'%20x='0'%20y='0'%20height='100%25'%20width='100%25'%20%0A%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20xlink%3Ahref=''%3E%3C/image%3E%3C/svg%3E)
Started in 2005, Criminal Minds focused on the minds of criminals, not just the crimes. The show asked, “Why did this happen?” instead of just, “What happened?” This gave the show a strange and exciting vibe.
The series ran for fifteen seasons, and viewers kept watching because of the mix between dark cases and the team’s personal stories. Some seasons were fan favorites, while others could not make it that strong. Even after the reboot of Criminal Minds: Evolution in 2025, people still argue about the original seasons. Fans keep rewatching and ranking them.
Here’s a look at every season, from the weakest to the best.
Disclaimer: This article contains the writer's opinion. Readers’ discretion is advised.
Criminal Minds: Ranking seasons from weakest to strongest
15. Season 9: A weak patch
Criminal Minds' Season 9 was filled with good cases, but it was often repetitive. The team tackled various shocking crimes, but the narrative didn't have the zing of previous seasons. The personal arcs, like JJ's backstory and his relationship in the military, were not given the attention they merited. The writers had many ideas, but weren't able to fully commit to any one of them. The result was as if it were a filler when compared to the more dramatic peaks of the show.
14. Season 10: Transition without energy
Criminal Minds Season 10 had trouble from the start. Alex Blake left. Kate Callahan joined the team, and the cast changes made things feel off. Kate, played by Jennifer Love Hewitt, had some good scenes. Still, she didn’t connect with fans and left after only one season. A few episodes stood out, but the season never had a great villain. No big storyline pulled everything together. It felt uneven the whole way through.
13. Season 12: Chaos behind the scenes
People usually remember Season 12 for the drama behind the scenes, not the cases. The show fired Thomas Gibson (Hotch) early on. After that, everything felt off. They brought in Luke Alvez (Adam Rodriguez), which helped a little. Still, this season never really found its balance. The story about Spencer Reid in prison began strongly, but it took over and pushed the rest of the team aside. Due to this, this season of Criminal Minds feels weak compared to other seasons.
12. Season 14: Short and uneven
In a short amount of time, Season 14 felt rushed. There were some interesting tales, like the investigation of David Rossi's life outside of the show and JJ admitting her love for Reid. However, the season did not have enough time to completely flesh out its narratives. The viewers were left looking for more depth. In comparison to the longer, richer seasons of Criminal Minds, it was an incomplete puzzle.
11. Season 13: Rebuilding after loss
After losing Hotch and Aaron Gideon earlier in Criminal Minds' history, Season 13 showed the team trying to rebuild. Alvez became a stronger presence, and Emily Prentiss grew into her role as team leader. Still, this season relied too much on random standalone episodes without a gripping villain. The team chemistry was there, but the storytelling needed more punch.
10. Season 11: Middle of the road
Season 11 is okayish; It isn’t amazing, but it isn’t bad. Tara Lewis (Aisha Tyler) joins the team. People like Lewis, and they think she brings something new. Still, the season doesn’t have a great villain. Frank, Foyet, and Mr. Scratch were much better. The acting is good and the stories are fine. But nothing about this season is special or unforgettable.
9. Season 1: The beginning
That first season of Criminal Minds felt different. The show focused on profiling; the cases were creepy and strange, and the characters were still figuring things out. Gideon led the team. The stories felt darker than later seasons. It wasn’t the best season, but it set things up for everything that came next. The start mattered.
8. Season 15: A short but strong goodbye
The final season of Criminal Minds had just ten episodes. The writers brought back Mr. Scratch, the team’s old villain. The show gave each character a real goodbye. Fans saw the team's evolution over the years, and the story mixed old memories with new ideas. Some moments felt emotional, but not everything worked perfectly. Still, the season reminded people why they loved Criminal Minds.
7. Season 8: Personal stakes
Season 8 is remembered for its stakes, especially with the introduction of Jeanne Tripplehorn as Alex Blake. The season also gave us one of the best villains in “The Replicator,” who targeted the team directly. That ongoing narrative kept viewers on edge, showing how dangerous profiling could be.
6. Season 7: A return to form
After the messy cast changes in Season 6 of Criminal Minds, Season 7 brought back familiar faces and energy. Emily Prentiss returned, and the chemistry felt strong again. The season also had emotionally powerful arcs, especially the finale, where the team’s loyalty and courage were tested. It was a satisfying comeback season that fans still appreciate.
5. Season 6: The dark turn
Season 6 is one of the most polarizing. On one hand, it had dark and disturbing cases that showed the risks of the job, while on the other hand, the behind-the-scenes drama with Paget Brewster’s exit affected the narrative. Still, arcs like Emily’s fake death and the growing menace of Ian Doyle made this season unforgettable. It showed how personal and dangerous the BAU’s work could become.
4. Season 5: High intensity
Criminal Minds' Season 5 raised the stakes. George Foyet, “The Reaper,” became the main villain. He went after Hotch and made things personal. Foyet scared viewers because he targeted Hotch’s family. Hotch struggled with fear and stress, and his family suffered too. This season felt intense for many fans. They say it is one of the best and most gripping seasons of the show.
3. Season 2: Finding its voice
By Season 2, Criminal Minds found its groove. The team worked better together. The cases got darker, and the profiling felt sharper. In the episode “Revelations,” kidnappers took Reid and tortured him. This episode showed the show’s emotional power. Each character had moments to stand out. Fans remember this season as a favorite one.
2. Season 4: Peak storytelling
This season is a fan-favorite for its storytelling. With cases like “Normal” and the return of The Reaper, it kept audiences hooked. The balance of personal drama and procedural crime-solving felt perfect. Emily Prentiss and Derek Morgan had standout arcs, and the show felt confident in every episode. This was Criminal Minds at its creative peak.
1. Season 3: The strongest of all
Season 3 takes the crown as the strongest. Despite losing Gideon early, the season gave fans some of the most powerful stories in the series. The “Unsub” cases were chilling, the characters had rich development, and the writing felt sharp.
Season 3 also gave us some of the most haunting episodes that may stand out forever. It perfectly balanced psychological thrills with emotional depth. Fans say it's the best season of Criminal Minds.
Trending
If you want to watch some incredible instances, terrifying antagonists, and characters that made you feel like one of them, definitely watch Criminal Minds. From the dark wit of Season 3 to the emotional end of Season 15 of the show, it has left a lasting impression on television.
Reply
