Is Addison Rae in Monster: The Ed Gein Story? Actress’ role in the true crime drama, explored

Yes, Addison Rae stars as Evelyn Hartley in Monster: The Ed Gein Story, which is one of Ryan Murphy's crime anthologies that premiered on October 3, 2025. Her role is that of a missing teenager from 1953, whose on-screen time is limited, but whose acting contribution brings a tragic and horrific feel to the series. Her acting contributes to the horror and fright concerning Ed Gein's life and makes Hartley's still-mysterious disappearance salacious.

The program weaves together dramatized fiction and actual history. Because Evelyn Hartley's case was never solved during her lifetime, Rae's program portrays her exploits in a dramatized context that explores the dark and sinister side of the disappearance.

Her performance provides psychological tension to the program without asserting historical fact, and it remains focused on real-life horror and speculative elements of Gein's life.

---

Addison Rae's role as Evelyn Hartley in Monster: The Ed Gein Story

Evelyn Hartley is the 1953 missing teenager whose case remained unsolved in Monster: The Ed Gein Story, played by Addison Rae. She has some short but powerful works, bringing emotional depth to the dramatized scenario. Her character is used by the series to demonstrate how the world around Gein and his frame of mind can become confused with each other into real crimes, but Gein has nothing to do with anything for any part of Hartley's disappearance.

Her character is an effaced and delicate one that generates tension and sympathy in a population. Although the actual Evelyn Hartley case was never resolved, Rae's readings direct the series to where it delves into the human cost of cold crimes in a world dramatized.

---

The historical Evelyn Hartley case

Evelyn Hartley disappeared as a La Crosse, Wisconsin, babysitter in 1953. Although the investigations were closed, she was never found and questioned by the police on behalf of Ed Gein for her disappearance. The case was never solved, and any scene of Gein's work on camera is not authentic.

The show acknowledges this mixing of fact and dramatization, employing Hartley's character to map the larger psychological backdrop of the period, i.e., fear, suspicion, and rumor of Gein's activities.

---

Fact and fiction in the show

Monster: The Ed Gein Story is a mixture of fact interwoven with fictional dramatization. What are the facts:

1. Ed Gein's grave desecration and murder exploits.
2. His family life and fixation on his mother, Augusta.
3. His psychiatric hospitalization after his arrest in 1957.

Fictionalized or dramatized elements are:

1. Personal encounter of Evelyn Hartley with Gein (for suspense in the narrative).
2. Inner monologues and hallucinations as a depiction of the mind of Gein.

All these imaginative features are designed to drive the narrative forward, but not deviate from the fundamental historical facts.

---

Influence of Addison Rae's role

Addison Rae's character throughout the series is one of understatement but power. Her contact with Evelyn Hartley's character provides emotional depth and emphasizes the series' blending of fact and fiction. Rae is utilized to bring the victims of the time period to life and provide each with a personal investment for viewers in the overall narrative of Gein's crime.

Her performance justifies the show's strategy: sensationalized narrative respectful of the era but extending speculation and psychological exploration of true crime.

---

Techniques psychological and narrative

Symbolic images, inner monologues, and suspenseful action are employed by the show in addressing the disturbed mind of Ed Gein. They are fictionalized techniques, but they are based on investigations into Gein's existence, isolation, and obsession with his mother.

Evelyn Hartley's life, on the other hand, in Rae's rendering of it as an on-screen anchor, provides a vehicle by which audiences are given access to the speculative and affective world of Gein without reference to historical truth.

---

Hence, Addison Rae shows up in Monster: The Ed Gein Story as Evelyn Hartley. Her appearance is short but by no means forgotten, adding a bit of tension and feeling to the series. The series draws on real aspects of Gein's life, his crimes, and his mental state, among them, and mixes them with fiction, relying on fictionalized accounts like Rae's to tap into unsolved cases and human potential.

Monster: The Ed Gein Story demonstrates how crime dramatizations interweave real events with fictionalized stories, and Rae's performance is in keeping with the tone of the show.

Also read: Monster: The Ed Gein Story - Did the serial killer help solve the Ted Bundy case? Details explored