All’s Fair has somehow managed to pull off the impossible. Even with a shocking 0% score on Rotten Tomatoes, Ryan Murphy’s new legal drama starring Kim Kardashian has become the top-streamed show on Hulu and Disney+ right now.So, how did a show the critics called “terrible” end up winning the audience over? The answer might be simpler than expected. It’s flashy, addictive, and full of familiar people that the audience just can’t stop watching.The internet can’t stop watching All’s Fair, even if critics hate itWhen All’s Fair dropped its first three episodes on Hulu, no one expected it to explode the way it did. Within 24 hours, it became the number one show on Hulu and Disney+ globally, hitting the top spot in more than 20 countries, including France, Australia, and Norway. View this post on Instagram Instagram PostThe story centers around three powerful divorce lawyers: Allura Grant (Kim Kardashian), Liberty Ronson (Naomi Watts), and Emerald Greene (Niecy Nash-Betts), who open an all-women law firm to take on some of California’s richest, messiest breakups.Even though critics tore into it, calling it everything from “unwatchable” to “existentially terrible” (as The Guardian’s Lucy Mangan brutally put it), people still hit play.Maybe it’s the cast lineup because let’s be honest, it’s wild. You’ve got Naomi Watts, Niecy Nash-Betts, Sarah Paulson, Glenn Close, and Teyana Taylor all sharing the screen. Or maybe it’s because Ryan Murphy shows, no matter how dramatic, always find a way to go viral.Whatever the reason, All’s Fair has everyone talking, proving once again that internet buzz can overpower critical hate any day.Kim Kardashian’s leap into acting is paying off-at least onlineFor Kim Kardashian, All’s Fair is more than just another TV gig; it’s her biggest acting moment yet. Playing Allura Grant, a sharp and stylish divorce lawyer, she looks right at home in Murphy’s glossy world of chaos. View this post on Instagram Instagram PostTalking to the BBC, Kim said she was drawn to the project because “divorce is such a relatable topic,” something she’s lived through personally. She also admitted she wouldn’t practice family law in real life, adding,“I’m more into criminal justice and reform work.”Kim’s dedication to learning her craft is no joke. She told BBC she came to set “completely prepared,” spending her time by “watching and learning from these women,” who she called “the best acting coaches in the world.” Her co-stars have also praised her professionalism, saying she was never late and always knew her lines.And while critics may not be impressed by her performance, fans seem to be watching purely out of curiosity or because they do genuinely love her. Whatever the motivation, it’s working. The series trailer even became Disney+’s most-watched trailer ever before its release.All’s Fair may not be winning critics over, but it’s definitely winning the streaming game. Despite a disastrous Rotten Tomatoes score, the show’s mix of glamour, drama, and Kim Kardashian power is enough to keep people glued to their screens.Whether viewers love it or hate it, they’re still watching, and that’s exactly what makes the show a surprising success story in 2025’s wild world of TV.Stay tuned to SoapCentral for more.