Law & Order: SVU - How Olivia Benson lost her greatest strength

For more than twenty years, Law & Order: SVU’s Olivia Benson served as the emotional and ethical anchor of the show. Centered by Mariska Hargitay’s enduring portrayal, Benson was not simply a face to the franchise. Rather, she was its soul. The sustenance she provided to emotionally damaged individuals—trauma survivors who needed to be understood and handled with emotional intelligence—makes her both a captivating character and an icon in sociocultural representation of justice.

However, the most recent seasons have elicited a more muted change. The change in role that Benson has experienced as the captain of her unit is one that, although common in law enforcement’s procedural drama landscape, results in losing something that made her stand out: her direct involvement with victims and their stories. What came off as a well-deserved promotion now seems to be slowly distancing her from what actually mattered: her bond with the victims.

With over 25 seasons to its name, the evolution of a show is likely to be inevitable. However, it’s clear now that the very trait that elevated Benson above other crime procedural leads was her frontline advocacy. That element has clearly been diluted. In becoming the boss, she loses access to the raw immediacy that used to define her—and in turn, the show has lost some of its emotional edge.

Leadership comes with distance, and distance comes with a price

Benson's appointment as captain was supposed to be the next chapter in her story. After years of advocacy for survivors, pushing against bureaucratic roadblocks, and helping train younger detectives the role of captain felt deserved. However, with every new promotion comes responsibilities and parts that must be played. Authority powers that are discretionary require more time behind a desk than situated next to an actual survivor.

This leads to Law & Order: SVU creating itself based on a protagonist whose influence came from her physical embodiment. Taking her off the field for any reason, no matter how reasonable the logic might be, breaks that bond. In addition to this criticism, the series tries to avoid these logistical issues by breaking the rules—sending Benson into the field when any real-life captain would be buried under a mountain of reports or squabbling over interdepartmental politics.

For longtime fans of Law & Order: SVU, these throwbacks are warm reminiscences. They expose, however, precisely how brittle her character is. The creators force Benson to inhabit two mutually exclusive roles: the story expects her to play both the commander and confidante but can only serve one at a time.

Empathy in action was the core of Benson’s legacy in Law & Order: SVU

Benson's most outstanding skill was not her badge—but how she attentively listened. She did not just hold interviews with survivors; rather, she actively engaged with them. That form of sensitive involvement was quite often the emotional high point of the episode and helped transform viewers’ perceptions of victimhood and resilience.

Trending

Rather than trying to solve the case as quickly as possible, the priority was on providing aid and acknowledging their existence during deep suffering. But now, that thread is beginning to unravel. Benson, the leader, has to deal with understaffing, departmental rivalry, and red tape fallout. These issues are all too real for someone in her shoes, but they often pull her away from the pieces of her life that used to bring her joy.

She begins outsourcing things she used to enjoy doing as while other characters step up to take on fieldwork roles as ‘fill-ins’, there is no substitution for the impact that Benson brought: not due to failures of acting or writing, but because Law & Order: SVU was at its strongest when she served as their emotional anchor.

×

Was this article helpful?

Thank You for feedback