Netflix’s Twilight tv adaptation needs to overcome a major obstacle for show’s success, details explored in-depth

Netflix is expanding its animated TV slate with its new Twilight rendition. But the show may have an unavoidable creative problem, and it all centers on Edward Cullen. The 2000s nostalgia is in full swing as the first Twilight novel approaches its 25th anniversary.

In this very significant time, the franchise has found new life online, and Netflix is zooming in on this resurgence. This time, the streamer is adapting Midnight Sun, Stephenie Meyer’s 2020 retelling of the story from Edward’s perspective.

---

Netflix’s Twilight TV adaptation may face a major creative challenge for the show’s success

Midnight Sun depends on Edward’s inner world

Unlike earlier adaptations, where the story was narrated from Bella Swan’s perspective, Midnight Sun filters everything through Edward’s thoughts. The events remain the same. The show will be different in terms of format, standing apart from live-action renditions. This creative shift signals a readjustment of tone and presentation.

While that opens up creative freedom, it also brings a major storytelling challenge to the surface. Midnight Sun unfolds almost entirely inside Edward’s head. If one takes away his inner thoughts, the story becomes redundant.

Most of the events mirror the story beat for beat, except for a few new additions. The earlier Twilight film series was careful about narration. Bella’s voiceover appeared only when it served the scene, and then the usual actions followed.

That restraint helped the movies avoid feeling heavy-handed and feeling like the tale unfolded inside Bella’s head. Overusing internal narration can feel awkward or overly explanatory. In Midnight Sun, however, there is no way around it.

Secondly, Edward’s behavior depends on a context that never appears in dialogue. His attraction towards Bella is not just romantic desire alone. Her blood overwhelms his senses and shuts down his rational thinking. These moments are never spoken aloud but unfold internally.

---

Bella's role in the story

Bella is the only human Edward cannot read, and this silence unsettles him. This confusion draws him closer to Bella but also increases his suffocating anxiety. Without access to his perspective, that tension disappears.

His decision not to turn Bella into a vampire initially also needs a solid explanation. In Midnight Sun, Edward despises his own existence and views vampirism as a curse rather than a gift.

His self-criticism and loathing for a monstrous existence were loud. That mindset explains why he cannot imagine passing that fate on to Bella. Without proper narration, the show may not be able to aptly catch these deeper layers.

---

Telepathy and animation change the rules

Edward’s inner world determines his reaction and interactions within the family. Much of their communication happens through telepathy. He reads their thoughts and returns his with gestures.

Edward and Alice often complete entire conversations without using a single verbal utterance. He understands her visions because he can see her thoughts forming.

Several major plot points rely on this ability, and this ability becomes crucial for the story as well. Cullens often debate on things without speaking, and Edward learns that Jasper and Rosalie want Bella dead after the car accident by reading their thoughts.

These moments essentially decide how Edward will react and how the story will unfold. During the climax, Edward tracks danger by seeing through his family’s minds.

Because of this, Netflix cannot downplay narration or telepathy. Both are central to Midnight Sun’s identity. Treating them as flaws to minimize would strip the adaptation of its purpose.

However, the animation may still be the show’s biggest advantage. The animated format can lead Edward’s thoughts to be externalized in other creative ways. His intrusive fantasies can be brought to the screen through creative visuals.

It is beyond doubt that this will be an interesting new way of visualising a known story. Telepathic exchanges can feel natural instead of stiff. The format can also embrace the stranger elements the films avoided.

---

The previous film franchise consisted of 6 films in total that spanned across the 2000s and 2010s.

• Twilight (2008)
• The Twilight Saga: New Moon (2009)
• The Twilight Saga: Eclipse (2010)
• The Twilight Saga: Breaking Dawn, Part 1 (2011)
• The Twilight Saga: Breaking Dawn, Part 2 (2012)