From Family of Liars to a new island - Where can We Were Liars Season 2 go next?

We Were Liars season 2 can leverage a first season that effortlessly and tragically tore apart the lies of an aristocratic family, as Cadence Sinclair Eastman stitched together the ghastly reality of her own past.

The series concluded on a spooky note: not only did Cadence hallucinate her dead friends, but in a major deviation from the novel, her aunts—the Sinclair sisters—were also depicted experiencing visions of the dead. That artistic choice unlocked the door to still greater possibilities.

Now that the Sinclair universe has been expanded with two books—E. Lockhart's prequel novel, Family of Liars, and the future standalone, We Fell Apart—fans and critics are left speculating: where will We Were Liars season 2 go?

Will it go deeper into the Sinclair family's tradition of denial and dysfunction or move to an entirely new island, a new cast, and a darker tone in a daring anthology-style reworking?

---

Back to Beechwood: Adapting Family of Liars

The most obvious course for We Were Liars season 2 would be to adapt Family of Liars, a prequel book written by E. Lockhart set on Beechwood Island in the summer of 1985. The novel centers on Carrie Sinclair, the eldest of four sisters—Carrie, Penny, Bess, and the deceased Rosemary, who drowned at the age of ten the previous summer.

Narrated in Carrie's fallible voice, Family of Liars delves into the psychological consequences of Rosemary's demise, Carrie's codeine addiction, and a complex network of cataclysmic secrets reflective of the fate of the next generation. Haunted by Rosemary's ghost—literally—Carrie is confronted by both a force from beyond the grave and a symbolic urging to individuate.

The season 1 finale of the show, where Carrie is communicating with the ghost of her son Johnny, obviously follows this narrative pattern, thus rendering the prequel a coherent and thematically sound continuation. A Family of Liars adaptation would enable We Were Liars season 2 to hold the psychological tone of the show while upping the emotional depth of its characters.

Carrie's mourning, identity crisis (once she finds out Harris Sinclair is not her biological father), and her self-destructive relationship with a manipulative lad, Pfeff, create a haunting image of a teenager bursting under the weight of expectations.

The themes—looks over reality, privilege, addiction, intergenerational trauma, and the degrading influence of silence—would work really well for viewers of season 1. Additionally, the prequel expands on the Sinclair family's poisonous habits.

It provides audiences with an opportunity to see why the sisters turned out to be the chilly, splintered grown-ups we were introduced to through Cadence's perspective—and how their decisions eventually led to the tragedy that played out years later.

With Family of Liars already out, full of storytelling potential, and directly connected to the season 1 epilogue, this direction offers clean continuity and emotional reward.

---

Exploring a new world: Adapting We Fell Apart

Alternatively, We Were Liars season 2 might decide to grow instead of carry on—adapting We Fell Apart, Lockhart's next standalone novel within the same world. Out in November 2025, the novel moves the location to Hidden Beach, a nearby island opposite Beechwood, over the same legendary Summer Fifteen time frame.

This time, the tale is about Matilda, a teenage girl who's asked by her reclusive, estranged father to spend the summer at his enigmatic beachside mansion. When she gets there, he's disappeared, leaving behind three strangers: an estranged brother, a troubled child star with a dark past, and a volatile outsider.

As Matilda attempts to decipher her father's secrets and self, she becomes trapped in a realm of psychological thrills, romantic intrigue, and gothic rot.

Adapting We Fell Apart would move We Were Liars season 2 into anthology territory, dealing with the same emotional issues—privilege, legacy, lying, and inner weakness—but with completely different characters and an unsettling, more stylized atmosphere. The Haunting of Hill House to Bly Manor vibes.

This risky step would enable the show to venture into various forms of storytelling, attracting fresh audiences and testing structure and aesthetics. It would also mirror Lockhart's expanding thematic universe, wherein secrets and emotional breakdowns are not unique to the Sinclair clan.

But this route is not without risk. Diverging from Cadence and the Sinclairs might lose emotionally invested fans of the initial narrative, particularly as season 1's finale hinted at further delving into the sisters. The lack of connective tissue may be disorienting, unless the standalone finds clever means of incorporating references or echoes of Beechwood lore.

---

So what's the future for We Were Liars season 2?

Though both possibilities are full of narrative possibilities, all signs indicate Family of Liars as the next installment of the Sinclair saga. The foundation has already been set, both through Lockhart's prequel, which has been published, and the last episode of the show. The Sinclair sisters were provided with depth, ghostly apparitions, and unsatisfactory emotional trajectories that must be opened up.

Returning to Beechwood Island for We Were Liars season 2 with a new perspective on the past would not only enrich the mythology but also reaffirm the show's most unsettling lesson: the lies we are born into are just as destructive as those we fabricate.

Nevertheless, We Fell Apart is on the horizon as a promising chance to open up the world even more. Whether it's season 3, a spin-off series, or the beginning of an anthology series, Lockhart's world has evidently outgrown one family's narrative.

In the meantime, fans can look forward to We Were Liars season 2 facing the specters of 1985, through Carrie Sinclair's shattered memories, hidden truths, and the deep-seated wounds that defined a generation way before Cadence ever dared to ask the right questions.

---

We Were Liars is available on Prime Video to watch now.

Stay tuned for more updates about We Were Liars season 2!

Also Read: We Were Liars fans deserve these 10 mystery-filled shows in their life