'%20x='0'%20y='0'%20height='100%25'%20width='100%25'%20%0A%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20xlink%3Ahref=''%3E%3C/image%3E%3C/svg%3E)
The 25-year-old dynamo from Denton, Texas, Breanna Nix, made a triumphant comeback to the American Idol stage during Disney Night Part 2 with a passionate rendition of The Parent Trap's "This Will Be (An Everlasting Love)." In an attempt to earn a place in the Top 3, her energetic stage presence and self-assured singing infused a lively edge into the timeless song.
The judges gave Breanna mediocre reviews despite her charisma and vocal performance. They acknowledged her potential while also pointing out areas needing improvement, particularly in the early portions of her performance. Critiques are becoming harsher as the competition intensifies, and even exceptional vocalists like Breanna aren't exempt.
Many fans on the internet, however, took issue with the judges' comments. Social media was swiftly used by viewers to criticize the panel for being overly harsh and even biased against Breanna. Some complained that the judges' remarks felt like an attempt to disqualify her from the competition, while others asserted that she has consistently demonstrated strength and deserved greater recognition.
An American Idol viewer commented on X,
"#americanidol Why do they hate Breanna? When she got in to top Luke so obviously gave the raised eyebrow 2 Carrie. Her voice is great! Even Amer Idol keeps daily tweeting bout John & pushing him.They've been trying 2 get rid of her from start. Stop trying 2 throw competition"
"BREANNA GETS ALL MY VOTES! Only woman left up against a lot of mediocre men, and the judges want to criticize her and not the ones who actually need the criticism. F*ck right off. #americanidol," a tweet read.
Another fan wrote,
"What are these judges talking about? Breanna was great. They say this to her and praise some of the ones they do. Please. #AmericanIdol."
Other viewers called out judges after Breanna made it to the Top 3 of American Idol Season 23.
"Absolutely fantastic Breanna! Where’s the judges standing now? Yeah didn’t think they would! Breanna is in the Finale! 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻 #AmericanIdol"
"#americanidol I‘m not sure if the judges or producers R reading the live tweets or if they just finally couldn't keep insulting her but FINALLY the judges gave Breanna her due. Maybe Lin Manuel changed their minds. A little late Carrie," another X user shared.
"You were a little bit unsure" — American Idol judge Carrie Underwood commented on Breanna's rendition of This Will Be
On Disney Night Part 2 of American Idol Season 23, Breanna Nix performed the song "This Will Be (An Everlasting Love)" from The Parent Trap. Although the 25-year-old competitor from Denton, Texas, brought her trademark enthusiasm to the stage, the judges weren't quite impressed with her performance.
"The first half I felt like you were a little bit unsure. Your next performance, just have fun," Carrie Underwood advised.
Despite all the criticism from the judges, Breanna Nix secured her place in the finale after America expressed their support through their votes.
Trending
American Idol Season 23 finale will air on ABC on May 18 at 8/7c.
Reply
