not provided by the police or by a neighbor, but by his wife, Cindy Schulz-Juedes, who claimed she slept in a camper on the property.
The case, which had started as an apparently bizarre burglary, turned into a homicide and proved to be a tangled web of money, suspicion, and unanswered questions.
That is what authorities believe now, Dateline and reports indicate: What actually happened to Ken Juedes was far from straightforward. His 58-year-old attacker, who had fired the shotgun at point-blank range as the man lay in bed, showed no sign of forced entry, and ominously, a scrawled note with a slur was affixed to his body with a knife.
It looked like a botched robbery, however, and it became a much more complicated case, one that would take 13 years before an arrest was made. The investigation later centered on his wife, Cindy Schulz-Juedes, in the years ahead, who was later found guilty of his murder in 2021 and was sentenced to life in prison the next year.
The crime scene and initial investigation
The early morning hours of August 30, 2006, brought one of Wisconsin's most intriguing murder cases. Ken Juedes was dead in bed with two gunshot wounds, in the back and the chest. When police officers arrived at Dill Creek Farm, they discovered that there had been no burglary and no theft from the house.
The gruesome tag and body facilitated the construction of the mystery instead of eliminating it. In Dateline coverage, police had characterized the scene as extravagantly staged, and the impression existed that the killer could be attempting to hoodwink them.
Cindy Schulz-Juedes told police that she'd slept the night before in an adjacent camper and woke up the next morning to discover the body of her husband. Her account, at first plausible, began to raise suspicions as soon as detectives opened an investigation.
She was described by Dateline as being incredibly calm and the first to propose a burglary, something never borne out by evidence.
Suspicion and motive
Throughout the course of the investigation, inconsistencies in Cindy's stories came to light. She would inherit land and the life insurance policies of Ken, and these were in the hundreds of thousands. She was also listed as the primary beneficiary on a will by Dateline and Oxygen news, something which was later suspected by Ken's family to be a forgery.
Prosecutors employed money as a motive, though it was consistently denied by Cindy. Despite the growing suspicion against her, she had nothing concrete against her. There was no weapon of murder, there were no fingerprints, and no DNA that could be traced to link her directly to the crime.
The detectives had only one thing to work with as evidence, which was that Cindy was searching for a shotgun similar to the one used to kill the victim, but that could not be recognized as identical via ballistics. For many years, the case never warmed up, lingering on the shelves of the Marathon County Sheriff's Office with detectives waiting for the missing piece to fall into place.
Breakthrough after thirteen years
Thirteen years on, in 2019, the police reopened the case. Re-interviewing of the witness statements and forensic testing for the first time, reported by Dateline, allowed them to build a stronger circumstantial case against Cindy Schulz-Juedes. She was arrested in December 2019 on a first-degree intentional homicide charge and obstructing an officer.
Prosecutors said that she staged the setting to appear as if there had been a burglary, while the defense maintained that the evidence was circumstantial and did not prove her beyond a reasonable doubt.
In 2021, Cindy was found guilty by a Marathon County jury. The verdict was delivered without explicit forensic proof, a conviction largely predicated on motive, opportunity, and contradictions in her own testimony. She was sentenced to life in prison without parole in June 2022.
Cindy had maintained that she had nothing to do with her husband's murder during the trial and that she was innocent of any role in it.
Aftermath and later events
In a strange twist of fate, Cindy Schulz-Juedes herself passed away in 2023 while an inmate at Taycheedah Correctional Institution. Her cellmate, Taylor L. Sanchez, was later convicted of murder and imprisoned for life without chance of parole, court and Dateline reports say.
The tragedy once again put the public spotlight on the eighteen-year, tragic chronicle of Dill Creek Farm. Even with Cindy's own guilty determination and subsequent murder, there are questions. There have been arguments back and forth on some of the internet discussion boards, such as the ones that have been posed on Dateline forums and the Court Junkie Podcast community subreddit.
The questions are about whether or not the case had really been closed out or if critical evidence had been overlooked. Vigilante detectives have also supported the jury's decision, yet they maintain that the evidence, as circumstantial as it seemed, always led to Cindy.
Legacy of the case
The Dateline segment "The Trouble at Dill Creek Farm" is still iconic and high-profile because it illustrates the challenge of closing long-term cold cases. It suggests the around-the-clock work of police detectives, the psychological burden shouldered by both families, and the doubt that persists when a case hinges on circumstantial evidence.
The killing of Ken Juedes serves as a reminder of the kind of silence that rural societies can maintain, and how, through patience and prudence, justice can ultimately be served. With its chronicle-of-events format, Dateline offered not just a whodunit in a murder but a tale of suspicion, loss, and survival.
Trending
Every facet of the case, from the unearthly crime scene on Dill Creek Farm to Cindy's trial and tragic death, demonstrates how complex human nature and forensic ambiguity can make it difficult to determine the truth.
Reply
