The Love Is Blind Season 9 reunion on October 29 was less “closure” and more “emotional dodgeball.” Old arguments bounced back fast, and poor Nick Amato was stuck in the middle. Turns out, he told two different women, Kait Nemunaitis and Annie Lancaster, the same lovey-dovey lines in the pods, like he was copy-pasting feelings.Once everyone saw the footage from Love Is Blind, things got messy fast. Nick tried to say sorry, but Annie brushed it off kindly while Kait looked ready to file his apology under “acting practice.” The whole thing reminded everyone why falling in love on a timer might be the most chaotic science experiment Netflix has ever funded.Love Is Blind’s Nick explains his behaviour on the show View this post on Instagram Instagram PostNick faced criticism for delivering nearly identical romantic speeches to both Kait and Annie while dating them in separate pods on Love Is Blind. The repetitive nature of his declarations raised red flags among viewers and cast members alike.Kait called out the pattern directly during the reunion. She suggested Nick's words felt scripted rather than heartfelt:"It felt like Nick went into ChatGPT and looked up pickup lines for how to get a girl to fall for you." The accusation of love-bombing implied Nick overwhelmed both women with excessive affection to manipulate their feelings. This tactic can create artificial intimacy quickly, which critics say undermines the experiment's core premise. Nick acknowledged the criticism and apologized to both women for his approach. However, his contrition received mixed reactions from the two people he hurt. Kait rejected Nick's apology outright. She called it "performative," suggesting he only apologized because cameras were rolling. Her skepticism reflected deeper concerns about whether Nick ever took their connection seriously.The harsh dismissal indicated Kait felt genuinely misled by Nick's behavior in the Love Is Blind pods. She clearly believed his romantic overtures were calculated moves rather than authentic expressions. Annie took the opposite stance despite being Nick's actual fiancée. She defended him during the reunion, insisting his intentions were "genuine" throughout their relationship. View this post on Instagram Instagram PostHer support seemed surprising given that Nick broke up with her before their wedding day. Annie admitted that trust issues plagued their engagement, with her constantly questioning whether Nick loved her as much as she loved him. Looking back, Annie conceded they were forcing something that wasn't meant to work. Still, she maintained that Nick wasn't intentionally manipulative.Nick and Annie's relationship crumbled under the weight of Annie's insecurity about his commitment. He ultimately ended the engagement, telling her he was unhappy and didn't want to marry. The two now maintain "friendly" terms according to reunion updates. Annie has moved on to a new relationship, while Nick remains single. Kait moved forward by dating Brenden Guthrie after filming wrapped. She acknowledged that post-show dating among cast members got "messy" with everyone involved with each other.What does this reveal about pod dynamics? View this post on Instagram Instagram PostNick's situation exposes potential pitfalls of the Love Is Blind format. The pressure to form quick connections may encourage contestants to rely on practiced lines rather than organic conversation.When multiple people receive the same speeches, it undermines the "unique connection" narrative that drives engagements. Authenticity becomes impossible to verify when participants can't see each other's interactions with others. Whether Nick consciously manipulated anyone or simply fell into repetitive patterns under pressure remains debatable. What is clear is that his approach damaged trust with both women, yielding vastly different reactions that reflected their individual experiences with him.The Love Is Blind reunion is now streaming on Netflix.