The Dateline series on the Tera Chavez's death brings new light to a case that continues to cause shock, controversy, and tragedy almost two decades after the fact. It was in October 2007, when 26-year-old Tera Chavez was found fatally shot in her Los Lunas, New Mexico, residence. At first, police suspected the shooting to be a suicide. But as information unfolded, the narrative shifted, and an investigation into a homicide began.
Dateline on NBC re-enacts this complex story, retracing the steps that preceded the ghastly discovery, the ensuing legal battle, and the remaining questions in the case. From files, interviews, and forensic data, the show tracks both the human cost and the remaining questions surrounding the death of Tera Chavez.
Tera Chavez: The woman caught in the middle of the case
Dateline tells us that Tera Chavez was not a star during her lifetime—she was a mother, a wife, and a woman looking for a new start. She was not living with her husband, Levi Chavez, at the time of her death; she was, by and large, single-parenting their children. People who knew her described her as sweet, driven, and determined to build a stable life for herself and her children.
She lived in the couple's Los Lunas home, while Levi lived somewhere else. The marriage had been portrayed as troubled, with arguing, tension, and emotional distance. Dateline reported that Tera found out Levi was cheating on her, which was one of the reasons that their breakup persisted.
Scenes and the questions they raised
Tera was found dead in her bedroom on the night of October 21, 2007. She had been shot in the head. Levi Chavez's police Glock handgun lay beside her along with a note apologizing to her husband. Initially ruled by police as a suicide, the case transitioned to investigating whether, after further review by Valencia County officials, it was intended to discredit such a ruling.
As seen on Dateline, there were a few things at the crime scene that didn't quite seem right. Forensic experts discussed the position of the gun, the fingerprints missing from the gun, and the spatter pattern of blood that did not appear to be suicide. And what was perhaps most surprising, the gun was fired by a left-handed individual, and Tera was right-handed, something that caught the attention of the arresting detectives and forensic experts.
Levi Chavez: Suspect and husband
Levi Chavez, an Albuquerque police officer at the time, soon became the focus of the investigation. Dateline uncovers that his personal life became the point of extensive curiosity. He was leading on multiple affairs, some of which were with female police department members, too. On the night of his wife's death, he was with his mistress. His actions not only questioned his professionalism, but they also questioned the strength of his marriage.
Prosecutors felt a motive existed: that Levi didn't want to be divorced, a possible loss of funds, and losing his position or being dismissed. Based on the Dateline special, the hypothesis prompted the authorities to reopen the case in 2008, a year after Tera's death, as a homicide.
The legal battle and acquittal
In 2011, almost four years later, Levi Chavez was charged with first-degree murder. His trial commenced in 2013 and was being covered by national media very soon after. Dateline also provided detailed coverage of the courtroom proceedings, from Tera's family testimony to forensic experts, as well as Chavez's friends.
The prosecution had made out the charge that Levi had faked the suicide by using his service revolver to make it appear as if death was self-inflicted. They had provided proof of how the relationship between the couple was falling apart and the deception tactics employed by Levi. The defense did put the focus, however, on the absence of clear physical evidence, noting that no DNA or fingerprints unequivocally linked Levi to the scene and time of death.
Following weeks of hearing evidence and around five hours of deliberation by the jury, Levi Chavez was acquitted of all the charges. It was reported that the jury stated the prosecution's case was circumstantial and too frail to prove beyond a reasonable doubt.
Reaction of the family and public
Tera's family was shocked and outraged by the acquittal. Dateline reported that they had naturally stepped forward to take responsibility for Levi and were dismayed at the outcome of the trial. Her mother stated that she wants Tera's kids to know the truth about their mother. She said,
“She’d never leave them. She’d never leave them of her own will. She didn’t leave them.”
The case attracted widespread public interest, not just over the question of how domestic violence cases are prosecuted, but also in the general presumption of responsibility where police officers are concerned.
Even while official statements ruled out prejudice in the investigation, Dateline lays bare how a few critics questioned whether or not Levi was treated with privilege due to his line of work. These topics continue to have everyone talking about transparency and fairness for police investigations.
Life after the verdict
Upon being acquitted, Levi Chavez resigned from the Albuquerque police force. Levi has kept silent and never commented on the case publicly. Tera's family remembers her memory through domestic abuse awareness, mental illness awareness, and law reform. Dateline reports that they believe that the case serves as a reminder to stay vigilant and uphold ethics in cases such as this one.
Dateline's contribution to re-evaluating the case
The show displayed the Tera Chavez case on the merit of a detailed, analytical retelling of events that occurred, inserting courtroom hearings, police questioning, interviews, and forensic testimony. Through retracing the timeline once again, Dateline paints the underlying challenges in addition to revealing the psychological and emotional suffering faced by Tera's family.
The show never speculates or provides unsubstantiated guesses. Dateline deals with only confirmed facts and public records so that the audience has an option to make their own conclusion on confirmed facts.
Why this case still matters
While legally resolved, the Tera Chavez case remains a part of the national controversy involving domestic violence, police integrity, and the weaknesses of forensic evidence. As demonstrated on Dateline, the case poses significant questions: How do tainted investigations possibly conclude? How much evidence must be accumulated to secure a conviction? And how do families receive justice when the judicial system fails to provide closure?
The show's meticulous reporting on the case has served to shed a national spotlight on the case so that Tera Chavez doesn't fall between the cracks, and her death tale remains in the limelight.
Also read: Dateline: A complete timeline of the Jonathan Crews murder case, revisited