Halloween Baking Championship: How is Maple Grove’s Megan Carroll faring on the show so far?

Megan Carroll, from Maple Grove, got off to a shaky start on Halloween Baking Championship Season 11 and almost got sent home right away. She’s a self-taught baker who sells cookies and sourdough at local farmers' markets. When the show premiered on September 15, 2025, she competed with nine other bakers for the $25,000 prize. Her first challenge was to make desserts inspired by her scariest Halloween nightmares with a fake blood twist, and her chocolate cake with pomegranate curd ended up in the judges’ bottom three.

Megan nearly got eliminated from Halloween Baking Championship, but another contestant gave her a second chance to show what she could do. The season has seven episodes, filmed in a spooky haunted house, with each week getting harder and creepier, and Megan has bounced back since her rough start. Her friendly Midwestern vibe and her “you betcha” sayings make her stand out from the other bakers, most of whom went to fancy culinary schools, proving that determination and heart can be just as important as fancy skills.

What has Megan Carroll’s performance on Halloween Baking Championship been like?

The opening challenge on Halloween Baking Championship required each baker to design a dessert representing a personal Halloween fear. Carroll created a chocolate cake with pomegranate curd and pomegranate-based "blood" for the visual impact. Other entrants choose raspberry, cherry, or citrus flavors for their renditions. Carla Hall, Zac Young, and Stephanie Boswell judged the submissions and put Carroll in the bottom three. A season-specific twist meant these low-scoring bakers faced an immediate "bake for your life" round to avoid elimination.

Carroll's tiramisu during this pressure-filled challenge on Halloween Baking Championship received lukewarm feedback. One judge simply called it "nice," prompting her Minnesota-proud response:

"I'm Minnesota nice."

She prepared to leave the competition, accepting her fate. Then came an unexpected turn. Another contender willingly handed up his seat, allowing Carroll to continue in the tournament. Her emotional response to the gesture was long-lasting. The premiere introduced national audiences to Carroll's regional accent and expressions. Her "you betcha" confessionals and Midwestern mannerisms became defining characteristics throughout the episodes. Some Halloween Baking Championship viewers questioned whether the show leaned too heavily into stereotypes, while others appreciated what they saw as genuine representation. A regular customer at Carroll's Plymouth farmers market stand told the Star Tribune that her television persona matches reality.

"Megan comes off in the show exactly how she comes off in real life," the customer observed.

This authenticity distinguishes her from contestants who might adjust their personalities for cameras. Carroll sells baked goods and perfume at the same market where her parents once sold sculpted gourds. She never attended culinary school or trained in professional kitchens. Instead, she learned techniques by watching Rachael Ray and Martha Stewart on television, building skills through observation and practice. After surviving her first-week scare, Carroll demonstrated noticeable growth in later episodes. She impressed judges with a pâte à choux pecan cream pie during one challenge, earning recognition as the second-best dessert that day. The strong showing secured her advancement to the next round.

Her trajectory differs sharply from competitors who studied under French pastry chefs or worked in established bakeries. Carroll relies on self-taught abilities developed through years of market sales and home experimentation. This background creates both advantages and limitations as challenges grow more complex.

Halloween Baking Championship continues, highlighting her Midwestern characteristics through additional "you betcha" moments and regional references. Carroll balances creative approaches with technical execution under strict time constraints, testing whether her unconventional training can match formally educated bakers.

How will she fare on the challenges that lie ahead?

As the competition progresses on Halloween Baking Championship, Carroll must maintain the improvement she's shown since her difficult premiere. Her emotional resilience will prove crucial as eliminations intensify and challenges demand greater technical precision.

The question remains whether her self-taught foundation can sustain her through increasingly demanding Halloween-themed tasks against professionally trained opponents. Her journey from near elimination to competitive contender on Halloween Baking Championship makes her one of the season's most compelling stories to follow.

Trending

Halloween Baking Championship Season 11 streams on Food Network, with new episodes available starting September 15, 2025.

×

Was this article helpful?

Thank You for feedback