Dexter: Resurrection star Michael C. Hall reveals why they had to make the new show despite the divisive ending of the previous one

Dexter: Resurrection is back from the dead, literally. The new sequel series to Dexter: New Blood brings Michael C. Hall’s iconic serial killer back for another chapter, just three years after the character was seemingly killed off. But why resurrect a show that had not one, but two controversial finales?

According to Hall, the answer lies in second chances, both for Dexter Morgan and for the franchise itself.

“I thought he was dead too,” Hall said in a new interview with ScreenRant.

“And I think Dexter did too.”

But as he explained, the idea of survival started to feel like an opportunity, not just for plot convenience, but for emotional depth.

“If it didn’t kill him, what would that look like? How would that change his world?”

Dexter: Resurrection premieres July 11 on Paramount+ with Showtime, and this time, it’s about more than just killing by the code. Hall calls this Dexter “reborn,” and promises a storyline that digs deeper into his humanity, his connection to Harrison, and his need to finally put down the weight of the life he's been dragging around. The result? A second chance that just might work.

Balancing closure and continuation in Dexter’s storyline

Michael C. Hall isn’t pretending this decision was easy. After all, Dexter: New Blood was billed as the true ending. But in his own words, the character’s return became an “increasingly interesting proposition.”

“Some time passed. He wasn't shot in the head. The possibility always remained that that gunshot didn't kill him, even though it seemed definitive… It felt like a crazy proposition. Are we going to end it that definitively and then say, actually no, he's still alive?”

He admits to having misgivings at first. But the key, Hall says, was making sure it wasn’t just a reversal; it had to mean something.

“The key for me to making it feel worthwhile is he's not just still alive, [but] he's reborn or has a genuine second chance at life. One that sees him able to put down a lot of what he's been dragging around.”

That includes Dexter’s emotional baggage, his legacy of collateral damage, and, most of all, his complicated relationship with Harrison. The show will explore all of that in Dexter: Resurrection, not as a rehash, but as new ground.

Why Dexter: Resurrection had to retcon the ending of New Blood

The finale of Dexter: New Blood divided fans yet again. After eight years of waiting for redemption, Dexter ended up dying at the hands of his own son, a dark, poetic finish that some called brave, while others called unnecessary.

Dexter: Resurrection rewrites that ending by revealing he survived. The groundwork was quietly laid in Dexter: Original Sin, a prequel that aired in 2024. In the opening scene, Dexter is shown being rushed to a hospital, suggesting that Harrison’s gunshot wasn’t fatal after all.

Yes, it’s a retcon. But one that comes with a purpose.

“What would that look like?” Hall asked rhetorically. “How would it change his approach to being alive, being given a second chance like that?”

If New Blood showed a man cornered by his past, Dexter: Resurrection shows a man trying to do something with what little future he might have left.

Dexter’s new environment sets the stage for emotional and moral rebirth

Dexter: Resurrection doesn’t just bring the character back; it gives him an entirely new stage. This time, Dexter moves to New York City, a setting that mirrors the energy and danger of his old life in Miami.

That change of environment could be crucial. New Blood intentionally isolated Dexter in a small town, surrounded by snow and secrets. Resurrection throws him back into the noise, into temptation, and into a world where he must again ask himself: Can I live by the code and still be a father? A man?

“[He’s] able to reclaim himself in a more kind of streamlined, vital way as a killer,” Hall explains, “but also experience a sort of undeniable connection to his human side through a recommitment to his son.”

It’s a sharp pivot. Less hiding, more healing. If Dexter fails again, this might truly be the last time.

So, is Dexter: Resurrection going to be worth it?

There’s no denying that Dexter: Resurrection is a risky move. Reviving a character that’s already died twice (once metaphorically, once literally) invites scrutiny. But what makes this revival intriguing isn’t shock value. It’s the honesty behind it.

Michael C. Hall isn’t pretending this is business as usual. He knows how it looks. And he’s still choosing to tell this story because this version of Dexter might finally have something to say.

Whether it ends in triumph or tragedy, Dexter: Resurrection is about giving a killer one last chance to figure out who he is and what he’s still capable of.

And for fans? It's a chance to return to a world we’ve never quite been able to leave behind.

Trending

Dexter: Resurrection premieres July 11, 2025, on Paramount+ with Showtime.

×

Was this article helpful?

Thank You for feedback