Is All Her Fault a limited series? Here’s what we know about the future of the Peacock thriller

All Her Fault hit Peacock on November 6, 2025, with eight episodes, one season, all ready for a binge.

It is a mystery thriller, and Sarah Snook takes center stage. She is the big draw here. The show is based on Andrea Mara’s novel, and critics are mostly into it, with Snook getting almost all the praise.

In All Her Fault, Marissa Irvine goes to pick up her son, Milo, from his first playdate. She expects a normal afternoon, but instead finds a stranger at the door who swears she has never even heard of Milo. That is when everything falls apart. The kid’s disappearance tears open a mess of family secrets and personal drama.

Suddenly, this picture-perfect Chicago family starts to look a lot less shiny. The series digs into love, control, and how far parents will go for their kids, all with that dark, psychological edge.

Is All Her Fault a limited series?

Yes, All Her Fault is a limited series. Peacock dropped all eight episodes at once, and right now, there aren’t any plans for a second season. The show adapts Andrea Mara’s novel, which tells a complete story in just one season, so you get the whole narrative, start to finish, with no big cliffhangers.

Peacock usually waits to see how a show performs with things like viewership, buzz, and reviews before talking about renewals. But with limited series like this, they almost always wrap everything up in one go. Unless something huge changes or they decide to spin it off with new characters, you shouldn’t expect another season. So far, Peacock hasn’t said anything about renewing it, which fits the “limited series” idea.

Meanwhile, All Her Fault has stirred up all sorts of reactions, but most critics and viewers seem to land somewhere between “pretty good” and “I liked it a lot.” Over on Rotten Tomatoes, it’s sitting at a 79% approval rating from 24 critics, which tells you plenty of people are on board.

The general vibe says people like the sharp, twisty thriller style, and both Sarah Snook and Dakota Fanning get a lot of love for their performances, especially how All Her Fault digs into the pressures working mothers face.

Snook, in particular, stands out. Critics highlight how she nails the raw emotion and vulnerability of Marissa, a mother pushed to the edge. Outlets like The Hollywood Reporter highlight the clever plot turns and the show’s tough look at maternal guilt and paternal pride. Sure, it is not everyone’s pick for the best domestic thriller ever, but it still delivers a solid, unpredictable mystery.

Not everyone is thrilled, though. Some reviewers call out pacing problems and storylines that wander or don’t quite add up. Variety says a few parts drag or get a little over the top, especially where certain characters are concerned. They also mention that some twists feel rushed or don’t really get enough setup.

Time Magazine calls the pacing choppy and some plot twists just plain hard to believe. Over on Reddit, a few viewers complain about the show slipping into soap opera territory, even though they agree Snook gives it her all.

As for the audience, the reaction is positive overall. IMDb has it around 7.4 out of 10, which means most folks enjoy the suspense and strong acting. Fans seem to love the chemistry between the leads and the tense atmosphere. Still, some wish the show had gone a little deeper with its characters instead of focusing so much on the thriller angle.

All Her Fault storyline and renewal hints

All Her Fault wraps up its main story: the mystery of Milo’s disappearance is finally solved. Still, the finale leaves a few character arcs hanging. Marissa and Jenny make it out alive, but their futures are totally up in the air. The show drops hints that their personal and professional lives could go in all sorts of directions now that the kidnapping mess is behind them.

Some secondary characters, Brian, Lia, and Detective Alcaras, have their affairs still pending. There are more questions raised about suspicious deaths and the actual condition of some of these individuals. Alcaras, for instance, is still pondering the issue of a certain death, and that storyline seems to point towards even more sinister secrets if the narrative were to continue. Thus, if Peacock were ever to choose to return the series for a subsequent season, there would be a vast amount of material and content to draw from.

Trending

The primary narrative, which is drawn from the book, is actually concluded in a very good way. According to reports, the makers have been plotting from the beginning for the show to be self-sufficient. In case of a future revival, we might witness Marissa mending her personal and professional life, or Jenny making frantic efforts to restore her career.

But Peacock has not really indicated a strong desire, and right from the outset, they branded it as a limited series.

×

Was this article helpful?

Thank You for feedback