Matlock Season 2 is full of big twists, but none of them are ones you might think you could expect. What began as a warm legal drama about Madeline “Matty” Matlock and her undercover antics is going to take a darker turn this time. Those characters who used to feel safe and stable now appear to have a lot of secrets.
The biggest shock? Edwin Kingston, played by Sam Anderson. He has always been a caring and helpful husband, but the new trailer and early hints reveal otherwise. Edwin may not be the good guy that we all believed he was.
This shift does not pertain to a single character. It disrupts Matlock’s entire narrative, leaving the audience to doubt the notion of trust, family relations, and hidden motives. The courtroom drama now possesses a sharper edge, and viewers are anxious to know what Edwin is really up to.
The twist in Matlock Season 2 trailer
The new Matlock Season 2 trailer drops a very discreet but very abrupt shock: it appears that Edwin is not so kind and innocent as he initially appeared in the previous season. The flash cuts reveal him staring at length, talking at odd points, and acting in a somewhat overcautious manner.
Those who viewed Edwin as Madeline’s sweet and supportive husband now have reasons to question him. The Matlock Season 2 trailer ingeniously uses his warmth to make it seem like it might be an act. It is a clever gimmick for a show that enjoys keeping the viewers guessing between belief and distrust.
Supposing Edwin has a dark side, it increases the stakes for Matty. Matlock Season 2 would be a courtroom experience that would be more personal and dramatic, with Matty facing a potential villain within her own family.
Showrunner Jennie Snyder Urman teases the fallout between Matty and Edwin in Matlock Season 2

Showrunner Jennie Snyder Urman has remarked that the major choices in the Matlock Season 1 finale will rattle Matty and Edwin's marriage, and the impacts will not pass slowly. The enigma, which appeared to have been resolved at the end, in fact hurt a lot of feelings. Urman gives some hints that Matlock Season 2 may explore that emotional mess: anticipate an exchange of harsh words, broken faith, and a long marriage put to the test.
Urman mentioned to TVLine:
“I mean, it’s a 50-year marriage, right? So they have to figure it out, and that’s what I’m interested in….But, how do you solve something in a long-term marriage when you say, ‘I want X and I want Y’ and they definitely don’t want X? Like, what happens? It’s the same thing as in a legal case when you get to a negotiable and you’re each non-negotiable. You still have to negotiate. So I’m interested in seeing how they get through that and what it leads to. [It] comes with things that cost Maddie, too, because you have to give things up in negotiations.”
This is important since Edwin is not just another background character. He has been Matty's anchor, the calm to her trial fire. If their relationship begins to break, Matty will have so much to lose. Any victory or defeat in the court will be even more intense as her personal life hangs by a thread.
Another theme that the cast and crew have mentioned the show wants to explore is: age, love, and lasting relationships. Having Edwin as a point of contention allows Matlock to explore those themes and makes the legal storyline enjoyable.
What this means for Season 2
Reducing a loved one to a villain is a clichéd TV trick, though it works well when intended to enhance a character instead of trying to pass off a twist. In Matlock Season 2, the possibility of Edwin turning dark makes his previous benevolence more complicated.
The viewers begin to look back and contemplate whether these caring moments were sincere or were hiding something. It depicts the coexistence of love and guilt.
This twist also increases the stress on Alfie and the decisions that Matty makes at the law firm. Matty might need to choose between justice and family. Matty has to choose between justice and family. If Edwin is involved, Julian’s pure image, Olympia’s views of wrong and right, and the trust in the firm are all in question.
Above all, it enhances the combination of weekly cases and continuous drama in the show. When the threat is within Matty’s home, then every case becomes personal.
For more such insights on Matlock Season 2, keep following SoapCentral.