Fans of The Amazing Race were pleasantly surprised during the April 30, 2025, episode when Jonathan displayed uncharacteristic calmness while competing with partner Ana in Naples, Italy. Social media lit up with commentary about this noticeable shift in his demeanor.
Throughout Season 37, audiences have grown accustomed to Jonathan's tense outbursts during high-pressure challenges, particularly directed at Ana. The duo's relationship dynamic has become a controversial talking point among viewers, with many expressing frustration at Jonathan's previous treatment of his teammate.
However, this Italian adventure showcased a more supportive partnership as they tackled mozzarella braiding, grocery shopping, and pizza-making challenges.
The apparent personality transformation sparked widespread discussion, though preview clips for next week's episode suggest the improvement might be short-lived, leaving fans divided about whether this represents genuine growth or merely a temporary reprieve from their typically strained interactions.
The Amazing Race fans react to Jonathan’s treatment of Ana
The Amazing Race community's response to Jonathan's behavior reflects clear divisions among viewers.
On one side stand those celebrating the calmer, more supportive version of Jonathan seen in Naples. These fans expressed relief at the absence of his typical critical comments toward Ana, appreciating moments where he encouraged his partner rather than assigning blame.
“Okay Jonathan acting like he has some sense tonight” one fan posted (via X).
“Jonathan not complaining for once and supporting Ana!? You know what, I’ll take it!!” another fan commented (via X).
“you know what, good for jonathan” a fan said (via X).
More people noticed a change in Jonathan.
“At least Jonathan isn’t blaming Ana for being lost” another fan said (via X).
“Jonathan has had two good legs in a row. But I think that changes next week” a fan commented (via X).
Conversely, a vocal portion of the audience remains skeptical. Some viewers of The Amazing Race expressed annoyance at Jonathan and Ana claiming first place, suggesting they hadn't forgiven his previous behavior. Others pointed to preview clips showing a return to his abrasive manner next week, reinforcing their negative perception.
“I am so annoyed that Jonathan and Ana won 1st place this leg. More so Jonathan than Ana” a fan said (via X).
“Once again, #AmazingRace producers, there's no need to show Jonathan being a jerk to Ana in the previews. Everyone just assumes it will happen in an episode unless told otherwise.” another fan posted (via X).
“I am so glad I have a mute button because Jonathan the Jackass had WAY too much screen time this episode. I am so annoyed I have to watch another week of him treating Ana like sh-t.” a fan commented (via X).
“So Jonathan is back to being a jerk again next week. Why am I not surprised” another fan said (via X).
This polarization highlights how reality TV personalities can develop reputations that become difficult to shake. For Jonathan, a single well-behaved episode hasn't erased weeks of controversial interactions that The Amazing Race viewers have witnessed throughout the season.
What happened in this episode of The Amazing Race?
The Naples leg of The Amazing Race offered Jonathan and Ana their moment to shine as a functional team. The episode featured various challenges steeped in Italian tradition, culminating in a pizza-making task that perfectly suited Ana's background.
Her experience working at Domino's for two years proved invaluable as she executed a perfect Neapolitan pizza on her first attempt. This expertise propelled the pair from third place to first place, securing them the leg victory.
Throughout these challenges, Jonathan maintained an unusually supportive attitude. Where viewers expected complaints or blame-shifting during navigation difficulties, they instead saw patience. This stark contrast to his previous behavior caught attention almost as much as their competitive success.
Despite the positive shift in this episode of The Amazing Race, the preview for next week suggests Jonathan may revert to his former ways. This has prompted discussions about whether reality TV contestants can meaningfully change under intense competitive pressure.
The non-elimination twist that saved Hans and Holden means all teams continue to the next round, ensuring viewers will have another opportunity to observe Jonathan and Ana's partnership dynamics.
If Jonathan maintains his improved attitude, it could redeem his reputation among fans. If not, this episode may be remembered as an anomaly in an otherwise controversial season performance.
Regardless of what happens next, this episode demonstrated that The Amazing Race remains compelling not just for its global challenges but for the human stories of growth, conflict, and partnership that unfold under extraordinary circumstances. As teams race toward the finale, personalities and relationships continue to fascinate viewers just as much as the competition itself.
The Amazing Race airs Wednesdays at 9/8c on CBS and streams the next day on Paramount+.