His & Hers ending: Was Alice justified? Why the mother-daughter twist is dividing fans

A still from the show (Image via Netflix)
A still from the show (Image via Netflix)

His & Hers has taken Netflix by storm, becoming the top-streamed show in 57 countries with just 24 hours of its release. The mini-series is based on a popular novel by Alice Feeney and features Jon Bernthal and Tessa Thompson as the main leads. However, the spotlight of this twisted thriller is taken away from the main cast to a character whose story arc appears to be little more than a narrative bridge in His & Hers.

The final twenty minutes of His & Hers have left viewers shocked, gagged, and talking about it all over the internet. The His and Hers Netflix show delivers a shocking revelation that nobody could have predicted or anticipated based on the slow-building premise. Just when viewers think they have figured out who killed Rachel Hopkins in the small city of Dahlonega, the series pulls off one of the most unexpected twists in recent television history.

The His and Hers ending has sparked unprecedented debates online, with viewers divided about whether the actual killer's actions were justified or absolutely evil.

Warning: This article contains significant spoilers and presents diverse viewpoints on the ending.


The twist no one saw coming on His & Hers

youtube-cover

The series spends five episodes making the audience suspect every character behind the murder. Detective Jack Harper had an affair with the victim, and his estranged wife, Anna Andrews, was near the crime scene. Even Catherine Kelly, working in disguise as news anchor Lexy Jones, seemed like the perfect revenge-seeking killer.

But the His & Hers finale crushes all theories under the weight of shocking revelations. The real murderer turns out to be Alice, Anna's mother, who everyone believed was dealing with dementia. She faked her perplexed behavior with a lot of conviction, serving cooked eggs with shells and serving hot water to Detective Priya instead of tea. Sometimes she was even found wandering the streets with no clothes. All of it was an act to cover up a bigger plan she had in mind to do the murders in His & Hers.


Why did Alice become a killer?

youtube-cover

The motivation behind Alice's crimes is both heartbreaking and shocking. While Anna was away grieving her baby daughter's demise, Alice found old videotapes in Anna's bedroom and one of them had Anna's 16th birthday party revealed a shocking secret. Rachel, Helen, and Zoe watch Anna being sexually assaulted by some men while they sing a birthday song to mock her during the act.

Anna had buried this trauma so intensely that she could not remember it. But Alics watched the barbaric attack on the old tape. The discovery broke something inside her, and she decided that these women would have to pay for their sins and for hurting her daughter.


How Alice got away with murder in His and Hers?

Alice employed her experience as a house cleaner to her advantage. She still had keys to several homes in the city. This allowed her to enter the homes of the victims without anyone suspecting. She killed Rachel first, right after Rachel's secret encounter with Jack, and then went on to kill Zoe and Helen on the anniversary of her granddaughter Charlotte's death.

The His and Hers Netflix show reveals how Alice carefully planted evidence at Catherine's lake home to frame her for all the murders. The plan almost worked in her favour.


Is a mother's love an excuse for committing a crime?

This is where the His & Hers debate evolves into a rabbit hole. The director William Oldroyd calls the story a "love letter" to maternal devotion. He believes Alice's actions brought justice for a crime that was never addressed. Tessa Thompson, who portrays the role of Anna, agrees that mothers are capable of unfathomable acts to protect their kids.

Many audiences support Alice and her actions as they feel that the legal system failed decades ago. These women never faced consequences for their actions and brutality. Alice simply did what needed to be done. Some audiences view her as a hero who avenges unspeakable violence.


The other side of the story for some viewers

Several critics and fans of His and Hers do not stand by the same viewpoint. They point out that Alice murdered three people without giving Anna any say on the matter. Helena nd Zoe might have been bystanders to the case, but did they deserve death in His & Hers?

Alice also framed an innocent woman, Catherine, who Priya executed for crimes she did not commit. The His and Hers ending explained shows that Alice's vigilante justice crossed many moral lines. In the name of confession, she accidentally traumatized her daughter by compelling her to relive buried, tragic memories. She took away Anna's agency to decide how to handle her own trauma.


Anna's silence speaks volumes in His and Hers ending

His & Hers ends with a controversial scene. Anna reads her mother's confession letter one year after the killings. She learns the whole truth about who really killed Rachel, Zoe, and Helen. Then she looks at Alice and gives a contented smile.

That smile indicated Anna had decided to protect her mother and wouldn't turn Alice in to the police. This makes Anna an accomplice to the crime, and this His and Hers concluding moment asks audiences a difficult question: Does love justify covering up brutal crimes?


Why can fans of His and Hers not stop talking about it?

Social media has exploded with extreme reactions to the His and Hers Netflix ending. One fan wrote that the twist left them.

"frozen, staring at the screen, replaying each scene."

Another called it

"triumphant in some crazy, messed-up way."

However, others find the His & Hers ending ethically wrong and disturbing.


His & Hers shocks with Alice, Anna's mom, as the secret killer avenging her daughter's past assault, leading to heated debates on whether a mother's love excuses murder and cover-ups. The His and Hers ending will keep fans debating for months about revenge, justice, and the limits of maternal love.

Edited by Zainab Shaikh