When one first hears the term "Ed Gein babysit kids," it reads like something out of a sick horror movie script, and that's where it should stay. This charge has been leveled across the years, especially since the series Monster: The Ed Gein Story.
Was there ever actually any merit in this rumor? The answer is no. While Gein did serve as a handyman in Plainfield, Wisconsin, there is no solid evidence that he ever babysat.
Police records, historical evidence, and verified biographies all reveal that Ed Gein lived a reclusive, socially isolated life. The fictional aspects of the Netflix series Monster: The Ed Gein Story are added to humanize and dramatize him, but all of those scenes, such as the babysitting anecdote, are pure fiction.
The actual Ed Gein: A retiring handyman, not a babysitter
Ed Gein performed odd jobs for neighbors in his tiny hometown, fixing fences, mending tools, and assisting occasionally with chores. He was known as a reserved and a little strange handyman. There is, however, no historical account, police affidavit, or corroborated report of him ever being asked to babysit children.
The Netflix series Monster: The Ed Gein Story might suggest otherwise, but this portrayal stretches creative liberty. In reality, Gein’s contact with neighbors was limited to practical, impersonal tasks, not nurturing roles or childcare.
Where the babysitting rumor came from
And where did the rumor that "Ed Gein babysat children" even come from? The misunderstanding probably arises from a single past Biography.com article that referred to Gein as "a handyman and babysitter." But this is seemingly an unsubstantiated assertion, one that no other credible source replicates.
None of the official sources mentions Gein babysitting children. They all, however, point towards his reclusive nature and increasing seclusion after his mother's death. For someone who kept his social interactions at bay, the chances of his being invited into people's homes to babysit children were extremely bleak.
Hollywood's role in reinventing the story
The legend that Ed Gein babysat children took hold partly because it is too neatly aligned with the psychological horror template that directors adore. Monster: The Ed Gein Story employs this dramatized aspect to illustrate how an unassuming-looking man might conceal ghastly things.
As established by People.com and Time Magazine's report, these scenes were deliberately dramatized with a view to shock. Gein's actual life, although macabre, did not feature babysitting, only isolation, grave digging, and two established killings.
Ed Gein's true crimes and confirmed facts
Beyond the legend, the actual tale is horrifying enough. Ed Gein murdered two women, Mary Hogan in 1954 and Bernice Worden in 1957. Human remains, body-part furniture, and victim-skin trophies were discovered by police at his farm during their investigation.
None of Gein's victims were children, and no credible evidence links Gein to any babysitting activities or missing children. In short, the claim that Ed Gein babysat children is new folklore at its best, to be sure, but without historical facts.
Why the babysitter myth endures
The rumor about Ed Gein babysitting children endures because it touches on something profoundly psychological, the terror that evil might reside in someone quite unremarkable. Tales like this send shivers down horror enthusiasts' spines and true crime buffs', but in the process, distort history.
The reality is that Ed Gein was socially awkward, emotionally naive, and incapable of sustaining normal human relationships. He wasn't trustworthy enough to be left with children; he wasn't trustworthy enough to be left to talk.
The actual Ed Gein was no friendly neighbour; he was a reclusive, troubled man whose ghastly acts shocked America in 1957. The next time you hear someone claim Ed Gein babysat kids, remember, it's just one more eerie legend born out of fact and fiction regarding one of history's creepiest figures.