Here's why fans despise the most hated episode of How I Met Your Mother

How I Met Your Mother's laughter, heartbreak, and iconic moments captured over nine seasons came crashing down when the show ended, something that remains challenging for fans to accept even today.

The series finale, ‘Last Forever: Part Two,’ not only splits opinions but also creates a united fan base laden with disappointment. More than ten years since then, it still holds the record for the worst-rated episode in the history of the show on IMDb. What makes this last chapter so widely disliked?

The problem doesn’t simply stem from it being overly emotional but rather from the method of delivering that emotion. After building up the story surrounding ‘the mother,’ fans were highly anticipating the conclusion and were instead greeted with a rushed montage consisting of breakups, death, and major life changes throughout the years. It felt like the showrunners disregarded character growth for a twist that no longer suited the story.

The finale of How I Met Your Mother erased years of character development

Perhaps the most discussed issue is the way the finale handled its characters. Ted, after meeting Tracy—the woman he had been narrating to his kids for nine seasons—loses her to an unspecified illness. Her death is depicted in a swift flash-forward, and the narrative does not conclude as an homage to her but rather as a pretext for Ted to recommence with Robin.

Barney and Robin’s marriage, which had been the main focus for the last season, disintegrates in a matter of minutes of screen time. Barney, who had advanced so far, dramatically reverts to his earlier season self—a shallow womanizer. His redemption comes too abruptly, in the shape of a daughter, but it feels far too little and far too late. Once the group’s heart, Marshall and Lily, are now relegated to the periphery. Viewers felt as though writers had chosen to disregard everything the series had set up to render an ending they had schemed for years.

Fans wanted closure — not a shock twist

The finale would have probably received a better reception had it strived for emotional catharsis instead of shock. Cristin Milioti’s portrayal of Tracy was adored, and fans would appreciate her character if she had been given proper time, depth, and a genuine farewell.

But her character didn’t even get that treatment. She was reduced to a plot device — a means for Ted to get back to Robin, who was already feeling like an ex for the love story they shared.

Trending

What set How I Met Your Mother apart was its stunningly raw emotionality, multidimensional characters, and long-term rewards. The finale, however, bypassed years of emotional investment, many fans returning to a surreal environment where their favorite characters had been violently replaced. Instead of a well-deserved conclusion, the show offered what felt like a convoluted narrative. And somehow, that’s the aspect that continues to hurt the most.

Over a decade later, “Last Forever: Part Two” still serves as a lesson in the significance of endings. Execute them the wrong way, and everything before gets overshadowed.

×

Was this article helpful?

Thank You for feedback